Building A Better World Flashcards
What does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) argue that Spiritualism did no do after the Victorian and Edwardian period?
Die out, it lasted long after these periods and flourished particularly in between the wars
Who does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) argue Spiritualism gave comfort to?
Many people who had lost loved ones in WW1
What presumption do most historians have of the period between the wars?
That secularism was dominant during it
What idea does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) challenge?
Te idea that there was a steady decline of popular religious belief in the interwar period
Why does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) argue spiritualism was of great interest during the wars?
It was able to adopt to modern ideas, which it incorporated with traditional beliefs and superstitions
Due to declining birth-rates after WW1 what emphasis began to be placed on women?
Women as mothers, rather than wives, domestication
What does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) argue post-Victorian spiritualism was not?
A pathological response to the late nineteenth century crisis of faith
What does Jenny Hazelgrove in Spiritualism and British Society between the Wars (2000) argue spiritualists relationship to modernity was?
It was buried in, but not undone by, modernity
What did the British consistently believe in?
Banshees, guardian angels, and haunting, namely he proof of communication between spirits and humans
What have historians previously done with British spiritualism?
Ignored it
What classes did spiritualism usually appeal to?
Working classes
When was the Panacea Society founded? And by who?
1919 by Mabel Barltrop
Why did Mabel rename herself Octavia?
She believed she was the daughter of God
How many people did the Panacea’s healing ministry reach out to?
130,000
What was the main belief of the Panacea community? And what was its main aim?
Main belief was understanding God as feminine as well as masculine
Main aim was to prepare for immortal life and Jesus’ rebirth
What is the Panacea Society an example of?
A closed and inward looking community
What question did the Panacea face about modernity?
How much to conform to the modern world and modernity
Why does Jane Shaw in Octavia, Daughter of God (2011) argue the Panacea society represented modernity itself?
The opportunities they offered to women, their theology and eclectic mixture of beliefs
What was Mabel’s chief concern about the teachings of the CofE?
Taught the salvation of the soul but not of the body
What was Mabel diagnosed with when she went into a mental hospital before her husbands death?
Melancholy and domestic worry
What role did Southcott give women in the redemption of the world?
A distinctive role as the final redeemer, because Eve had been the original cause of the fall
What was the name of the leader of the earlier movement and the Book of Revelation that inspired the Panaceans?
Joanna Southcott
What did the war give impetus to? And why?
Southcottian revival - thought this was a time of national trial and tribulation
What was a common reason for sectioning women in late 19th century?
Religious reasons
What did Doctors argue spiritualism was causing?
Mental illness and hysteria
What happened to many women liberated by their involvement in new religions, who were frustrated by Christianity’s subjugation of women?
They were sectioned
Who was Mabel thought to be?
Shiloh and spiritual child of Southcott
Why was the popularity of the Panacean movement not surprising?
No NHS and many illnesses untreatable, also aftermath of flu
Were there many other popular spiritual healing groups around?
Yes, C of E had one
Where did the Panaceans unusually have quite a few healing patients?
India, but all over the Empire
What did the healing mission provide?
Hook and bait to the movement
What were reports in newspapers like of the Panaceans?
Were unfavourable but caused great interest
What did the water takers end up doing to the Panacean movement?
Diluted it
What was the Panacea museum an important vehicle for?
Publicising the healing and movement
How did the Panacea society feel about birth control?
Condemned it, cessation of intercourse was preferable
What did war mean for sex?
Sexual freedom, because of an urgency to marry and have sex people were freer, this freedom did not disappear after the war
What did letters to the Panacea Society in Jane Shaw’s Octavia, Daughter of God (2011) show the ideal of marrying for love and companionship was?
Popular, utopian ring to it, people imagining new possibilities for married life
Which two countries vied with one another to be known as the homeland of the industrial revolution?
Britain and Germany
What was Britain a wellspring for?
Modernity
What does Bernhard Rieger in Technology and the Culture of Modernity (2005) say debates about technologies always carried with them?
An undercurrent of tribulation, heralded the advent of a new age but also threatened new dangers
What did Germany and Britain compete with each other to produce?
Fastest ships, highest flying planes, most popular films
Why did the British support technological advancement?
Because they thought it would ensure the status quo of imperial dominance and head off decline and disintergration
What received a crippling below in WW1 according to Kees Gispen?
Nineteenth century belief in progress
What remained exempt from the loss of belief in progress and pessimism?
Technology
How does Kees Gispen describe the mixed tensions between technological optimism and fears of decline and cultural pessimism?
He says they formed ‘a witch’s brew of positive and neative energies’
If technological innovation was the underlying cause of most fears about modernity, what does Bernhard Rieger in Technology and the Culture of Modernity (2005) wonder?
How technology escaped criticism and remained the idol of European civilization
What aura does Bernhard Rieger in Technology and the Culture of Modernity (2005) argue surrounded new technologies and why?
An aura of “modern wonders” mysterious by definition, creating both excitement and insecurity - people did not fully understand how technology worked
What were anxieties about technological innovation encouraged by?
Spectacular calamities such as the titanic in 1912 and The Hindenburg in 1937
When did fear of technology really become dominant?
1945
What three conditions does Bernhard Rieger in Technology and the Culture of Modernity (2005) say caused public support for technology?
1 - cacophonous chorus - public debated pros and cons of modern technology producing a basic “social consensus” about its importance
2 - powerful social fantasies about heroism of pilots and glamour and luxury of ocean liners
3 - Belief that new technology was the key to national strength
What were the Panaceans an example of?
Seekers in society, seeking a better future
What characteristic figure of modernity in 20s 30s seemed to encapsulate the spirit of the age?
The flyer