Ch 4 Human Variation and Adaptation Flashcards
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach
- Classified humans into 5 races
- “White, yellow, red, black, brown”
The Concept of Race
- In biology a category with subspecies
- Based on distinctive physiological, morphological, and ecological features
- Easily observed differences among humans from major geographic areas
The Concept of Race: What’s wrong with that? (2)
- Look at its enormous sociocultural significance
- Look at why it doesn’t hold up biologically
The Concept of Race: Where do we draw the Line?
- Easy to see extremes – what about all the variation in the middle?
- “Falls apart” when we start to draw lines
- Occurs on a continuous spectrum, not ‘present vs. absent’ but ‘more vs. less’
- Difficult whether we divide people into 3, 5 or even 30 ‘micro’-races
The Concept of Race: Who gets to draw the Line?
- Many examples of dominate group using race for oppression, subjugation, sterilization and genocide
Ex. eugenics movement
Human Polymorphisms
- Loci with more than one allele (ex. ABO blood type)
- Examining single traits can help when looking at natural section or gene flow, but are limited
- Studying several traits simultaneously helps us understand relationships between populations
- Examining these traits can tell anthropologists lots about our history
Alberta Sexual Sterilization
- Drafted under the guises of protecting the gene pool
- Sterilizing mentally unwell people to prevent the passing of mental illness
- Criminal behaviours, mental illness, prostitution etc. all deemed mental illnesses
- There was a fear that the gene pool would be weakened if these “not normal” people were allowed to “breed”
- Lied to about the fact they would be ‘sterilized’ during another operation (ex. Dental work)
- Women, men, children
Considerations about Race:
Human Populations are Heterogeneous
- We recognize there is variation between different human populations
- Discrediting the notion of race does NOT mean scientists are suggesting there are no phenotypic or genetic differences
Considerations about Race:
Polygenic traits are difficult to measure accurately
- Skin pigmentation is difficult to measure accurately
- What/ how are you counting?
- Hard to determine how much was genetic versus how much was environmental
Considerations about Race:
Discrete Boundaries
- A continuously varying trait has no inherently meaningful boundaries!
- Boundaries are always arbitrary and thus subject to bias
Considerations about Race:
Traits are not linked
- Features ascribed to different races do not co- occur together – they are not phenotypic or genotypic clusters
- Ex skin color, hair colour & texture, facial physiognomy all occur on different chromosomes through different alleles, therefore they do not co vary
Considerations about Race:
Specific # of traits cannot define a race
- How many features are necessary to assign race?
- It is arbitrary; there is no agreement on how many differences it takes
- No single feature can clearly assign race
- No ‘race’ has exclusive possession of any particular variant of a gene or genes
Considerations about Race:
Genetic Diversity
- How much genetic diversity actually matters?
- Lewontin (1972) study – over 85% of genetic diversity occurs among individuals within populations
Considerations about Race:
Gene flow
- Populations are genetically “open,” meaning that genes flow between them
- No fixed racial groups can ever exist
- Humans have always inbred
Cline
- A gradient over which the frequency of expression of a trait changes
- Create a map of changes in trait expression based on measured frequencies
- “There are no races, there are only clines.”
- Ex. sickle-cell anemia cline