Chapter 14 External Confirmation ISA 505 Flashcards
1.
Define External Confirmation?
[Chapter 14]
External confirmation is a procedure of obtaining evidence by auditor directly from a third party in written form (on paper, electronic or other medium).
Give examples of some areas where external confirmation is used?
[Chapter 14]
- Debtors, Creditors (sample basis)
- Banks, Lawyers (100%)
- Third parties holding inventory, investments held by brokers.
Under what circumstances, confirmation is NOT used?
[Chapter 14]
- Risk is low, or
- Balance is immaterial, or
- Evidence obtained from other procedures, or
- Management requests.
What is the reliability of evidence obtained through External Confirmation?
[Chapter 14]
Confirmation provides highly reliable evidence (being written, external and direct evidence).
What assertions are satisfied by external confirmation?
[Chapter 14]
Confirmation provides evidence about:
- Existence,
- Rights and Obligation,
- Accuracy, Valuation and allocation assertions.
Confirmation does NOT provide evidence about:
- Completeness
List steps involved in the process of Circularization.
[Chapter 14]
- Decide timing.
- Decide parties
- Decide information
- Decide Type (positive or negative)
- Obtain signature
- Send letters.
- Perform procedures on the basis of replies.
- Preparate summary and conclusion
Which further procedures are performed if confirmation is sent at interim date?
[Chapter 14]
- Compare balances.
- Select a sample of transactions after interim date, and perform:
* tests of controls, and
* tests of details. - Send confirmation letter again (if necessary).
What are different types of confirmations sent to debtors?
[Chapter 14]
- Positive Confirmation Request.
* Method 1: Balance included
* Method 2: Balance NOT included - Negative Confirmation Request
What is a Positive Confirmation Request?
[Chapter 14]
Confirming party is asked to reply auditor in all cases whether he agrees or disagrees.
What is a Negative Confirmation Request?
[Chapter 14]
Confirming party is asked to reply auditor in case of disagreement only.
What is the risk in Positive Confirmation Request? How it can be reduced?
[Chapter 14]
Risk: Confirming party may reply without verification.
How to reduce: Use Method 2 Confirmation (i.e. Blank Confirmation without balance)
What is the risk in Negative Confirmation Request? How it can be reduced?
[Chapter 14]
Risk: Less reliable, no explicit evidence, confirmation may be lost or disregarded.
How to reduce: Use only when 4 conditions are met.
Which conditions must be satisfied to use Negative Confirmation?
[Chapter 14]
- Large number of small balances.
- Risk is low, and auditor tested controls.
- Very low exception rate is expected, and
- Confirmation party will not disregard request.
What procedures should be performed by auditor if reply to confirmation indicates agreement?
[Chapter 14]
No further work is required.
What procedures should be performed by auditor if reply to confirmation indicates disagreement?
[Chapter 14]
- Ask client to reconcile.
- Check whether exception is because of:
* timing difference (i.e. cash in transit or goods are in transit), or
* misstatement in records of client, or
* misstatements in record of confirming party. - Increase risk, if there is indication of weakness in internal control or fraud.