Chapters 13, 14, 15, 16 Flashcards
Describe the purpose of descriptive research
- To document the factors that describe characteristics, behaviors and conditions of individuals and groups.
- Descriptive data supply the foundation for classifying individuals, for identifying relevant variables, and for asking new research questions.
Describe the purpose of developmental research
- Describes developmental change - for instance, change in motor development in infants and children
- Describes sequencing of behaviors in people over time
Describe the purpose of normative research
- To describe typical or standard values for characteristics of a given population
Describe the purpose of qualitative research
- to describe the complex nature of humans and how individuals perceive their experiences within a social context
- to explore and understand human behavior
Describe approaches to qualitative research
- Phenomenology
- Ethnography
- Grounded Theory
- Constant comparative analysis
- Observation
Discuss analysis issues in qualitative research
- -Involves many hours of sifting through narratives, coding, and organizing. Computer programs have been developed to help organize the data , not to analyze data as this would promote a loss of intimacy with the data as well as confidentiality and security of participants.
- In qualitative research, the concept of measurement must be examined in terms of judgments rather than numerical equivalency.
Describe the role of descriptive surveys in research
- Present group characteristics, weaknesses: accuracy of information, bias of sample, example of foot strike and minimalist shoes
Discuss the purpose of case studies
- provides an opportunity for understanding the totality of an individual’s condition outcomes and care
- Understanding unusual patient conditions
- Examples of innovative or creative therapies
- Generating and testing theory
- Providing future research directives
Describe the structure of case studies
- Involve an in-depth description of an individual’s condition or response to treatment; however, case studies can also focus on a group, institution, or other social unit, such as a particular school, healthcare setting, community or family. A description of interesting, new, and unique cases is necessary to build a foundation for clinical science and as a means of sharing special information among professional colleagues.
What are the Six types of descriptive research
- Developmental
- Natural History
- Normative research
- Qualitative research
- Surveys
- Case Studies
Describe the Phenomenology approach to qualitative research
- Drawing meaning from complex realities through careful analysis of first-person narrative material. I.e. illness, physical disability, and childbirth…book example of family with autistic child and how making life very routine was helpful
Describe the Ethnography approach to qualitative research
- The study of attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors of specific people within their own cultural milieu…researchers become immersed in culture to see how culture effects beliefs and attitudes…i.e. pregnancy and childbirth in Native American women
Describe the Grounded Theory approach to qualitative research
- The researcher collects, codes, and analyzes data simultaneously
- Facilitates the identification of relevant variables, and using an inductive process, identification of theoretical concepts that are “grounded” in the observations
Describe the Constant Comparative analysis approach to qualitative research
- As data are collected, they are analyzed and theories are tested. Theories evolve as research is ongoing. I.e. Jensen’s 2007 publication theory of what constituted expert practice in PT
- At any point in the study, if data do not support the theory, the data are not discarded, but the theory is refined so that it fits the existing data
Describe the Observation approach to qualitative research
- non-participant, strictly observing or can be combined with interviews
Describe the techniques for ensuring trustworthiness of qualitative data
- Triangulation: process by which concepts are confirmed by using more than one source of data, more than one data collection method, or more than one set of researchers. For example, a researcher may identify a specific concept through an interview, by direct observation of group performance, and by analysis of written material. If comparable conclusions are drawn, then internal validity is strengthened.
- Audit trail: a clear description and documentation of the thought processes used to interpret data assists in improving the validity of the findings as the reader can follow the investigators logic.
- Other strategies for improving accuracy include the involvement of more than one investigator to confirm ideas, and confirmation of conclusions with the subject of the study through member checks, and analysis until data saturation (no new themes identified)is reached.
Define exploratory research
- The systematic investigation of relationships among two or more variables. Researchers use this approach to predict the effect of one variable on another or test relationships that are supported by clinical theory.
Compare and contrast longitudinal research with cross-sectional research
- In longitudinal studies, the researcher follows a cohort of subjects over time performing repeated measures at prescribed intervals.
- In cross sectional studies, a researcher studies a stratified group of subjects at one point in time and draws conclusions about a population by comparing the characteristics of those strata.
Explain correlation and regression
- Correlation is the foundation of exploratory studies. It’s the measure of the degree of association among variables. Correlation is a function of covariation, that is, the extent to which one variable varies directly or indirectly with another variable. Example: You could examine the effect of nutritional status, depression, and sleep on fatigue in elderly patients.
- Regression is used to establish the accuracy of prediction (predictive correlational studies are designed to predict a behavior or response based on the observed relationship between the behavior and other variables. These designs can be used to develop models such as clinical prediction rules.
Describe a case control study
- A case control is a method of epidemiologic investigation in which groups of individuals are selected on the basis of whether or not they have the disorder under study. Cases are those with the disorder while controls are those without the disorder acting as the comparison.
- The investigator then looks back in time interview, questionnaire, or chart review to determine if the groups differ with respect to exposure or characteristics that may put the person at risk for developing the condition of interest.
Outline considerations for selection of subjects in case control and cohort studies
- Case control studies subjects selected based on whether or not they have disorder
- Cohort studies subjects selected based on exposure rather than outcome/ development of the disorder
What are the advantages and disadvantages of Longitudinal Research
Advantages:
- Ability to accumulate data through intensive documentation of growth and change on the same individual allowing for observations of patterns of change and suggest causal relationships between variables
- collected in time sequence allowing for documentation of direction as well as magnitude of change
Disadvantages:
- extended obligation to a single project requiring long term commitment of resources
- subjects can’t be replaced and compliance must be ensured
- internal validity can be threatened by repeated testing, attrition secondary to extended data collection timeframe, and confounding variables that may affect the developmental sequence that’s being evaluated
What are the advantages and disadvantages of Cross Sectional Research
Advantages:
- More efficient than longitudinal study
- Internal validity isn’t threatened by testing or history effects because subjects are tested only once at one point in time.
Disadvantage:
-Major threat to validity is selection as it’s difficult to know to what extent results reflect the effects of age or the passage of time versus the effects of extraneous variables.
*Many of the extraneous variables pertain to cohort effects which are not age specific but are due to a subjects generation or time of birth (exposure to health info, education, historical events that influenced life choices).
Describe a Cohort Study
- A Cohort is defined as a group of individuals who are followed over time. The most common type of cohorts are geographic cohorts such as residents of a community or birth cohorts (baby boomers).
What are developmental and historical cohorts
- Historical cohorts of those who experienced a common event (WWII veterans, experienced natural disaster)
- Developmental cohorts are based on life changes (getting married, moving to nursing home)
What are the five criteria to provide evidence for cause and effect
- Time sequence
- Strength of the association
- Biologic credibility
- Consistency (with other studies)
- Dose-response relationship
Contrast Case control studies and Cohort Studies
- Case controls are usually retrospective and work well for rare conditions
- Cohorts are usually prospective and work well for common conditions