Chapter 12 Flashcards
Mate Competition vs Mate Choice
Mate Competition (intra-sexual selection): when members of one sex compete with one another for mating opportunities
Mate Choice (inter-sexual selection): when members of one sex exhibit distinct mating preferences
Anisogamy VS Isogamy
ANISOGAMY: the existence of differently sized gametes (small and large) in different sexes
ISOGAMY: the production of gametes of the same size by all individuals (algae, fungi)
How did Anisogamy evolve from Isogamy? Explain using the Parker Model
3 Assumptions:
a) In the ancestral marine environment, individuals in a population that retain reproductive compatibility produce different sized gametes
b) Each parent has a fixed amount of energy to allocate to gamete production, resulting in a size-number trade-off: as the number of gametes produced increases, their size decreases
c) Zygote viability is related to its size, larger zygotes have higher viability since they contain more resources for survival
Explanation: Parker’s model suggests that producing small gametes is advantageous since many gametes are produced and large gametes are advantageous since they have high survival. However, intermediate-sized gametes have the lowest fitness. meaning the highest fitness individuals are “proto-males” or “proto-females” (two different reproductive strategies)
Bateman’s Hypothesis VS Triver’s Parental Investment Theory
Bateman’s Hypothesis: female reproductive success is most strongly limited by the number and success of eggs that a female can produce, whereas male reproductive success is limited by the number of mates a male contains (meaning greater variation in male reproductive success and more intense sexual selection on males)
Triver’s Parental Investment Theory: predicts that the sex that pays the higher cost of parental investment should be choosier when it comes to mates, the other sex will then experience more intense sexual selection
T or F: when one sex has greater parental investment, they are are not as sexually receptive as the other sex since they are caring for current offspring, which results in a difference between sexually receptive females and males (operational sex ratio), a large skew in this ratio leads to greater intensity of sexual selection on the non-caring sex, meaning choosy females and a higher variation in male reproductive success
True
Weapons vs Ornaments
Weapons: exaggerated morphological traits used in competition with individuals of the same sex
Ornaments: exaggerated morphological traits used to attract mates
Research 12.1: Weapon Size & Mating Success in Dung Beetles
a) Male dung beetles fight with each other to defend dung piles, where females dig subterranean tunnels to mate and raise their offspring
DUNG BEETLES & HORN SIZE: Research Question
Do large horns provide an advantage in male to male fights?
DUNG BEETLES & HORN SIZE: Methods
a) Staged fights between males in artificial nesting arenas (two panes of glass placed 5mm apart and filled with soil and dung)
b) They placed a single female in the arena, which quickly dug a tunnel
c) Two males, closely matched for body size but not horn length were introduced with the females
d) The winner was deemed to be the males that successfully entered and remained in the tunnel after 24 hours; most winners mated with the female
DUNG BEETLES & HORN SIZE: Conclusion
a) Males tried to hook their horns under their opponent’s head, also using their horns to push opponents out of the tunnel
b) In contests between small beetles, the larger males or the male with the longer horn won most contests
c) In contests between larger beetles, large horn size along was the most important predictor of success
d) Conclusion: the maintenance of long horns in male dung beetles can be explained by sexual selection driven by male-male competition
Research 12.1: Ornaments & Mate Choice in Peafowl
a) Male peacocks possess extremely large tails whose feathers contain brightly coloured ocelli (eyespots)
b) Since males fan out their tail when displaying to females, it seemed likely that female mate choice involves tail morphology
c) Early work showed the females prefer to mate with males that have the most ocelli, males with the most ornamented tails
d) Before peahens select a peacock mate, males must compete to establish and defend a display site, a LEK
e) Many males aggregate on a lek, a location that LACKS resources where they display to females using behaviours like vocalizations and fanning of the tail
PEACOCKS & ORNAMENTS: Methods
a) Captured and colour-banded males and females in early spring
b) They measured each male’s tail length and body size, and counted number of ocelli
c) Recorded male-male interactions during the breeding season, along with number and duration of male tail displays to females (number of vocalizations, copulations)
PEACOCKS & ORNAMENTS: Results
a) They found intense competition for display sites, as only 45 of 61 males successfully defended a site, meaning 25% had little chance to reproduce
b) Found significant positive correlations between the likelihood of defending a display site and both body size and tail length
c) Only 12 males obtained copulations, and over one third of all copulations were obtained by a single male
d) In general, males that had high display rates and the most ocelli obtained the most copulations, although not the largest males
PEACOCKS & ORNAMENTS: Conclusion
a) Both mate competition and mate choice have played a role in the evolution of the peacock tail
b) First, only a subset of males successfully defended a display site, all of which were large individuals (tarsus) with long tails (train)
c) Second, females strongly preferred males with high display rates and tails with many ocelli
d) Together, male competition and female choice have favoured the evolution of males with long, elaborately ornamented tails and high display rates
Research 12.1: Male Mate Choice in Pipefish
a) Males can also be choosy, favouring the evolution of female secondary sexual traits in some species
b) In pipefish, females compete for males that invest heavily in parental care
c) Females transfer their eggs to the males’ egg-brooding structure, the male then fertilizes the eggs and cares for them as they develop, the males become pregnant
d) Males should be the more choosy sex and female-female competition for mates may be intense, also may expect females to display secondary sexual ornaments
e) Female pipefish possess a secondary sexual ornament: a temporary striped pattern on the side of the body that is displayed only during competition between females and when courting males, a courtship dance
f) Normal pipefish body colouration is quite cryptic but the ornament makes the female stand out and so is likely to increase predation risk, making it costly
PIPEFISH & MALE MATE CHOICE: Hypothesis
Males use a sexually selected trait in their mate choice
PIPEFISH & MALE MATE CHOICE: Prediction
Males should spend more time and mate more often with those females that display their temporary striped pattern (ornament) the most
PIPEFISH & MALE MATE CHOICE: Methods
a) Day 1, no interactions were allowed
b) Conducted a simultaneous-choice test with a single male and two enclosed females that were matched for size
c) Recorded the amount of time the male spent in front of each female, how often a female displayed her ornament, and how often the male engaged in a courtship dance with each female
d) Day 2, interactions were allowed
e) Conducted the same experiment but with all dividers removed so that individuals could interact
f) Recorded total time dancing, latency to dance, and copulations with each female
g) Removed and counted all eggs from the male’s brood pouch
PIPEFISH & MALE MATE CHOICE: Results
a) Males spent more total time and time dancing, and had a shorter latency to dance with the female that displayed her ornament more
b) The more ornamented female contained more copulations
Research 12.1: The Sensory Bias Hypothesis in Guppies
a) How does a male trait become a focus of female mate preference?
b) One explanation is the Sensory Bias Hypothesis: female mating preferences are a byproduct of preexisting biases in a female’s sensory system
c) These biases are presumed to have evolved in a non-mating context, with males evolving traits to match those biases
d) Female guppies prefer to mate with males that display the greatest amount of orange colouration, derived from carotenoids obtained in their diet (which play a key role in immune system function), but colourful guppies are also easier for predator to spot
e) In stream populations where predation risk is high, female preference for orange is reduced, and males display less orange body colour than do males in other populations with low predation risk
f) Guppies in the wild are attracted to and consume orange coloured fruits that fall into the water
GUPPIES & SENSORY BIAS HYPOTHESIS: Hypothesis
Guppies have an innate preference for orange food items because they contain carotenoids, and this preexisting bias favours males that display orange colour
GUPPIES & SENSORY BIAS HYPOTHESIS: Prediction
Both male and female guppies should be attracted to orange-coloured objects since their colour is associated with the presence of carotenoids
GUPPIES & SENSORY BIAS HYPOTHESIS: Methods
a) In one set of studies, they placed small discs on a leaf in the water, discs could be red, orange, green, purple, blue, white, yellow, or black
b) They noted all guppy approaches, pecks at objects, and the sex of the individual
c) They also conducted a similar experiment in the laboratory where discs were placed in an aquarium
GUPPIES & SENSORY BIAS HYPOTHESIS: Results
a) Both male and female guppies exhibited a strong attraction to the orange and red discs, and the strength of the preference for orange was correlated with female mating preference for the colour orange
b) In populations with the strongest female preference for orange males, both sexes displayed the strongest attraction to the orange discs
Research 12.6: Mate Copying in Guppies
a)
Research 12.2: Female Choice & Nuptial Gift in Butterflies
a) Nuptial Gift: a physical resource like a food item that an individual provides to a potential mate to enhance mating success
b) Many arthropods provide nuptial gifts before or during mating
c) In some species, females prefer to mate with larger males since they offer larger nuptial gifts
d) Green-veined white butterflies provide a SPERMATOPHORE: sperm packaged within a protein-rich structure produced by male accessory glands, as a nuptial gift
e) Once inside a female, the spermatophore disintegrates, releasing nutrients, which the female can use to reproduce
f) Since adults feed mainly on nectar, the spermatophore can represent an important source of protein
g) The spermatophore can be directly inserted, placed as a capsule, transferred by a spermatophore structure, or placed within a sperm web or sperm packet
BUTTERFLIES & NUPTIAL GIFTS: Research Question
Does female egg production vary positively with the size of the nuptial gift received from a male?
BUTTERFLIES & NUPTIAL GIFTS: Methods
a) Quantified how much resource transferred from the male to the female’s egg production by radioactively labelling leaves that they’d feed males with
b) Calculated the rate the spermatophore disintegrated in the female’s abdomen to calculate the amount of spermatophore the female received
c) Allowed a female to mate with a single mate and lay eggs, which were then collected and dried
d) Female’s eggs, abdomen, and thorax were tested for radioactivity to quantify the amount of male nutrients transferred from the male to the female in the spermatophore
BUTTERFLIES & NUPTIAL GIFTS: Conclusion
a) Females receiving larger spermatophores produced more eggs, showing a direct benefit of male nuptial gift on female fitness
b) Females can benefit directly by mating with males that offer large nuptial gifts
Research 12.2: Female Choice & Territory Quality in Lizards
a) Another direct benefit of mate choice for females is access to high-quality resources defended by a territorial male
b) Males defend territories where they display to females from rock perches, the quality of a territory is based on rockiness, rocks provide perches not only to display to females but also to spot predators
c) Rocks also increase the range of “microclimates” available for thermoregulation, which is important for lizards
d) Previous work demonstrated that offspring growth and survival are greater when females lay eggs within male territories that have many rocks, the highest quality territories
LIZARDS & TERRITORY QUALITY: Research Question
How does territory quality affect female choice and fitness?
LIZARDS & TERRITORY QUALITY: Methods
a) They manipulated territory quality after males had established territories but before females became receptive and selected males
b) Dominant males settled on territories with the most rocks (highest quality)
c) They moved 10-40 rocks from territories of large, dominant males to the territories of small neighbouring males
d) This separated high-quality males from high-quality territories
e) After breeding season, they measured egg mass of each female