Chapter 3 - Insider Dealing + Misleading Statements and Misleading ImpressionsMarket Abuse Flashcards
Explain what [A] CJA 1993, Part V covers:
• Covers “insider dealing” (as defined): i.e., misuse of inside information
Explain what [B] FSA 2012, ss.89-91
• Covers “misleading statements and misleading impressions” (as defined): i.e., misrepresentations and misleading the market - [A]+[B] are both dealt with in CRIMINAL courts - Using CRIMINAL standard of evidence (“beyond all reasonable doubt”)
Explain [C] Market Abuse Regulation (MAR) (formerly, FSMA 2000, s.118, + MAD)
• Covers “market abuse” (as defined): i.e., similar to [A]+[B] above - [C] is dealt with by CIVIL regulator (the FCA) - Using CIVIL standard of evidence (“balance of probability”)
Explain - History of Market Abuse Controls in UK
3 separate regimes since 2001:
- 1.12.2001–30.6.2005
• UK initiative: FSMA 2000, s.118
- 1.7.2005 – 2.7.2016
• Market Abuse Directive (MAD): FSMA 2000, s.118, re-drafted
- 3.7.2016 – present
• Market Abuse Regulation (MAR): FSMA 2000, s.118, and MAD repealed and replaced
Explain the Behaviour covered by MAR
How many are there?
- • Insider dealing
- • Unlawful disclosure of inside information
- • Market manipulation
What are the Financial instruments covered by MAR
How many are there?
Those admitted to trading (or application for admission made) on:
- • Regulated market (e.g. main market of LSE)
- • Multilateral trading facility (MTF) (e.g. AIM)
- • Organised trading facility (OTF) (due in 2018 under MiFID II)
Explain the Definition of Market Abuse Under MAR
A person commits market abuse where he:
- • engages, or attempts to engage, in insider dealing #
- • recommends, or induces, another person to engage in insider dealing
- • unlawfully discloses inside information
- • engages, or attempts to engage, in market manipulation #
Notes:
Where insider dealing or market manipulation are committed by a legal person (e.g. a company), they are also committed by any natural person (e.g. a director) who participated in the decision
The underlined terms (above) are defined in the following slides
Explain the Definition of Insider Dealing
A person who is in possession of inside information uses that information:
- To acquire or dispose of financial instruments to which the information relates (whether it is for his own account or for a 3rd party, and whether it is done directly or indirectly)
- To cancel or amend an order to which the inside information relates, where the order was placed before the person possessed the information
Such a person in possession of inside information may be any of:
- • Director (or equivalent) of an issuer
- • Shareholder of an issuer
- • Access to the information through employment, profession or duties
- • Access through criminal activities • Knowing tippee
Explain the Definition of Inside Information
How many points does it have? 4
Inside information has the following elements:
- The information is of a precise nature
- It has not been made public
- It relates directly or indirectly to one or more financial instruments
- If it were made public, it would be likely to have a significant effect on the price of the financial instrument (or of a related derivative)
Notes:
- Information is “of a precise nature” when it would enable a specific conclusion to be drawn about its effect on the price
- Information would have a “significant effect” on the price if it would be likely to be used by a reasonable investor to help in making a decision
- For persons who execute orders, inside information also includes information conveyed by a client and relating to the client’s pending orders
Explain the Definition of Market Manipulation
How many points? 5
Market manipulation comprises:
- False or misleading behaviour
- Behaviour which secures, or is likely to secure, the price of financial instruments at an abnormal or artificial level
- Deceptive behaviour
- Dissemination through the media, including the internet, of false or misleading information which the person knew or ought to have known was false or misleading
- Manipulation of benchmarks
Explain the Control of Inside Information
What should you do?
Disclosure of inside information
- Issuers must publish inside information (as defined) as soon as possible
- The information must remain on the issuer’s website for at least 5 years
Delaying disclosure of inside information
- Delaying disclosure is permissible if:
> immediate disclosure would prejudice the legitimate interests of the issuer; and
> delayed disclosure is not likely to mislead the public; and
> the issuer can ensure the confidentiality of the information
• The FCA must be notified (and may ask for full written explanation)
Explain Insider Lists
How many points? 4
Detailed requirements apply. In outline, issuers must:
- Maintain (and keep up to date) a list of persons with access to inside information (distinguishing between permanent and temporary insiders)
- Ensure that the persons on the list acknowledge in writing their duty of confidentiality (and are aware of the sanctions that apply)
- Remain fully responsible for the list even where it is maintained by an adviser (e.g. an accountancy or legal firm)
- Keep the list for at least 5 years
Explain Safe Harbours
How many points? 5
This is the term used to describe behaviour which might have a direct or indirect effect on an issuer’s share price, but which would not be subject to sanctions under the market abuse regime.
Safe harbours include:
- Acting in conformity with the EU’s Buy-back and Stabilisation Regulation
- Acting in conformity with the FCA’s rules on Chinese walls
- Disclosures in accordance with the UKLA’s Disclosure Rules (DTR)
- Disclosures in accordance with the Takeover Code’s rules on disclosure during a takeover bid
- Market soundings
Explain Accepted Market Practices and STORs
Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs)
Accepted Market Practices
- No sanction would apply to any behaviour or transaction that conforms with an accepted market practice
- Under MAR, these may be identified by competent authorities (eg, the FCA) and are subject to the approval of ESMA
- There has only ever been one example in the UK (relating to the metal market) – now discontinued
Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs)
- Firms (and operators of regulated markets, MTFs and OTFs) are required to report any suspicious transactions or orders to the FCA “in a timely manner”
- Note that this reporting obligation applies to unexecuted orders and requests for quotes as well as to executed transactions
Explain Investment Recommendations
How many points? 2
Persons producing or disseminating investment recommendations must take reasonable care:
- To ensure that the information is objectively presented; and •
- To disclose their interests or indicate any conflicts of interest
Investment recommendations also include sales notes and re- dissemination of research