Chapter 1 - Overview and Parties Flashcards
Definition of IWT
“the poaching, possession, dealing, transporting, importing/exporting flora and fauna without a relevant permit and/or in contravention of national and international laws” and INCLUDES forest and fisheries crimes
A subset of environmental crime which includes mining, hazardous materials, chemicals, and waste
illegal poaching, smuggling and transport of a specific animal product or species by criminal syndicates or individuals for profit or other material gain
“low risk, high reward crime”
Wildlife crime is estimated as the fourth most profitable crime globally with recent estimates of up to $1-$2 trillion annually
Transnational organized crime groups rely on
- WEAK criminal justice RESPONSE
- Corruption
- DISCONNECTED global law enforcement
Natural Resource Crimes $ Annually, expected increase each year
2016: UNEP - 91-258 billion
2019: World Bank - 1-2 trillion annually
UN - expect this value to increase 5-7% each year
Those involved in the sale of an animal
may not realized they’re a part of an illicit activity, which creates confusion for law enforcement.
Global Initiatives target various parts of the chain:
Taking from the wild
Moving it from wild to consumer
Consumers
Overall law enforcement either
actively enables through corruption or unintentionally enables through lack of capacity
Consequences of IWT
- Increased criminality in the areas where the activities are occurring
- Communities lose revenue (from like ecotourism? or local trading of valuable items?)
- Gov’ts lose money trying to stop the trade
- Undermines legal commerce - fucks with economy (overfishing in Africa - local and law abiding fishers can’t generate revenue)
- Rural households that might depend on over-exploited animals may be deprived of physically and culturally important species (physical - overfishing means they lose their primary source of protein)
- BIODIVERSITY-RELATED - timber loss increases desertification - exacerbates effects of climate change/completely alters the ecosystem
- BIODIVERSITY-RELATED - decreases biodiversity - it’s own entire set of issues
- BIODIVERSITY-RELATED - Increased exposure to zoonotic disease
Definition of transnational
Not just the activities taking place in more than one country, but
when they’re planned in one country and executed in another and
when the effects are “FELT IN MORE THAN ONE STATE”
INTERNATIONAL FRAMEWORKS
CITES
Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora
Founded in 1975, 183 country members
- International Agreement
- Make sure that international trade in wildlife does not threaten their survival
Interesting - sometimes it’s like a subspecies or geographically separate population of a species that’s listed
Appx I - highest level of protection - no commercial trade
Appx II - not threatened yet but may become so without trade controls - export permits required by importing and exporting countries. Includes species that look like other species under threat.
Appx III - a member country has asked, but it’s not necessarily threatened - export permit and certificate of origin required
CITES is legally binding for members. BUT CITES does NOT address the IWT - they just work on regulating trade.
Tricky bit - domestic laws may not protect non-native species, which leaves loopholes that traffickers can exploit]
GLOBAL WILDLIFE CRIME INITIATIVES
ICCWC
International Consortium on Combating Wildlife Crime
(2010)
- Co-ordinates criminal justice system responses and builds global capacity across criminal justice systems.
- Provides support to WENs and law enforcement agencies
(Reps from: UNODC; INTERPOL; World Bank; World Customs Org; CITES)
So while CITES works to regulate the trade of wildlife (with lots of holes), ICCWC co-ordinates the justice system response and builds capacity across them, specifically with WENs
WENs
ICCWC supports these
Wildlife enforcement networks (WENs)
- regional
- INTER-Agency
- INTER-Governmental
- Facilitate information sharing on and tackle cross-border IWT
- Develop and share regional best practices in combating IWT
These are them:
Southeast Asian Nations Wildlife Enforcement Network (ASEAN WEN) - Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Phillipines, Singapore, Vietnam, Thailand
South Asia Wildlife Enforcement Network (SAWEN) - Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka
Central America Wildlife Enforcement Network (CAWEN/ROAVIS) - Belize, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Dominican Republic
South America Wildlife Enforcement Network (SUDWEN) - Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Columbia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru, Venezuela
Horn of Africa, Djibouti, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Uganda
GLOBAL WILDLIFE CRIME INITIATIVES
IUCN
International Union for Conservation of Nature
data on global extinction risk
data dissemination
GLOBAL WILDLIFE CRIME INITIATIVES
UNODC
United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime
assists UN in coordinating response to transnational organized crimes
Works with Member states to:
- strengthen policy
- strengthen legislative and regulatory frameworks
- enhance knowledge and skills
- increase awareness
- enhance cooperation on all levels (global/regional/international)
GLOBAL WILDLIFE CRIME INITIATIVES
UNEP
United Nations Environment Programme
- human-centric perspective
- economic and national security implications
- role of corruption and financial crimes
So a supporting player but not focused directly on IWT
GLOBAL WILDLIFE CRIME INITIATIVES
INTERPOL
Basic - kind of approach
Program kind and breakdown
INTERnational Criminal POLice Organization
(194 state law enforcement agencies)
INTERPOL takes an OPERATIONAL approach toward law enforcement
The have an Environmental Security Program
- Fisheries
- Forestry
- Pollution
- Wildlife