Belmont Report Flashcards
What are the three basic ethical principles?
- Respect for Persons, 2. Beneficence, 3. Justice
What does the term “practice” refer to?
Interventions that are designed solely to enhance the well-being of an individual patient that have a reasonable expectation of success.
What is the purpose of “research”?
To designate an activity designed to test an hypothesis, permit conclusions ti be drawn and thereby to develop of contribute to generalizable knowledge
When a procedure is “experimental” (in the sense that it is new, untested or different) is it research?
No, it is not automatically placed in the category of research.
Can research and practice be carried out together?
Yes, when research is designed to evaluate the safety and efficacy of therapy.
Respect for Persons incorporates what two ethical convictions?
- Individuals should be treated as autonomous agents and 2. Persons with diminished autonomy are entitled to protection.
Respect for Persons incorporates what two moral requirements separate from the ethical convictions?
- Required to acknowledge autonomy and 2. Required to protect those with diminished autonomy
Respect for Persons: What is an autonomous person?
An individual capable of deliberation about personal goals and of acting under the direction of such deliberation
Beneficence: Persons are treated in an ethical manner not only by…
…respecting their decisions and protecting them from harm, but also making efforts to SECURE THEIR WELL-BEING.
Beneficence: What are the two general rules that have been formulated as complementary expressions of beneficent actions?
- Do not harm and 2. Maximize possible benefits and minimize posible harms.
Respect for Persons: What is a big dilemma while working with prisoners?
Whether to allow prisoners to “volunteer” or to “protect” them from subtle coercion
Justice: What is Justice? (2 brief statements)
“Fairness in distribution” and “what is deserved”
Justice: When does injustice occur?
When some benefit to which a person is entitled is denied without good reasons or when some burden is imposed unduly.
Justice: Name the 5 accepted formulations to distribute burdens and benefits:
- To each person an equal share, 2. to each person according to individual need, 3. to each P according to individual effort, 4. to each P according to societal contribution, and 5. to each P according to merit.
Applications of the general principles to the conduct of research leads to consideration of what requirements?
Informed consent, risk/benefit assessment, and the selection of subjects of research
Applications: The informed consent process can be analyzed as containing what three elements?
- Information, 2. comprehension, and 3. voluntariness
Informed Consent, Information: What are specific items for disclosure intended to assure that subjects are given sufficient info? (5)
- The research procedure, 2. their purpose, 3. risks and anticipated benefits, 4. alternative procedures, 5. and a statement offering the subject the opportunity to ask Q’s and withdraw at any time from research.
Risks and Benefits: responsibility of the investigator?
Responsible to gather systematic and comprehensive information about the proposed research
Risks and Benefits: responsibility of the review committee?
To determine whether the risks that will be presented to subjects are justified
Risks and Benefits: responsibility of the prospective subjects?
Determine whether or not to participate
The term risk refers to…
A possibility that harm may occur
The terms “small” risk and “large” risks refer almost ambiguously to…
both the chance (probability) of experiencing a harm and the severity (magnitude) of the envisioned harm.
Is “benefit” expressed in probabilities?
No, unlike risks which are, benefit refers to a positive value related to health or welfare.
Types of potential risks/harms? (5)
psychological harm, physical harm, legal harm, social harm, and economic harm.
What the most likely types of harms to come to research subjects? (2)
psychological or physical pain/injury - but others are still possible.
21CFR11
Electronic records; electronic signatures
21CFR50
Protection of human subjects
21CFR50.20
General requirements for informed consent
21CRF50.23
Exception from general requirements of IC
21CFR50.24
Exception from IC requirements for emergency research
21CFR50.25
Elements of IC
21CFR50.27
Documentation of IC
21CFR50.50
Children involved in clinical research IRB duties
21CRF50.51
Studies w/ C NOT involving > minimal risk
21CFR50.52
Studies w/ C involving > min risk but with potential benefit to subject
21CFR50.1
Scope of Research
21CRF50.53
Studies w/ C involving > min risk, no potential benefit, but yield generalizable knowledge about the subject