Chapter 5 Flashcards
What is a Tort?
- Civil wrong other than breach of contract for which the law provides a remedy in the form of damages
- Purpose is to punish by hitting defendant in the pocket book
Intentional Tort
- deliberate action resulting in a harm
- meant to do the act, but not necessarily meant to harm the innocent party
Negligence/Unintentional Tort
- arises due to failing to use reasonable care
Strict Liability
- Liability without fault
- usually reserved for abnormally dangerous activities
Assault
- Personal Intentional Tort
- intentional act placing a person in fear or apprehension of immediate bodily harm or offensive contact
- Fear can be legitimate even if threat cannot be carried out (eg. unloaded gun)
Hill v. Western Union Telegraph
- Defendant worked for Western Union Telegraph and was under contract to fix Plaintiff/Hill’s clock
- Employee, Sapp, was drunk and told Hill “If you … let me love and pet you, I will fix your clock” while standing behind counter
- Won at trial court bot lost at the appellate level as the employee did not act within the scope of his employment
- Appellate Court did say that there certainly could have been an assault
Battery
- Intentional act of physical contact or offensive touching of someone else without his or her permission
- physical harm not required, but physical contact is required
Defenses to Assault or Battery
- Consent
- Privilege (eg. cop pulls gun on a suspect, or searches suspect)
- Self-Defense (w/ reasonable amount of force - deadly force allowed only if deadly force first used against you)
False Imprisonment
- intentional holding or detaining of a person within boundaries if the person is harmed by such detention
Shopkeepers Privilege
- Common Law
- merchant has the right to reasonably detain suspected thief on business premises for a reasonable amount of time
- Illinois has this as a statutory protection for the Merchant
Intentional Infliction of Mental Distress
- usually requires manifestation of physical harm (eg heart attack or stroke)
- more than just obscene and abusive language
Tidelands Automobile Club v. Walters
- rare victory in Intentional Infliction of Mental Distress
Invasion of Privacy
- invasion of a person’s right to solitude, an unwarranted public exposure
- must have public disclosure of a private fact that is offensive to the ordinary person, BUT public figures lose a lot of their right to privacy
Galella v. Onassis
Public figures do not lose all of their rights of privacy - they still have a right of privacy as to the details of their private life
Defamation
- publication of a false statement that tends to injure a person’s reputation or good name causing the public to hold that person up to hatred, contempt, or ridicule, or cause him/her to be shunned or avoided
Constitutional Privileges
- statements made by legislators and other public officials
Hutchinson v. Proxmire
- Constitutional privileges are limited
Conditional or Qualified Privileges
- a statement made in good faith with proper motives are protected
Malicious Prosecution
- wrongful use of legal proceeding, civil or criminal
- difficult to win, because you must win all lawsuits against you and then prove that the opposing party had NO probable cause and prove malicious conduct
Unique Requirement for Texas Malicious Prosecution
- Special damages or special injures
- the alleged Malicious Prosecution must have interfered with a person or his property in the form of an arrest, attachment, injunction, or sequestration
- supposed to assure good faith litigants without fear of intimidation by a countersuit for malicious prosecution
Abuse of Process
- recognized in Texas
- a party maliciously misuses or misapplies regularly issued civil or criminal process for a purpose and thereby obtains a result not lawfully warranted
Disparagement
- form of defamation against a Business
untrue statement made, while knowingly false, with malice, causing special damages
- slander of title, or slander of quality
Intentional Interference with Contractual Relations
- est. in England 1853
- 3rd party induces one of two original parties to break original contract and damage other original party
Texaco v. Pennzoil
“Ten Billion Dollar Jury Award”
- Getty Oil Company, Pennzoil Co., Texaco Inc.
- Getty and Pennzoil were original contracting parties, until Getty broke the original contract and sold to Texaco
- Getty knew that they had a contract with Pennzoil and had Texaco indemnify them - jury awarded Pennzoil damage request of $7.32 Billion and an additional $3 Billion in punitive damages
- Texaco filed for Bankruptcy, and case eventually settled for $3 Billion
Defenses to Trespass
- A trespasser enters to assist someone in danger even if that person is a trespasser
- trespasser enters to protect property
Advantages to Registering Copyright
- can only sue infringers if the copyright is registered
- establishes a public record
- can have an impact on damages