Ch 2 Ethics and Governance Scandals Flashcards
What is the typical pattern associated with scandals and resulting reforms?
- Scandal outrages public
- Public tolerance diminishes
- Credibility of corporations is eroded
- Lawmakers, regulators, directors, and professional bodies respond to restore confidence
What was at the heart of the Enron scandal?
Failure of BOD
What was at the heart of Arthur Andersen’s downfall?
An organizational culture gone awry
What was at the heart of the WorldCom scandal?
Power in hands of one man
What was at the heart of the subprime mortgage meltdown?
Greed without due diligence
What were three key reforms in response to all the scandals?
- SOX
- Circular 230 (new professional standards on tax preparers and advisors)
- Dodd Frank Act
In 1933, why was the Glass-Steagall Act passed?
To control bank speculation and protect investor deposits
In 2010, what was the passage of the Dodd Frank Act in response to?
Response to subprime lending problems
In 1999, what did the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act repeal?
Glass-Steagall Act
What was the stock market crash/great depression a result of?
- Widespread speculation
- Inadequate financial reporting
- Inadequate banking controls
As a result of the spectacular stock market crash in 1929, the government implemented the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as well as which of the following acts:
a) Glass Steagall Act
b) Investment Advisers Act
c) Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act
d) All of the above
e) Two of the above
e) Two of the above (Glass Steagall and Investment Advisers Act)
What does the Securities Act of 1933 require from companies raising money from the public?
- Register with SeC
- Follow SEC regulations reissuing securities, providing information to investors
- Requires audit certification by independent accountant
What did the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 create?
Created regulatory framework for trading of stocks and bonds of registered companies
What did the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 separate?
Separates investment banks from commercial banks to prevent bank failures (i.e. to prevent commercial banks from engaging in speculative practices)
What did the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 create?
Created framework for registration and regulation of investment advisors
Between 1970 and 1990, what movements arose?
- Environmentalism
- Consumerism (e.g. Ralph Nader)
- Socially responsible investing
- Anti-bribery
- Regulation concerning child labor, fair wages, fair trade, sweatshops
- Corporate stakeholders
Name a scandal related to accounting fraud.
- Aurora Foods
- Sunbeam
- WM
- Adelphia
- Xerox
What did AA do in 1954 that started to shift its organizational culture?
Expanded from providing accounting and audit services to providing consulting services (to the very same firms it was auditing)
True or false.
By 1984, AA’s consulting services revenue was greater than audit service revenue.
True
What was the prime motivation behind the decisions of AA’s audit partners on the Enron, WorldCom, WM, and Sunbeam audits?
- Revenue generation and client retention
- Partners more interested in serving their own interest than serving the public
During the 1980s, how did the culture of integrity at AA change?
- Revenue generation became key to promotion
- Focus was on providing non-audit services to management
- Pressure to reduce audit costs increased
- Audit partners allowed to override rulings of quality control partners
Did the AA partner in charge challenge Enron’s accounting policies?
No
True or false.
AA was providing both audit and consulting services to Enron, and was deriving more revenue from providing management services.
True
Why should an auditor make decisions in the public interest rather than in the interest of management or current shareholders?
Auditors responsibility is to the public
Why didn’t the AA partners responsible for quality control stop the flawed decisions of the audit partners?
- Tried via memos
- But firm’s governance structure had earlier determined that audit partner in charge could override quality control partner’s decisions
In March of 2002, what did the SEC announce?
It was investigating AA for audit deficiencies w/r/t Enron audit
What did AA’s lawyer seem to encourage the Enron audit team to do?
Shredding documents
Should all of AA have suffered for the actions or inactions of under 100 people?
- Seems unfair to many innocent partners and staff
- Society was not well-served by loss of one of the Big 5
- But disappearance of AA sent a clear message
Which of AA personnel should have been prosecuted?
- Larger fine and imprisonment for AA decision makers like audit partners
- Plus a very large fine and sanctions for continuing firm
How was Enron founded?
Founded by Ken Lay in 1985 as a result of merger of two natural gas pipeline companies
Although Enron’s core business was selling gas, what did it move into?
Energy futures market
How did Enron record revenues from the energy futures market?
Recorded revenue in current period rather than period in which gas delivered (“prepays”)
Were the special purpose enterprises established to invest in Enron’s capital-intensive energy projects independent of Enron?
No
What was the impact of Enron’s aggressive accounting methods?
Artificially inflated revenues while understating liabilities
What did an internal and external investigation of Enron reveal?
BOD failed to provide oversight and governance
- Permitted Enron executives to not record material off the book liabilities through use of SPEs
- Paid executive compensation to senior executives, often w/o proper approval
- Permitted executives to engage in high risk accounting transactions and inappropriate conflicts of interest
True or false.
Enron BODs failed to ensure the independence of Enron’s auditor’s, AA, and chose to ignore the complaints of various whistleblowers.
True
What was the aftermath of the Enron scandal?
- Tens of thousands of employees lost jobs
- Millions of investors lost millions of dollars
- Ten key employees indicted and sent to prison although Ken Lay died before sentencing
- AA convicted of obstruction of justice w/i the year
- Congress would enact SOX
Ken Lay was the Chair of the Board and the CEO for much of the time. How did this probably contribute to lack of proper governance?
- Not an effective overseer of his own CEO actions as a good independent Chair of the Board should
- Inherent conflict of interest
At Enron, why didn’t more whistleblowers come forward, and why didn’t some make a significant difference?
- Fear of retaliation
- Poor tone at the top
At Enron, what should the internal auditors have done that might have assisted the directors?
- Should have been alert for flaws in Enron’s conflict of interest policies