Beliefs in Society - topic 2 -religions and social change Flashcards
Religion as a conservative force: In which 2 ways does religion act as a conservative force?
It defends traditionalist customs
Holds beliefs and functions that conserve or preserve things in stabilising society.
Religion as a conservative force: What do they mean by defending traditionalsit custsoms?
Often conservative beliefs about moral issues e.g anti abortion
Patriarchal
Religion as a conservative force: How can it help stabilise society?
it promotes social solidarity and reduces the need for individuals to pursue their own selfish beliefs and cause societies downfall.
Weber: religion as a force for change: Give an example of religion being a force for change?
Religious beliefs of Calvinism helped bring about major social change
Weber: religion as a force for change: What are the similarities between Calvinism and capitalism?
the modern-day people are more systematic in pursuing profit
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs include what 4 things?
Predestination
Divine transcendence
Asceticism
the idea of vocation or calling
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs: What does predestination mean?
God has predetermined who will go to heaven (‘the elect’) and nothing we do can alter that
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs: What does Divine transcendence
mean?
God is so far above human understanding and no mortal can claim to know anything about him
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs: What does Asceticism mean?
(abstinence , self-discipline and self-denial
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs: What does the idea of vocation or callingmean?
(vocation: other-worldly asceticism in renouncing all personal goods to join a convent or monastery and this-worldly asceticism (introduced by Calvinism) methodical, rigorous work in an occupation
Weber: religion as a force for change; Calvinist beliefs: What does hard work give them?
. This hard work would produce a psychological function that allowed them to cope with their salvation panic through their accumulating wealth and their work would produce much riches that they’d invest in profit not luxuries
Weber: religion as a force for change: What were the causes of modern capitalism?
Calvinism
a number of material or economic factors e.g. natural resources, trade or a money economy
Weber: religion as a force for change: What were the causes of modern capitalism?However there have been a number of other societies that have had a higher level of economic development but hasn’t developed modern capitalism, Weber argues that this is due to what?
the lack of a religious belief system alike to Calvinism
Weber: religion as a force for change: Hinduism and Confucianism: How is hinduism similar to calvinism?
Hinduism was an ascetic religion like Calvinism
Weber: religion as a force for change: Hinduism and Confucianism: How is hinduism similar to calvinism?
its orientation was this-worldly asceticism in how it directed its follower’s attention away from material goods.
Weber: religion as a force for change: Hinduism and Confucianism: How is Confucianism similar to calvinism?
Confucianism (in ancient China) was a this-worldly religion - focused on this current lifetime/ this world
Weber: religion as a force for change: Hinduism and Confucianism: How is Confucianism similar to calvinism?
wasn’t ascetic, so wasn’t disciplined.
Weber: religion as a force for change: Hinduism and Confucianism: Why did these two cultures not undergo rapid social change?
Both Hinduism and Confucianism lacked the drive to develop a modern capitalist system unlike many western cultures, therefore they didn’t under go social change due to the other factors other than Calvinism.
Weber EVALUATION: GOOD?
Weber took a different view to Marx, who believed that it was solely economic factors that encourages change, he believed that cultural aspects also took influence
Marshall argues however that this is due to the lack of investment and skilled labour (supports the idea of material and cultural importance).
Weber EVALUATION:BAD?
Kautsky (1926) argues that Weber overestimates the roles of ideas and underestimates the economic factors in bringing capitalism.
Tawney (1926) believes that the roles of technology takes the vital influence in capitalism, not religious ideas.
Scotland had many Calvinist follower’s; however, capitalism was slow to develop.
Weber EVALUATION:BAD:Kautsky: What did he say?
Kautsky (1926) argues that Weber overestimates the roles of ideas and underestimates the economic factors in bringing capitalism.
Weber EVALUATION:BAD:Kautsky: What did he say?
Tawney (1926) believes that the roles of technology takes the vital influence in capitalism, not religious ideas.
Weber EVALUATION:BAD: Tawney : What is the relevance of scotland?
Scotland had many Calvinist follower’s; however, capitalism was slow to develop.
Religion and social protest:The American civil rights movement: How did it begin?
The civil rights movement began in 1955 when Rosa Parks refused to move for a white person on a segregated bus which began the Bus Boycott
Religion and social protest:The American civil rights movement: Who played an important role in the movement?
Bruce argues that the black clergy were the back bone of the civil right movement,
Dr Martin Luther King played an important role in through his speeches and rallies