Chapters 9 - 14: Mate, Sexual Selection, and Parental Care Flashcards
What is the origin of the female hyena’s psuedopenis?
- High levels of androstendione (T precursor) in males and females
- Higher T in pregnant females than lactating females
- Androgen blockers during pregnancy should halt masculinization of female clitoris
- Doesn’t significantly alter male or female embryo development
How does dominance impact female hyena reproductive rate?
Their rate of reproduction is greatly increased by being a dominant rather than a subordinate female. This is b/c social status is passed by heredity in hyenas.
What are the costs of the psuedopenis in hyenas?
- High death rate of first-time mother hyenas
2. High death rate of first litter of cubs
What is the adaptive value of the pseudopenis?
- Pseudopenis development may be a by-product of selection for some other trait
- High androgen levels are adaptive → larger, more aggressive females
- Aggressive, high-status females leave more offspring; rank is inherited
- But androgens are not the clear cause of female pseudopenis development; don’t affect male offspring
What is the social bonding hypothesis?
The pseudopenis may serve as a signal to reduce female-female aggression. (Kruuk)
What is the sexual mimicry hypothesis?
By mimicking submissive males, females trick other females, and divert aggression. (Muller & Wrangham)
How could pseudopenis development be adaptive?
- Females evolved to be dominant over males
- Males present erect penis as a submissive signal of courtship: no aggressive intent
- Females with a pseudopenis could signal lack of aggressive intent, submission, rank
- This would be a combination of social harmony and sexual mimicry hypotheses (Alcock)
What is one example of a shifts in adaptive function?
Whistling moths both make and hear high-pitched sounds. Their ear is complex and has been assembled from parts that were evolutionarily for other purposes. The ear cells resemble mechanoreceptor cells involved in flight (for deaf moth species).
What is the difference in biology between hearing and deaf moths?
- Deaf moths (Saturniids) lack ear with tympanic cavity of Noctuids
- B1 nerve in Saturniids carries info about the wing position
- B1 nerve in Noctuids carries acoustical info
- Similar structures, origins, but different function
How are shift in adaptive functions defined?
“. . . A part that originally served one purpose becomes adapted by slow changes for widely different purposes . . .” - Darwin
What is another example of a shift in adaptive function?
The varying structures of arthropod gills, all of which adapted from one ancestor with gills, leg appendages, and legs. This includes spiders, horsecrabs, crustaceans, insects, and myriapods. Function of these structures changed based on whether or not organism lived on land or water.
How are water mites an example of sensory exploitation?
- Male mimics prey vibration (trembling stance)
- Female grabs him (prey), then releases
- Male deposits sperm packet, female picks it up and uses it
- Sensory exploitation: male exploits female’s pre-existing prey-detection system
How are bowerbird calls an example of sensory exploitation?
Aggressive call deters rivals; this was its original function. Courtship call is a modified aggressive call and now a serves courtship role.
How are guppies an example of mate preference and sensory exploitation?
- Females prefer males with orange spots
- Orange spots are the results of food (condition), not genetics
- Female mate preference may derive from pre-existing sensitivity for orange (nutrient-rich) foods
What is the underlying assumption behind experiments on sensory exploitation?
If sensory exploitation is important in shaping effective signals, experimentation should reveal animal responses to totally new stimuli. Artificial attributes should elicit strong responses, particularly when they exaggerate the stimuli that should cause sensory exploitation.
How was manipulation of the least auklet an example of sensory exploitation?
Model auklets manipulated with crests received the highest numbers of female solicitation displays.
- Experiments gave least auklets either a large head crest, a small head crest, or a breast crest. This was just feathers that protruded from those areas of the body.
- Auklets w/ a large crest on the head received the most courtship displays.
- This is b/c the crest causes sensory exploitation in female auklets.
What is an example of signal receivers responding to an ancestral signal that is no longer present?
Scleroporus virgatus that lack blue stomach patch of other Scleroporus species will still respond to lizards with painted blue patches (by retreating).
Can some animals have a preference for signals never possessed by the current or ancestral species?
- Present a novel trait not exhibited by any related species through experimentation.
- If there is a preference, then the preference is unlikely to be due to sensory bias.
- Sensory bias can develop is species are related, but this is probably not true if the trait has no shared evolutionary history.
How are swordtails an example of sensory exploitation?
- Platyfish are closest relatives of swordtails, but lack swords
- Ancestor probably also lacked swords
- Female platyfish prefer males with experimentally elongated tails, even though ancestors never had them (pre-existing sensory bias)
How is manipulation of finch and zebra finch white feathers an example of sensory exploitation?
Addition of white plume made male zebra finches more attractive to females. Females may be predisposed to favor white feathers b/c white feathers are used during nest construction.
What is the panda principle?
Based on the panda thumb, which was retooled to function differently than its evolutionary purpose. Functional part is co-opted from previous parts; earlier structures used and modified for new purposes.
What is Parthenogenesis?
A type of reproduction, occurring in some insects and flowers, in which the unfertilized ovum develops directly into a new individual.
What animal does parthenogenesis occur in?
Whiptail lizards. Females have sexual behavior to stimulate parthenogenesis, but actually reproduce asexually. Sexual behavior just triggers reproduction.
What features make yelling a recruitment signal?
- Single non-territorial, non-resident ravens call to attract other single ravens to prey
- Paired, territorial birds never call when they find prey in their territory
- By attracting other single birds, singleton is able to feed; cannot be repelled by territorial pair
What are some features of begging behavior as a signal?
- Fitness cost of loud begging: attracts predators in some species
- Other species under high predation have evolved quieter begging calls
- Parents may give alarm calls that signal babies to be quiet
Why do some offspring beg louder than others?
- Sibling scramble competition: louder call gets the food
- Honest signaling: healthier chick begs more loudly, parents choose it over weaker chick. Parents can assess health of chick.
What is the definition of illegitimate signal receivers?
An animal that intercepts a signal from a different species to the detriment of the signaller and the intended receiver.
What is an example of illegitimate signal receiving?
Bat detects mating call of tungara frog, thus increasing predation risk. Male frogs often use just whine call (even though females prefer whine-chuck call) because bats hone in on whine-chuck call.
What are some examples of honest signalling?
- Deep croaks deter rivals in European toads.
- Only large males can make deep croaks.
- Call is an honest signal of body size, and toad can decide whether to fight or retreat based on this signal - Threat duration and pushup frequency in side-blotched lizards will decrease after treadmill test
- Display performance accurately reflects physiological state - Only red deer in top condition can produce calls for long periods
- Call length is an honest signal of body condition
What are dishonest signals?
Receivers of honest signals can lose fitness by responding to dishonest signals by illegitimate signalers; aka signals that mimic a true signal to exploit the intended receiver of the dishonest signal.
What type of reproductive behavior do bowerbirds demonstrate?
- Males build elaborate display structures
- Females visit structures, evaluate them (and males)
- Male mates with female visitors who accept him; provides no parental care
What 2 bowerbird species don’t build bowers?
- Ai. melanotis
2. Ai. crassirostris
What are the benefits of bowers in male bowerbirds?
- Bower may signal info about male quality to female
- Bower quality and decoration number is correlated to mating success
- Bower may signal info about male health or parasite resistance to female
- Bower may signal info about male’s developmental history
- Better bower may signal better (larger) brain
This is important b/c most copulations are made by very few males, and female bowerbirds are choosy based on bower structure.
How do males differ from females in reproductive effort?
Sperm is cheap
Males have excess in gametes
Reproductive success depends on # of mates
How do females differ from males in reproductive effort?
Eggs are expensive and scarce
Reproductive success depends on (limited by) number of eggs produced
What did Robert Trivers postulate about parental investment?
- Time, energy, and risks taken to help offspring that may reduce chance a parent will reproduce successfully in the future
- Tradeoffs between existing offspring survival vs. future offspring production
What role do females play in parental investment?
Generally make larger parental investment than males (per offspring)
- Gamete production
- Embryo development
- Lactation (mammals)
- Parental care
What reflects female fitness and reason to genetically prioritize parental investment?
Avoid costs of additional matings after choosing best partner (resources; good genes).
What reflects male fitness and reason to genetically not prioritize parental investment?
Compete with rivals (access to mates); evolutionarily, the goal is to mate with as many females as possible.
What factors influence sex role reversal?
- Female-biased operational sex ratio
- Ability of females to produce too many eggs for a single mate to care for
What is sex role reversal?
Males provide parental care of offspring.
What are some examples of sex role reversal?
- Seahorses carrying eggs in pouch to protect brood
- Male Yellowhead Jawfish carrying eggs in its mouth to protect brood
- Cichlid/severum male mouth-brooding for protection
How are Mormon crickets an example of sex role reversal?
- Males present females with nuptial gift (edible spermatophore) that females use to provision eggs
- Males mate once; females mate multiple times
- When populations are large, male crickets are more choosy about who gets the packet (larger females produce more eggs)
What characteristics are there for sexual selection in evolution?
- Males and females differ in physical ornaments and display behaviors
- Males and females differ in reproductive success
- Costly traits that reduce survival will still be selected for if they increase lifetime reproductive success
What is true of sexual selection in baboons?
Dominance rank correlates w/ reproductive success.
- Dominant and submissive males both mate equally, but dominant males mate more often when females are in estrus
- Submissive males mate when females are not fertile
What is true of mate guarding/controlling in baboons?
- Top-ranked male does not always have mating priority with estrous females
- High-ranking males did not guard estrous females as long as thought
What features characterize a condition strategy of sexual selection?
- Males have a choice of mating tactics
- One tactic is usually superior to the other
- The males in poorer condition have to adopt the less successful tactic
- However, if their condition changes, so can their tactic
What are some alternative mating strategies in males?
- Sneaker strategy - attempting to mate w/ females by having smaller bodies and feminized appearance to trick larger/dominant males
- Satellite mating - indirectly mating w/ female by either being in physical proximity or taking advantage of mating opportunities after the dominant males have attempted to court
What are some examples of satellite mating?
- Male frogs attempting to fertilize eggs by trailing the female
- Rams following the dominant male in pursuit of a female or waiting to mate when the dominant male is distracted fighting off others and etc.
- Horseshoe crabs staying attached to females for long periods and taking advantage of the group for the opportunity to mate
What are some examples of alternative mating strategies that are under genetic control?
- In Sandpipers, can develop a territorial or submissive satellite strategy
- In sponge isopods, can be a large alpha, a beta who mimics female appearance, or a gamma which chooses a sneaker approach
What should happen if mating strategies are genetic?
They should have equal fitness irrespective of the strategy used.
What should happen if mating strategies are conditional?
Fitness should differ based on type of strategy.
In polygamous species, males can gain a fitness advantage over other males by what?
- Removing sperm from previous male
- Guarding females
- Producing more sperm
- Sealing female reproductive tract after mating
What is sperm competition?
Competition at the fertilization level.
What is an example of sperm competition?
In fish:
- Territorial guards female; has more sperm
- Sneakers sneak between males/females when territorials are spawning
- Satellite males hover until fertilization between territorial/female, then slip in
How do damselflies address sperm competition?
- Damselfly males remove sperm from female before depositing their own sperm
- Special organ used for sperm removal
Can females cooperate in sperm removal?
Yes.
What is an example of this sperm removal cooperation in females?
In female dunnocks, males stimulate the female to remove sperm.
Can sperm competition occur within the female animal’s body?
Yes. Sperm can be stored in some species. Extra-pair copulations boost sperm numbers; overwhelm stored sperm by the previous donor.
What is mate guarding?
Male guards female after mating to prevent his sperm from being removed by another male.
What are the costs of mate guarding?
- Time lost finding other mates
- Fewer mates and fewer offspring
- High energy expenditure guarding
What are the benefits of mate guarding?
- Paternity assured
2. Fitness benefit?
What is an example of the effects mate guarding has on Seychelles birds?
- Male Seychelles warblers tricked to stop guarding
- Unguarded females quickly found new mates
- Extra pair copulations increased
- Male Seychelles warblers also adjust guarding behavior
- They spend more time guarding mates when more males are around
What affects extra pair copulations and mate guarding efficacy?
- Food availability affects EPC rates
- Food near nest makes females easier to guard
- Fewer extra pair copulations
How are honest signals one possible explanation for extreme sexual dimorphism in traits, coloration, and behavior between sexes?
May signal male quality. This is possible in peacocks:
- Plumage quality may signal male quality
- Carotenoids in food increase coloration: more carotenoids = brighter colors
- More carotenoids = better foraging/providing ability
- Carotenoids also involved in immune response: brighter = healthier; stronger immune response
What is the good parent theory in female mate choice?
- Females choose males based on their health and ability to be good parents
- Indicators of male parental quality:
- Color
- Ornamentation
- Courtship behavior
- Female gets a healthy mate, no diseases/parasites
What is the Hamilton-Zuk hypothesis of parasite-mediated Sexual Selection?
- Trait (plumage color) is related to an adaptive feature that is not obvious (genetically mediated parasite resistance)
- Colors can only develop well if male is resistant to parasites
- Resistance = good genes
What is the good genes theory in female mate choice?
- Females choose males based on their ability to provide offspring with superior genes
- Male courtship displays and ornaments or plumage quality signal info about genes
- Offspring of such fathers would have survival and reproductive advantages
What is one example that may give support to the good genes theory?
- Singing duration in male starlings is correlated to immune response
- More singing stamina = stronger immune system
- Females prefer males with longer songs; offspring get genes for strong immune system
What is the runaway selection theory in female mate choice?
- Females choose males based on their extreme plumage/coloration or display behavior
- Genetically controlled female preference for a genetically controlled male trait
- Male offspring of extreme fathers would be preferred by females and would have repro advantages; female offspring would inherit preference for extreme males
What is one possible example of runaway selection theory?
- In widowbirds, females prefer males with longer tails
- Males with longer tails leave more long-tailed offspring
What is the sensory bias/chase away theory in female mate choice?
- Females choose males based on displays/ornaments that exploit a pre-existing sensory bias
- No benefit received by female
- Males with elaborate displays/ornaments are favored, trait is passed onto offspring
What is monogamy?
Males and females pair for life; no other mates.
What is serial monogamy?
Males and females pair for breeding season; new mates chosen each season.
What is polygamy?
One male mates with multiple females; females typically only mate with one.
What is polyandry?
One female mates with many males; males typically mate with only one female.
What is the mate assistance hypothesis?
- Monogamy and male parental care are beneficial to offspring production (fitness)
- Fitness is actually higher in monogamous males than in polygamous males (e.g. seahorses)
What is the mate guarding hypothesis?
- Monogamy arose as a by-product of mate-guarding
- Males who guard fertilize more offspring than those who don’t (whose mates are fertilized by others), e.g. clown shrimp