Chapter 2: basics of contract law Flashcards
What is a contract?
binding legal relationship between two or more persons to do something, not to do something, or to deliver something in the future
contract law
part of private law pertaining to contracts
freedom of contract/ party autonomy as a general principle
- wheter to enter into a contract
- terms and conditions of contract
- freedom to modify the terms of a contract or to put an end to a contract
(contracting parties are lefislators of their own, can freely deviate rules)
exceptions to freedom of contract
- Infringing fundamental principles of law (: illegal, no guarantee of freedom for both parties)
- Infringing mandatory legal rules (: protected party can waive protection(post factum))
- discrimination
kinds of discrimination and meaning
- direct discrimination: one person is treated less favourably than another person would be treated in a comparable situation
- indirect discrimination: neutral provision/ criterion/ places one group of persons at a particular disadvantage when compared to a different group of persons
- harassment: unwanted conduct which violates a persons dignity
pre-contractual duties
duty to …
- disclose the other person information concerning the product to be supplied so that person can reasonably expect
- not provide misleading info
- inform about price and changes
- inform about address, id if bussines
- …
one person has the duty to actively gather info that he needs to take an informed transactional decision
negotations
- when you break off the negotiation contrarty to good faith and fair dealing= culpa in contrahendo liability for loss caused and incurred
contract agreement
a contract is based on offer and acceptance
- idea of meering of the midns
- real intentions to enter binding legal relationship
- reach sufficient agreement on terms already determent
who has and has not the capacity to make and or accept an offer ? (by national law)
yes generaly: every adult
not: a minor, mentally handicapped, drunken/ not able to fromulate an offer
(def) offer
- proposal to make a contract
- intention to result into a contract if other party accepts it
- containing sufficiently definite terms to form a contract
- must be communicated to one or more specific persons or to the public
offer to the public (example, exeptions, when)
treated as offers it they show an intention to be binding if they are accepted.
- exceptions: when the personal qualities of the other party are a detemining factor.
e.g., advertisements, auctions,…
revocation of offer (which law?, why important?)
- domestic laws:
for german/ swiss: no revocation
for french: allowed, but not for certain exceptions
common law: allowed - important because:
interests of stakeholders, protection
revocation of offer DCFR (?, exception, offer to public)
in general allowed if it reaches the offeree before he or she has dispatched an acceptance.
- exception:
offer is irrevocable, has a fixed time for its acceptance, offeree has acted in reliance on the offer (onw reasons to rely on it) - to the public: can be revoked by the same means as were used to make the offer
late acceptance
ineffective -> no contract
- but: “regularisation” is possible: when offeror informed offeree that late acceptance will be treated as effective acceptance -> contract
- but: delay in transmission of late acceptance, it will in due time reach the offeror. -> contract
modified acceptance
is reejection and counteroffer (=new offer)
- exception: acceptance, if reply contains a definite consent to the offer, but alters the terms in a non-material way -> new terms become part of the contract
- exception: rejection, if reply alters the terms in material way, if offer expressly limits acceptance to the terms of the offer, if the offerer objects to the new terms without undue delay
standard terms to form a contract
generally: terms of contract negatiated by informed and equally powerful parties
def: a term which has been formulated in advance for several transactions involving different parties and which has not been individually negotiated by the parties.
(standard term becomes part of contract if brought to attention of other party before conclusion of contract)
knock out rule
standard terms form part of the contract to the extent that thay are common in substance, the conflicting terms knock out each other
form of a contract
- no form required except for when expressly required (for certain contracts)
a contract is concluded, without any further requirement when both parties are happy (def: the document comprising Section 1 of the Contract signed by or on behalf of the Parties confirming their willingness to enter into and be bound by the terms of the Contract)
when is a promise/ contract serious? (problem)
- Roman law in antiquity
- different types of contracts in roman law
- STIPULATIO (= a form of contract based upon a simple question and answer.) .with formal requirements
- seldom: contracts based on mere consent
when is a promise/ contract serious? (problem)
- Roman law in the Middle Ages:
- PACTUM NUDUM (‘nude contract’): imperfect obligation, (=an agreement or promise that is made without consideration and hence unenforceable)
- PACTUM VESTITUM (‘vested contract’): allowed to sue the other party (= an informal agreement made legally enforceable by an official act.)
when is a promise/ contract “serious”? (problem)
- canon law
- no difference between a ‘simple promise’ and a ‘sworn promise / corroborated with an oath
- breaking a promise is a sin - therefore, every contract is binind, not only the “vested contract”
- CAUSE required to ensure seriousness
- > practice accepted the idea developed in canon law (pacta sunt servanda - treaties are to be kept)
when is a promis/ contract serious? (problem)
- french law
- CAUSE (reason) required to indicate seriousness
- “four resuisites are essential for the validity of an agreement. The consent of the party who binds himself,; His capacity to contract; A definity object which forms the subject matter of the undertaking; a lawful cause in the obligation.”
- “an obligation without cause or with a false cause, or with an unlawful cause, may not have any effect.”
When is a promise/ contract serious? (problem)
- Common Law
- CONSIDERATION (= something in exchange for the promise, e.g., another promise or an actual act) required
- consideration must have some real value or at least tepresent a detriment to the person who contributes it
When is a promis/ contract serious? (problem)
- German Law
- no consideration, no cause necessary
- “seriousness” discussed when considering the intention to conclude a legally binding relationship
When is a promise/ contract serious? (problem)
- DCFR3
- No consideration, no cause necessary
- “seriousness” discussed in term “intention to enter into a legally binding relationship”
no-oral midification clause
clause (=a particular part of a written legal document) in a contract stating that all midifications must be in writing
-> established in Austria, Germany, DCFR
representative (agent)
a person who has authority to affect directly the legal position of another person (= the principal) in relation to a “third party” by acting on behalf of the principal.
when they act in the name of the principal within the scope of authority granted (= determened by authorisation) : it is as if done by the principal
representaiton problems
1) Representative acting in own name
2) Representative acting “in the name of” but without authority
- > solution: protaction of purported principal (your not bounded), protaction of third party (no contract), representative might be held liable for damages (except when third party knew)
invalidity of the contract can be based on
- mistake, fraus, coercion or threats, unfair exploitation ->” vitiated consent”
- infringement of fundamental principles or mandatory rules or lack of capacity - supra
- unfair contract terms -> partial invalidity= invalidity of the unfair term
avoidance of the contract is possible if
- party would not hace concluded the contract or would have entered it on fundamentally different terms
- other party: cause/ knew mistake, breached pre-contractual duties