Biological Paradigms Flashcards
What are the two fundamental biological paradigms?
- Mechanism/atomism
- Vitalism
How is life explained through mechanism/atomism?
Life can be explained by actions of physical, chemical, and electrical forces
What is the central dogma of biology according to mechanism?
Life is complex carbon based chemistry and DNA ultimately codes for life processes
The “whole is equal to the sum of its parts” is part of what biological paradigm?
Mechanical/atomism
T/F: Life and its functions depend on a “vital influence” which is Physical in nature
False - Vital influence is Non Physical in nature
What does Vitalism derive from?
Dualism
What does life equal?
Life = chemistry “animated” by a spirit/force
T/F: Vitalism is not an inclusive doctrine
False - it IS inclusive - matter/chemistry + the additional influence of a seperate, non physical entity or field
What are the two versions of Vitalism?
- Extreme vitalism aka naive vitalism
- Moderate vitalism aka critical vitalism
What version of vitalism is the presence in living systems of a substantial entity that imparts to the system powers possessed by no inanimate body?
Extreme (naive) vitalism
What vitalism is the “ghost in the machine”?
Extreme (naive) vitalism
What vitalism is the popular doctrine that is reinforced by common sense and everyday language?
Extreme (naive) vitalism
Frankensteins monster is an example of what vitalism?
Extreme (naive) vitalism
What is moderate vitalism also known as?
Critical vitalism
What vitalism believes “life in matter inseparably”?
Moderate (critical) vitalism
T/F: In moderate vitalism, vital forces are never a part of, always apart from, the process of living things
False - Vital forces are ALWAYS part of, NEVER apart from, the process of living things
What immaterial expression (mind) co evolves with the physical structure as an extension of “property” dualism in what vitalism?
Moderate (critical) vitalism
T/F: Life is like an autonomous, mind like, non-spatial entity that exercises control over organic processes in Critical vitalism
True - Critical vitalism aka Moderate vitalism
What are chiropractics “untestable” metaphors?
Universal and innate intelligence
What mechanism is equated with contemporary “organismic” biology?
Moderate mechanism
What is like vitalism that opposes the reduction of biology to physics and chemistry?
Organicism
What is the Szent-Gyorgi experience?
The whole is more than the sum of its parts but NOT due to the addition of a seperate, non physical activity
How can moderate mechanism/organicism be expressed?
The presence in living systems of emergent properties, contingent upon the organization of inanimate parts, but not reducible to them
T/F: Life is epiphenomenal or an emergent property of matter in Moderate mechanism
True