Biological Evaluations Flashcards
Advantage to Lombroso
Gave criminology scientific credibility
Advantage to Lombroso
Research led to criminal profiling
Advantage to Lombroso
Goring (1913) - lower intelligence in convicts, supported lombroso theory
DisAdvantage to Lombroso
Deterministic ( features does not equal criminal)
DisAdvantage to Lombroso
Disfigurements are not inherited, but can affect facial look (not reliable)
DisAdvantage to Lombroso
Scientific racism (western bias)
Advantage to sheldon
Use of control group supported his jdeas
Advantage to sheldon
Gluek & gluek (1965) found that 60% of delinquent sample were mesomorphs (30% of non delinquent sample)
Disadvantage of sheldon
Somatotypes can change
Disadvantage of sheldon
He only studied males (lacks credibility for women)
Advantages of twin studies
Natural occurring variable
Advantages of twin studies
Christiansen (1977) supports link between criminality and twins
Disadvantages of twin
Small sample size may not be representative
Disadvantage of twin
If twins share an environment, criminality could easily be caused by another factor
Advantage of adoption
Studies show there is a correlation between adopted kids and their biological parents