Burglary Flashcards
Burglary is an offence under….?
s.9 of the Theft Act 1968
What are the two different ways that s.9 can be committed?
Under s9(1)(a) a person is guilty of burglary if he enters any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal, inflict GBH, or do unlawful criminal damage to the building or anything in it
Under s.9(1)(b) a person is guilty of burglary if having entered a building or part of a building as a trespasser, and then he steals or attempts to steal anything in the building or inflicts or attempts to inflict SBH on any person in the building.
What is S.9(1)(a)
Under s9(1)(a) a person is guilty of burglary if he enters any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal, inflict GBH, or do unlawful criminal damage to the building or anything in it
What is s9(1)(b)
Under s.9(1)(b) a person is guilty of burglary if having entered a building or part of a building as a trespasser, and then he steals or attempts to steal anything in the building or inflicts or attempts to inflict SBH on any person in the building.
What are the 3 common elements between s.9(1)(a) and (b)?
- entry
- of a building or part of a building
- as a trespasser
What is the difference between the subsections?
the intention of the defendant at the time of entry.
Under (1)(a) D must intend to -steal -inflict GBH -do unlawful damage upon entering
Under (1)(b) what the defendant intends upon entry is irrelevant, but the prosecution must prove that he actually committed or attempted to commit theft or GBH
What is not defined under the Theft Act 1968?
Entry
While entry was not defined in the Theft Act 1968, several cases have decided on the meaning of the word. What was the first main case on this point?
Collins 1972
What happened in the case of Collins?
D, naked, climbed a ladder to a random girls window. V thought he was her boyfriend, invited him in and had sex. Collins conviction for burglary was quashed the COA held that the jury had to be satisfied that D had mad an ‘effective and substantial entry.’ He had consent.
D, naked, climbed a ladder to a random girls window. V thought he was her boyfriend, invited him in and had sex. Collins conviction for burglary was quashed the COA held that the jury had to be satisfied that D had mad an ‘effective and substantial entry.’ He had consent.
What case is this?
Collins
What case modified the concept of “effective and substantial entry’ to ‘effective entry’ after the case of Collins?
Brown
What happened in the case of Brown?
D leaned through a shop window while still standing on the outside ground. COA held that the word ‘substantial’ did not meet the definition of entry and his conviction for burglary was upheld as his entry was effective
D leaned through a shop window while still standing on the outside ground. COA held that the word ‘substantial’ did not meet the definition of entry and his conviction for burglary was upheld as his entry was effective
What case is this?
Brown
In what case does the ‘effective entry’ test set by Brown as modified from Collins not appear to have been followed?
Ryan
What happened in the case of Ryan?
D was trapped while going through a window to a house. Part of his body was still outside. The COA upheld conviction as there was evidence on which the jury could find that the defendant had entered
D was trapped while going through a window to a house. Part of his body was still outside. The COA upheld conviction as there was evidence on which the jury could find that the defendant had entered
What case is this?
Ryan
What are the three cases which establish was entry is?
- Collins
- Brown
- Ryan
What gives an extended meaning to the word “building”?
the Theft Act 1968
The Theft Act 1968 has extended the meaning to the word “Building” so that it includes….?
inhabited places such as houseboats or caravans which would otherwise not be included in the offence
Although the Theft Act 1968 has extended the meaning of building so that it includes inhabited places such as houseboats or caravans- would does it not give?
a basic definition for building