Chapter 1 - Market reforms and commercial (re)insurance contract wordings Flashcards
Referring to the slip as an aid of construction of the wording should run counter to one of the objects of replacing the slip with the policy: namely that the wording is designed specifically to reflect the agreement between the parties more clearly. This has been tested by which case law:
Youell v. Bland Welch (1992) - The slip was held to be inadmissable
Which case law held that a ‘slip policy’ was intended to be the contract of insurance and that a clause included in the slip policy, but not in the subsequent wording, formed a part of the contract?
HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd v. New Hampshire Insurance Co. (2001)
Which three issues with slips led to the introduction of the MRC?
- Subjectivities imposed by an insurer which did not clearly define when they had to be met
- Conditions noted on a slip against an insurer’s written line and whether these were to apply to the insurer’s participation or to all the other insurers on the slip; and
- Changes that could be agreed by the leading insurer on behalf of other insurers
In the UK, the non-subscription market is considered to comprise membership of…
- Association of British Insurers (ABI); and
2. British Insurance Brokers’ Association (BIBA)
What problem did the UK non-subscription market have?
Insurers often failed to maintain appropriate ‘version control’ over their wordings
What 4 other markets in the insurance industry have helped developed how insurance is bought and sold?
- Direct Insurance
- Bancassurers
- Supermarkets and high street retailers
- Online comparison sites (aggregators)
When continental and overseas markets use MRCs it is likely….
…they are subscribing to a risk that is led by a London Market insurer and are signing the MRC for their participating in the risk
A binder used by overseas and continental markets is…
…effectively a one or two page quotation setting out details of the risk, sum insured and any specific conditions and limitations to be noted
If the terms and conditions of a binder quotation are acceptable to the client …
…the broker will instruct the insurer to issue a final binding agreement
In 1999, which three parties agreed to work together to propose reforms to the traditional London Market business processes?
- International Underwriting Association of London (IUA)
- London Market Brokers’ Committee (LMBC - now LIBA)
- Lloyd’s
In 2000, the London Market Principles (LMP) programme included which three things?
- The reform of placing of insurance and reinsurance business through the introduction of a new slip format
- A new Leading Underwriters Agreement
- The principle of contract certainty
From 1st April 2013, the FSA became….
The Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulatory Authority
3 key drivers for change in the UK (re)insurance market include:
- Loss of reputation - poor record in policy issuance
- Legal costs - formal disputes over policy wordings were expensive for both sides
- Other costs:
- Tangible - wasted management time associated with managing legal disputes and costs of correcting errors
- Intangible - Destruction of relationships from higher acquisition costs
The London Market Group (LMG) issued what in a response to the FSA’s challenge in 2005….
…The Code of Practice (October 2005)
This was updated to the Contract Certainty Code of Practice - Principles & Guidance (October 2012)
Contract Certainty Code of Practice - Principles & Guidance (October 2012) is…
…a common approach for the whole UK insurance industry.
It is stated to apply to general insurance contracts either entered into by a UK regulated insurer, or arranged through a UK regulated broker (slip and non-slip business).
Its status remains as industry guidance and it is not intended to be binding on any party.
Contract certainty is….
…achieved by the complete and final agreement of all terms between the insured and the insurer by the time that they enter into the contract, with contract documentation provided promptly thereafter.
Contract Certainty Principle A - When entering into the contract is….
….The insurer and broker (where applicable) must ensure that all terms are clear and unambiguous by the time the offer is made to enter the contract or the offer is accepted. All terms must be clearly expressed, including any conditions or subjectivities.
Contract Certainty Principle B - After entering into the contract is….
Contract documentation must be provided to the Insured promptly
Contract Certainty Principle C - After entering into the contract is
The insurers and brokers (where applicable) must be able to demonstrate their achievement of principles A and B
Contract Certainty Principle D - In respect of contract changes is
Contract changes need to be certain and documented promptly.
Where there Is more than one participating insurer:
Contract Certainty Principle E - When entering Into the contract is
The contract must include an agreed basis on which each insurer’s final participation will be determined. The practice of post-Inception over-placing compromises Contract Certainty and must be avoided.
Where there Is more than one participating insurer:
Contract Certainty Principle F - After entering Into the contract is
After entering Into the contract:
The final participation must be provided to each Insurer promptly.
Where there Is more than one participating insurer:
Contract Certainty Principle G - Where the contract has not met the principles is
The Insurer and broker (where applicable) have a responsibility to resolve exceptions to any of the above principles as soon as practicable and without undue delay.
The three Appendices to the Contract Certainty principles contain guidance regarding…
…subjectivities and signing provisions, and a checklist
What 4 things should a subjectivity set out?
- the condition/action that needs to occur, by whom and to what standard;
- the applicable timescale, if any, within which the condition is to be met;
- the terms which are to apply until the condition Is met; and
- any consequences which follow if the condition is not met.
What does Appendix 2 of the Code provide?
A sample checklist designed to help assess contracts against Principle A: All terms and conditions are clearly and unambiguously expressed.
Appendix 2 of the Code encourages organisations to..
…develop their own versions tailored to their particular businesses.
The list may also serve as a reminder as to the content of particular contracts. For example, has a law and jurisdiction clause or a several liability clause been included? Is the contract compliant with any regulatory requirements?
What does a several liability clause provide?
That a subscribing insurer’s obligations under the contract are several, not joint, and are limited solely to the extent of their individual subscription.
In other words, they do not extend to a co-subscriber’s subscription if, for any reason, that co-subscriber does not satisfy all or part of their obligation.
Appendix 3 of the Code sets out…
Signing Provisions
A carrier’s participation should be clearly determined as required by which principle…
Principle E (For subscription contracts, signing provisions are recommended.
Written lines are typically,,
to stand or un-annoated
Written lines that may be subject to change in the event of over-placement of the contract by the broker are…
…un-annoted
What type of model provision is this:
In the event that the written lines hereon exceed 100% of the order. any lines written ‘lo stand’ will be allocated In full and all other lines will be signed down In equal proportions so that the aggregate signed lines are equal to 100% of the order without further agreement of any of the Insurers.
However:
a. In the event that the placement of the order Is not completed by the commencement date of tho period of Insurance then all lines written by that date will be signed in full;
b. the Insured may elect for the disproportionate signing of Insurers’ lines, without further specific agreement of Insurers, providing that any such variation Is made prior to the commencement date of the period of Insurance, and that lines written ‘to stand’ may not be varied without the documented agreement of those Insurers.
c. The signed lines resulting from the application of the above provisions can be varied, before or after the commencement date of the period of Insurance, by the documented agreement of the Insured and all Insurers whose lines are to be varied. The variation of the contracts will take effect only when all such Insurers have agreed, with the resulting variation In signed lines commencing from the date set out In that agreement.
With Disproportionate signing
What type of model provision is this:
In the event that the written lines hereon exceed 100% of the order. any lines written ‘lo stand’ will be allocated In full and all other lines will be signed down In equal proportions so that the aggregate signed lines are equal to 100% of the order without further agreement of any of the Insurers.
However:
a. In the event that the placement of the order Is not completed by the commencement date of tho period of Insurance then all lines written by that date will be signed in full;
b. The signed lines resulting from the application of the above provisions can be varied, before or after the commencement date of the period of Insurance, by the documented agreement of the Insured and all Insurers whose lines are to be varied. The variation of the contracts will take effect only when all such Insurers have agreed, with the resulting variation In signed lines commencing from the date set out In that agreement.
Without Disproportionate signing
In the model provision that allows disproportionate signing, signed lines for each contract are set out at what point?
at the conclusion of the placement or, if later, the commencement date of the period of (re)insurance. Any subsequent variation must be agreed between the (re)insured and all of those (re)insurers whose lines are to be varied.
If lines totalling 120% are written with 40% of those lines ‘to stand’ on a contract which Includes a Disproportionate Signing provision, how should the lnsured’s broker must sign down the lines?
The lines totalling 80% not written to ‘to stand’, to 60%.
It remains free to choose whether to sign all of those lines down by a quarter (that is, proportionately), or to do so disproportionately according to whatever criteria suits.
Are contract certainty and contract clarity the same?
No
Whilst the objective of (the code of practice of) contract certainty is to provide clarity for both customer and (re)insurer 011 the terms and conditions prior to inception, it is often taken to mean…
…contract evidence. In other words, the customer and (re)lnsurer have agreed a full written contract at inception, and no more.
t is not necessarily the case that, at inception, each party’s intention mirrors that of the other, and that that agreed intention has been reduced to writing in clear and unambiguous terms to achieve…
…contract clarity
There will be evidence of the contract in the form of…
…an agreed wording.
To deal with inconsistencies with non-standard slips, what was introduced in 2002?
a standardized LMP slip
The LMP slip was mandated by….. or business incepting from……and recommended by ……. to …….
he LMP slip was mandated by the Franchise Board at Lloyd’s for business incepting from the 2 January 2004, and recommended by the IUA and the LMBC to its members.
One of the key provisions of the LMP slip was that…
the fully claused wording must be attached to the slip or all clauses fully referenced.
What replaced the LMP April 2005 slip and what subsequently replaced that?
In June 2006, the Market Reform Slip (MRS) and was in turn replaced by the MRC.
When did the MRC standard become mandatory for open market business f
1 November 2007
What are three main forms of Market Reform Contract:
- open market;
- binding authority; and
- lineslips.
In support of each form of Market Reform Contract is
n MRC standard for documenting and agreeing contract changes (that Is, the Market Reform Contract Endorsement or MRCE). Additionally, their content Is compatible with ACORD standards.
What does ACORD stand for:
ACORD (Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development) is the global standards-setting body for the insurance and related financial services industries
What 4 things should an Open Market MRC be used for:
- all firm quote and firm order open market insurance and reinsurance business placed by London Market brokers;
- all marine open cargo covers and the declarations attaching to them (marine open cargo covers are defined as those risks where the insured has, or is expected to acquire, an insurable interest in each declaration bound);
- declarations or off-slips attaching to line-slips where the use of MRC (Lineslip Declarations) is not appropriate; and
- declarations off limited binding authority agreements, where appropriate.
General guidance as to the use of the Open Market MRC includes: Currency Acronyms Contract terms Reference to Subjectivities Contract Provisions
- The currency of any monetary amounts should be identified by the relevant three-letter ISO currency code - for example, GBP for British pounds sterling and USO for United States dollars - rather than symbols such as£ or$.
- Acronyms - for example, TBA (to be agreed/advised?) - or any other terms which are ambiguous or non-specific should not be used.
- All contract terms should be clearly stated and any standard registered wordings or clauses should be referenced or attached. All bespoke and non-standard wordings and clauses must be attached in full.
- The contract should make reference to the need to attach any notice required by local laws to a contract after it has been agreed by the insurer and before It is provided to the insured (for example, US surplus lines brokers must attach notices in state-prescribed forms to surplus lines contracts).
- Any outstanding subjectivities stated in the contract must be expressed as unambiguous conditions and, as we discussed in section A4C, must specify the responsibilities and timescales for resolution and the consequences of failure to do so.
- Standard contract provisions must be relevant to the risk or the administration of that risk.
Open Market MRC is in how many sections?
6: Risk details Information Security details Subscription agreement Fiscal and Regulatory Broker remuneration and deductions
What section of the OM MRC sets out the details of the risk/contract involved, such as insured, type, coverage,
conditions etc.
Risk Details
What 12 headings are mandatory on an OM MRC:
UMR Type Period Interest Limit of Liability Situation Conditions Choice of Law and Jurisdiction Premium Premium payment terms Taxes payable by the insured and administered by the insurer Insurer contract documentation
OM MRC: Situation includes…
Situation, territorial limits or scope, trading warranties or location
OM MRC: Conditions includes…
The full wording (Including all clauses and any amendments, qualifications, variation or similar) should be entered or referenced here. Further, the contract document must
reference or attach in full all wordings and clauses. If referenced, they must be readily available to the broker and all carriers.
OM MRC: Taxes payable by the insured and administered by the insurer
includes…
Here, ‘payable by’ refers to the party bearing the economic cost of the tax, and
‘administered by’ to the party responsible for settling the tax with the relevant authority. Examples Include: insurance premium taxes and stamp duties
OM MRC: Insurer contract documentation includes…
Either a copy of the contract document or an Insurance policy for open market risks
What section of the OM MRC would Include descriptions of the business activities, turnover details of a particular insured, and claims history.
Information
What is required to establish the individual (several), not joint, liability of each insurer or syndicate member if there is more than one subscriber to the risk, or the insurer is a Lloyd’s syndicate?
a several liability clause
What has been agreed for use on open market risks and, according to the standard, should be reproduced in full, not referenced where there is more than one subscriber to the risk?
Several Liability and Attestation clause (LMA 3333)
Where would a several liability clause be found in an Open Market MRC?
security details
What clause is this:
The liability of a (re)lnsurer under this contract Is several and not Joint with other (re)lnsurers party to this contract. A (re)lnsurer Is liable only for the proportion of llablllty it has underwritten. A (re)lnsurer Is not jointly liable for the proportion of liablllty underwritten by any other (re)insurer. Nor Is a (re)insurer otherwise responsible for any liability of any other (re)lnsurer that may underwrite this contract.
The proportion of liablllty under this contract underwritten by a (re)lnsurer (or. In the case of a Lloyd’s syndicate, the total of the proportions underwritten by all the members of the syndicate taken together) Is shown next to Its stamp. This Is subject always to the provision concerning “signing” below.
In the case of a Lloyd’s syndicate, each member of the syndicate (rather than the syndicate itself) Is a (re)insurer. Each member has underwrillen a proportion of the total shown for the syndicate (that total itself being the total of the proportions underwritten by all the members of the syndicate taken together). The liability of each member of the syndicate Is several and not joint with other members. A member Is liable only for that member’s proportion. A member Is not Jointly liable for any other member’s proportion. Nor Is any member otherwise responsible for any liability of any other (re)lnsurer that may underwrite this contract. The business address of each member Is Lloyd’s, One Lime Street, London EC3M 7HA. The Identity of each member of a Lloyd’s syndicate and their respective proportion may be obtained by writing to Market Services, Lloyd’s, at the above address.
Proportion of liability
Unless there Is “signing” (see below), the proportion of liability under this contract underwrillen by each (re)lnsurer (or, In the case of a Lloyd’s syndicate, the total of the proportions underwritten by all the members of the syndicate taken together) Is shown next to Its stamp and Is referred to as Its “written line•.
Where this contract permits, written lines, or certain written lines, may be adjusted (“signed”). In t11at case a schedule Is to be appended to this contract to show the definitive proportion of liability under this contract underwritten by each (re)lnsurer (or, In the case of a Lloyd’s syndicate, the total of the proportions underwritten by all the members of the syndicate taken together). A definitive proportion (or, In the case ol a Lloyd’s syndicate, the total of the proportions underwritten by all the members of a Lloyd’s syndicate taken together) Is referred to as a
“signed line”. The signed lines shown In the schedule will prevail over the written lines unless a proven error In calculation has occurred.
Although reference Is made at various points in this clause to “this contract• In the singular, where the circumstances so require this should be read as a reference to contracts In the plural.
(Re)insurers liability clause (LMA 3333)
(Re)insurer’s liability several not joint
What section of the Open Market MRC details the order (if known prior to placement), the basis of the written and the signed lines, and the signing provisions
Security Details
It is recommended that, if the order is not known, written lines are expressed as…
percentages of the monetary limit (for example, 25°/o of US$1 million) whether they are to be expressed as a percentage of the whole or of order.
Typically, written lines are expressed as
percentages of whole, order, or of part (that Is, where the orders are rnonetaiy amounts).
There Is no need to reference the basis of the signed lines unless It differs from that of the written lines. This is most likely to be relevant for….
…quota share or excess of loss treaty reinsurance.
At the end of the Security Details section, under the heading ‘Written Lines’, each (re)insurer places its stamp to Identify:
- the particular company or entity (re)insuring, and to which an underwriting reference is usually annotated; and
- Its written line to identify the proportion of the risk it Is prepared to underwrite.
Who should clearly identify all underlying insurers and their respective proportions under Security Details:
Consortia and Agencies
Where is this text found and what does it do:
In a co-insurance placement, following (re)insurers may, but are not obliged to, follow the premium charged by the slip leader.
(Re)insurers may not seek to guarantee for themselves terms as favourable as those which others subsequently achieve during the placement.
Security details under the heading ‘Written Lines’
It enables a single MRC to handle placements with multiple insurers on different terms.
The final part of Security details section has three tables which detail….
- Unacceptable line conditions, for example, ‘wording to be agreed’ for the obvious reason that wordings should be agreed before an insurer commits to the contract;
- Unnecessary line. conditions, as provision is made for them elsewhere In the contract. For example, ‘SDD 14/11/05’ intended to indicate the expected premium payment date because It should appear under the Settlement Due Date heading in the Subscription Agreement Section, and ‘Excluding Hull War’ because such a condition should be articulated in the Risk Details section.
Acceptable lines conditions - ‘line to stand’ and ‘excluding Letters of Credit and Outstanding Claims Advances (and/or for incurred but not reported losses’. The latter condition is peculiar to reinsurance business.
How do you Imagine the guidance under Security details would classily a line condition stating:
‘Warranted premium payable within 60 days of inception’?
Unnecessary line. condition - This is a premium payment term that should be under the premium payment terms heading section in the risk details section
What section in the Open Market MRC documents all of the inter and intra-market arrangements that will operate between the subscribers to the risk?
Subscription Agreement.
These are in relation to the agreement of contract changes, claims, the collection of expert fees, the payment of premiums and the use of third party service providers.
Here, any applicable market agreements for the agreement of contract changes and claims, must be referenced, and the relevant agreement parties identified. Equally, those (re)insurers agreeing for their proportion only should also be stated.
Subscription Agreement
Contract changes are typically the subject of
a General Underwriters Agreement (GUA).
Claims will be the subject of a….. if there are any subscribing Lloyd’s syndicates, or the ….., if there are any subscribing bureau company underwriters.
Lloyd’s Claims Scheme and IUA claims agreement practices
Is the SDD a policy condition such as a premium payment warranty or condition?
No it is a term of trade, an accommodation to the broker
Under subscription agreements periods of credit for subsequent premium instalments and adjustments must also be stated and are usually
120 days
Two mandatory fields under subscription agreement are …
dealing with the payment of premiums (bureaux arrangements) and claims
(claims administration).
What section in the Open Market MRC deals with fiscal and regulatory Issues specific to the parties.
Fiscal and regulatory
The fiscal and regulatory section in the open Market MRC identifies:
any taxes or charges which are payable by the insurer (for example, income taxes, parafiscal levies, withholding taxes and other taxes such as fire brigade taxes).
the country in which the policyholder is resident, if a private individual, or has its main operating address, if a corporate body.
Any taxes payable by the insured should be included in what section in the open Market MRC
the risk details section
Two Mandatory headings under Fiscal and Regulatory are:
Overseas Broker and Regulatory Client Classification.
There are also various disclosures to be made if the business originates from, or involves, the USA.
The Fiscal and Regulatory section should state what in relation to Lloyd’s placements…
the risk code and the split of premium for each for signing purposes.
The 5 options under Regulatory Client Classification in Fiscal and Regulatory are:
Consumer Commercial Customer Large Risk Group Risks Reinsurance
Consumers include:
Either
(1) private individuals,
(2) small businesses, commonly referred to as microenterprises,
(3) other small non-business organisations, or
(4) any other entity that would be considered a consumer by the relevant regulatory authority In the local territory.
Commercial customers include:
A customer who Is not a consumer. This classification must not be used If the contract Insures a ‘large risk’.
Large Risks include:
A contract insuring:
• Railway rolling stock, aircraft, ships, goods In transit, aircraft liability or liability of ships
• Certain credit or suretyship risk; and
• Land vehicles (other than railway rolling stock), fire and natural forces, other than damage to property, motor vehicle liability, general liability and miscellaneous financial loss, insofar as the policyholder exceeds at least two of the following criteria:
- balance sheet total euros 6.2 million;
- net turnover euros 12.8 million; and
- average number of employees during the financial year of 250.
Group risks include:
A group policy sold to a customer (consumer, commercial or large risk) for the benefit of policyholders in relation to their common employment, occupation or activity.
What section of the open market MRC contains information relating to brokerage, fees and other deduc1ions from the premium.
Broker remuneration and deductions
Brokers are ‘strongly encouraged’ to disclose what in the Broker remuneration and deductions section?
whether or not a fee Is payable by its client.