Chapter 12 Flashcards
What type of laws regulate state taxation?
Legislative Law
Administrative Law
Judicial Law
What is included in legislative law in relation to state taxation?
state constitution
state tax code
What is included in administrative law in relation to state taxation?
regulations
ruling
What is included in judicial law in relation to state taxation?
State tax cases
Federal tax cases
Commercial domicile
State where a business is headquartered and directs operations
Not necessarily where it is incorporated
Nexus in relation to taxation
The sufficient (or minimum) connection between a business and a state that subjects the business to the state’s tax system.
What is included in state and local taxes?
sale and use taxes
income taxes
property taxes
Businesses are subject to state taxes if:
The state is the commercial domicile of the business
or
The taxpayer has nexus
Causes sales tax nexus
Any physical presence in the state
Wayfair decision
What is the Wayfair decision
Business must collect sales tax and remit it to the state (has sales tax nexus) if they have at least $100,000 in sales or at least 200 transactions a year in that state.
What is sales tax on?
Tangible personal property, not services
Who pays use tax
The buyer when they buy an item in another state that has a lower tax than the state they use the item in and the seller did not collect the additional tax, or the seller did not collect any tax due to lack of nexus in the case of online dealers.
What criteria did the Supreme Court spell out for whether states can tax the income of non-domiciliary companies and to what extent they can tax them.
- Sufficient connection or nexus
- Only a fair portion of business income
- Cannot discriminate against non-resident businesses
- Fairly related to the services the state provides the business
Public Law 86-272
Protects sellers of tangible personal property from income tax nexus if and only if:
1. Tax is based net income (not gross receipts or revenue)
2. Only sells tangible personal property in state (no services)
3. Activities in state are limited to the solicitation of sales
4. Orders are approved outside the state
5. Delivers goods from outside the state via common carrier
Supreme Court determination of activities that constitute solicitation in Public Law 86-272
- Any form of advertising
- Carrying samples and promotional material for display or distribution without charge
- Passing inquiries or complaints to home office
- Checking customer’s inventory for reorder
- Maintaining a sample room for two weeks or less (trade show rule)
- Recruiting, training, and evaluating salespeople in home office or hotels
- Owning or furnishing personal property and autos used in sales activities
Supreme Court determination of activities that do not constitute solicitation in Public Law 86-272
- Making repairs for customers
- Collecting delinquent accounts
- Investigating credit worthiness
- Installing or supervising the installation of sold property
- Training employees other than sales representatives
- Approving or accepting orders
- Repossessing property
- Securing deposits
- Maintaining and office other than a home office
Multi-state Tax Commission (MTC) Factor Presence Nexus Standard for economic nexus for income tax
$50,000 of property or payroll in the state
$500,000 of sales
or
25% of total property, payroll, or sales
Separate tax return state requirements
Require only those businesses/entities with nexus in the state to file an income tax return, even when a group of companies file a consolidated return
Unitary tax return state requirements
Even companies not filing a federal consolidated return can be unitary for state tax purposes.
Include all members meeting the unitary criteria–whether they have nexus or not
What did the Supreme Court identify as factors to determine if a group of businesses in unitary for tax purposes?
- Functional integration (vertical or horizontal integration or knowledge transfer)
- Centralization of management
- Economies of scale (group discounts or other efficiencies due to size)
What does is mean to say unitary concept pervades activities in the entire income tax system?
Includes computing taxable income, computing apportionment percentages, and determining tax return filing requirements
State tax base equals
Federal taxable income +/- State tax adjustments
State (x) taxable income equals
State tax base x (percent apportioned + percent allocated)
Is business income apportioned or allocated?
apportioned