Chapter 11: International Laws and Norms Flashcards
Geneva Conventions (Monitored by the International Committee of the Red Cross)
First convention (1864) created rules governing the treatment of wounded soldiers. Second convention (1906) created rules governing the treatment of soldiers at sea. Third convention (1929) created rules governing the treatment of prisoners of war. Fourth convention (1949) revised the previous conventions and added protections for civilians during wartime. All UN member states have ratified the Geneva Conventions
International Law
A body of rules that binds states and other agents in world politics and is considered to have the status of law
-Must include primary and secondary rules
-Primary rules are the negative and positive rules regulating behavior
-Secondary rules are the constitution that structures the making of the primary rules, or rules of how rules are made
EX:
Geneva Conventions
World Trade Organization
UN Convention on the Law of the Sea Treaty
The Responsibility to Protect (R2P)
Developed out of the Canada sponsored International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (2000).
Breaks down traditional norms of state sovereignty that stress non-intervention
States are responsible for protecting the safety and welfare of their citizens.
If states fail to do this, the international community has a responsibility to step in to protect citizens.
Three specific responsibilities (R2P)
The responsibility to prevent
-Addressing political, economic, and legal roots of conflict
The responsibility to react
-Sanctions, legal measures, military action
The responsibility to rebuild
Six criteria for military intervention (R2P)
•Right authority -UN Security Council Chapter VII resolution •Just cause •Right intention •Last resort •Proportional means •Reasonable prospects
When was the R2P invoked in Libya?
R2P was invoked when justifying the NATO intervention in Libya in 2011
•200+ people had been killed in clashes with the government.
•Libyan President Muammar Qaddafi made public statements suggesting a harsh crackdown on the opposition dominated city of Benghazi.
•The UN Security Council invoked R2P and authorized NATO air strikes.
Differences between the Geneva Conventions and R2P
•Geneva Conventions -voluntary and respect state sovereignty. -international law. •R2P -does not respect state sovereignty. -international norm.
International norms don’t have ________ rules.
Secondary
Customary international law (part of International law)
Practices deemed appropriate and corrected by states over long periods of time.
International treaties (part of international law)
Agreements, often based on customs, that are negotiated and ratified by states.
Making International Law (Diplomatic immunity)
Example: Diplomatic immunity
•Began as a long-standing international norm
•Formally codified in the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (1961)
•Diplomats are exempt from a host nation’s laws.
•Intended to avoid politically motivated detention of diplomats.
•Violations of laws are typically handled by sending diplomats home.
•$16 million + in unpaid parking tickets in New York
Making International Law (Crimes against humanity)
- Example: Crimes against humanity
- Includes any of the following acts when they are part of planned, systematic attacks against civilians:
- Murder
- Extermination
- Enslavement
- Deportation or forced population transfer
- Imprisonment or severe deprivation of liberty in violation of fundamental rules of international law.
- Torture
- Rape and other forms of sexual violence
- Persecution against any identifiable group based on political affiliation, race, nationality, culture, religion, or gender
- Enforced disappearance of persons
- Apartheid
Freedom of the seas
- Began as an international custom
- Formally codified in the UN Commission on the Law of the Sea Treaty (UNCLOS) (1982/1994)
- 12 nautical mile territorial sea
- 200 nautical mile exclusive economic zone
- High seas
Characteristics of international laws
- Obligation
- Precision
- Delegation
- Hard and soft laws
Obligation Law
•The degree to which agents are legally bound. •Compliance is unconditional for high-obligation law
-WTO treaties
•Compliance is aspirational for low-obligation laws
-Human rights treaties