Bioequivalence Flashcards
When did experts realize the importance of bioanalytical assays?
In the mid 1950s (increased recognition that different products with the same amount of active ingredients may have different therapeutic responses)
This is due to manufacturing technique, exipients, environmental conditions, etc.
What was the impetus for the formation of the early form of the FDA?
Sale of a toxic concoction (sulfanilamide+diethylene glycol) that killed 100 people was marketed to be healthy
What happened with the Thalidomide tragedy?
It was used to cure morning sickness in late 1950s, but withdrawn after found to be a cause of birth defects
What was the effect of the 1962 amendments to the FDA?
Added a proof-of-efficacy requirement to new drug approval (new generics had to meet safety, efficacy, and BE criteria)
This effectively halted generic drug industry
What was the effect of the 1984 Drug Price Competition and Patent Term Restoration Act?
Established the ANDA (abbreviated new drug application)
Approval of generics for already proven drugs only need to meet pharmaceutical equivalence and BE (reduced requirements to stimulate generic drug industry)
Are generic drug manufacturers liable for any side effects beyond the side effects for the brand name product?
No, as long as the generic drug manufacturer lists all of the warnings from the brand name manufacturer
What is the definition of pharmaceutical equivalents?
A new drug that, in comparison with another drug, contains identical amounts of the identical medicinal ingredients
Does not necessarily contain the same exipients (similar extent and rate of absorption)
What is the FDA definition of bioavailability?
It is the rate (Tmax, ka) and extent (AUC) to which the active ingredient or moiety is absorbed from a drug product and becomes available at the site of action.
Purposesly avoids system circulation (distribution, no need to measure drug concentrations in time intervals)
What is the Canadian definition of bioavailability?
It is the rate (Tmax, ka) and extent (AUC) of absorption of a drug into the systemic circulation
What is the FDA definition of bioequivalence?
The absence of a significant difference in rate (Tmax, ka) and extent (AUC) to which active ingredient becomes available at site of drug action when administered at the same molar dose
What is the Canadian definition of bioequivalence?
High degree of similarities in the bioavailabilities of two pharmaceutical products from the same molar dose which is unlikely to produce clinically relevent differences in therapeutic effects
*In Canada, we have a more stringent burden of proof on manufacturers to show bioequivalence
What is the basic assumption of bioequivalence?
When a test product is claimed to be bioequivalent it is assumed that the products are therapeutically equivalent and interchangable
Good response to patients questioning the efficacy of generic products
What factors modify bioavailability?
- Physicochemical properties of drug
- Formulation and manufacturing variables
- Physiological factors (differences in GIT regions, variations in pH, GI motility, first pass metabolism)
- Interactions with other substances
What is relative bioavailability?
Extent and rate of bioavailability of drug from two or more different dosage forms given by same route of administration
What is rate of bioavailability?
Represents the apparent absorption rate constant for drug from drug product
Determines time to and height of peak Cp when kd same and absorption complete (Tmax and Cmax are indicators of rate of F)
What is relative optimal bioavailability?
Absorption rate constant, ka from solution (disintegration and dissolution are skipped) is true rate constant
What types of activity require BE studies be performed?
- Any new generic product
- An innovator manufacturer to show product to be marketed is BE with the formulation used in clinical trials
- Following changes to formulation of a drug already on the market
- When considering new route of administration
What types of drug formulations do not need in-vivo bioanalysis studies?
Class I BCS drugs
- Solution intended for IV use
- Topically applied for local use
- Oral dosage form not intended to be absorbed (Cp is not a good indicator for drug affect)
- Administered by inhalation
- Solution, elixir, syrup, tincture, etc. (contains no inactive ingredient known to affect BA)
What are the different types of bioequivalence studies performed by FDA and Health Canada in descending order of preference?
- Pharmacokinetic study (PK-BE)
- Pharmacodynamic study (PD-BE)
- Comparative Clinical Study
- In Vitro Study (need BCS waivers)
When are acute pharmacodynamic studies (PK-BE) performed to show bioequivalency?
Used when PK approach not possible (locally acting drug product)
Uses a pharmacological or clinical endpoint
ex. FEV for inhaled bronchodilators
What are the characteristics of acute pharmacodynamic studies?
- Must be validated (accurate, sensitive, reproducible)
- Requires demonstration of a dose-response curve
- Many PD tests difficult to quantify
- Placebo effects = larger sample size
- PD variability = larger sample size
- Doeses should produce a range of response values
- Instrument measurements should be made under double-blind conditions
When are comparative clinical studies performed to show bioequivalence?
Used when PK or PD approach possible
How do comparative clinical studies show bioequivalency?
Uses a controlled clinical blind or double blind study (BE established through evaluation of clinical response)
Ex. clinical studies showed bioequivalence for antifungal products (Ketoconazole)
What are some disadvantages of using clinical studies to show bioequivalence?
- Least accurate, last sensitive, least reproductive
- Considered only when analytical and PD not available
How do pharmacokinetic studies (PK-BE) show bioequivalency?
Uses PK measures to determine rate/extent of drug release from product and absorption into systemic circulation
ex. Compare AUC, Cmax, and early exposure (partial AUC to peak) to show bioequivalence
What are some major components of an ethics approval?
- Institutional Human Ethics Review
- Informed consent
- Pre-study physical exam and medical history
- Post-study physical exam and medical history
- Post-study physical exam
What are some considerations for selecting subjects?
- Minimize risk to study subjects
- Minimize inter- and intra- subject variable
What are some common subjectg criteria for bioequivalence studies?
Normal, healthy volunteers (male or female)
- Age (18-55yo)
- BMI (18.5-30)
- Routine medical examination and thorough histroy
- Alcohol and drug abuse
- An ECG (especially if drug is QTc prolonging)
- Not pregnant, lactating, or likely to become pregnant
When are bioequivalence studies started in patients already using the drug?
Usually done when it is unethical to administer said drug to healthy volunteers
What are the three fundamental statistical concepts of study design?
- Randomization
- Replication
- Error control (minimize experimental error)
What is the most common bioequivalency study design?
Single Oral Dose (SOD) Design
Review slide 41 for a brief description of the typical Single Oral Dose (SOD) Design
How does the Single Oral DoseI (SOD) study design work?
- PK data from a patient is collected after one dose of Product A (reference) or B (test)
- Following a washout period, the subjects are switched to a different treatment group
- PK data from patients is collected again after a single dose of Product B (test) or A (reference)
see slide 41
What are the advantages of crossover study designs?
Diminish intersubject variation
More than two formulations and different study conditions can be studied
What are the limitations of parallel group study design for bioequivalency studies?
Does not allow a within-subject comparison (each individual only takes one drug, not both like crossover design)
Need to increase sample size to acheive same power as cross-over designs
When are parallel group designs considered for bioequivalence studies?
Only considered if:
- Drug has a very long half-life
- Some depot formulations
Parallel study designs are used in these situations because the washout periods are too long and it is unpractival to continue the study after the washout period (subjects have grown and changed since)