Chapter 8 Flashcards
Are certain variables dependent and others independent? Or does it depend on context?
o It’s not about the variable, but rather how it’s used that determines if it’s indep or dep
Are the variables explicitely stated in the research process in Ql and Qn research?
• In Ql, research variables often clearly ID’d in the open-ended research questions.
In contrast, in Qn, should clearly describe the variables even if they are not explicitly labelled as such b/d data collection methods are spec aimed at measuring study variables as objectively as possible
(I don’t understand the difference here…p 149 end of par 4)
Variables can be defined at 2 levels. what are they?
Operational + theoretical
Theoretical def’n
one that is described and understood conceptually. Not always clearly measureable. (ex: stress defined as perception of threat and that he/she can no way to manage that threat)
Operational def’n
o one that is defined in specific concrete terms; allows us to see how we would measure the var (ex: stress defined as heart rate or rating of threat on 4 point scale)
Do variables in Qn need a theoretical or an operational def’n?
• Many variables in healthcare are abstract and need both theoretical + operational def/n if they are going to be used in Qn research
(needs operational def’n but not necessarily theoretical)
Can most variables be operationalized?
• Almost any var can be operationalized, but the correctness + accuracy of that operationalization must be evaluated
Operationalization =
translation from theoretical and concrete measure or set of measures
What is an error?
• When variable is not measured with 100% accuracy, we say there is error in measurement.
Error refers to the difference between what is true and the answer we obtained from our data collection (ex: difference in results from observing + recording 1000 people’s genders and knowing the true genders)
Does Ql operationalize?
Ql doesn’t operationalize variables b/c does not presume to know enough about the var of interest to assign concrete measures. It DOES translate specific experiences or observations into theoretical concepts or descriptions of variables during data analysis
Are both Ql and Qn open to errors? In which kind is there more opporunity for error?
Both kinds of research are open to errors in translation!
In Ql, you are translating specific experiences or observations into theoretical concepts or descriptions of variables during data analysis. Therefore, Ql is open to errors in interpretation (ex: may fail to take into account all of the themes a person is expressing).
• Errors of measurement can be even greater in Qn b/c are operationalizing…can occur in both the translation of theoretical to oper + in the operationalized measurement
What kind of var is quite easy to operationalize?
demographic
• Eg: Education can be operationalized as 1) if student has RN or LPN diploma 2) total number of yrs in post-secondary
What is the primary putpose of Ql research r/t to operationalization
• Primary purpose of many Ql is to dev clear theoretical def’n of var so might eventually be operationally defined + concretely measured
(I feel like many Ql researchers would disagree with this!)
Does Ql seek an absolute truth?
• Ql assume truth is moving target – we can come closer to finding a meaning of variable but it is always highly context-laden + therefore evolving
Data collection methods for Ql research include?
DCMS for Ql rely on sharing through verbal, visual, written, music, within life activities (such as cooking a meal). Includes interviews, journaling, observation art analysis
Two categories of interviews for Ql research
unstructured + those that used groups
What do unstructured interviews look like?
1) Q’s asked in informal + open fashion w/o previously established set of categories or assumed answers.
- Assume is dependent on interactions between interviewer+ participant.
- Researcher may bracket + put aside own knowledge/beliefs or may incorporate
- Data collected include not just spoken words but actions, expressions, etc
- May be carried out through in-depth interviews oral histories, storytelling, life review, etc. Typically recorded + then transcribed verbatim with notes on sighs, tone, etc.
What are the notes taken on interactional dynamics (actions, expressions, body language, etc) during an interview called?
Field notes
what the interviewer is seeing during the process…used to enrich the data
How do group interviews for ql research work?
a. May take form of focus groups or brainstorming
b. Incl not just member’s responses to the questions but then also responses to other group members
c. May happen informally as come across people in dialogue already – research introduces self + obtains consent to listen in
Pro and cons of group interviews?
a. Pros: rich in data and inexpensive
cons: may limit hearing + knowing unique perspectives as limits some individual expression
Are semistructured + structured interviews used in ql research?
– assume + control options for answers. Not usually used in Ql.
What can journaling be used for in ql research?
Journaling can provide continuous and evolving info from an individual perspective that cannot be collected face to face.
What is a free write?
• more limited form of written data in which participant is directly asked to write response or description about phenomenon on the occasion of data collection
(I think it’s considered more limited than journalling or interview perhaps)
How can we study the past in Ql research?
• Documents + records may be used in Ql to examine the past
Is data collection in Ql research structured? Objectified? Planned + thought through?
• Data collection in Ql is not structured or objectified, but is carefully planned + thought through
Two major ways of introducting errors in Ql research
during process of data collection, analysis or both.