Beliefs in society Flashcards
Why does the usage of the word “ideology” vary?
In sociology it has various different meanings and definitions.
How many types of ideology does Karl Mannheim define and what does he say about them?
He offers 2 definitions:
A set of beliefs used to justify and perpetuate and existing social order. This is used by consensus theories.
Utopian ideology is the set of beliefs about how the world could be organised in the future, in order to benefit the oppressed. This is used by conflict theories.
What issues does Karl Mannheim identify with ideologies?
Ideologies distort how fair or unfair societies are seen.
What do developers of Marxism say about ideology?
1) Gramsci argues Hegemony: Bourgeois Ideology is so domineering that the become ingrained within mainstream thought process as common sense.
2) Althusser argues that some institutions in societies are “ideological state apparatuses” which transmit capitalist ideology.
Why do many scientists attempt to distinguish themselves from religion?
They argue they are distinct from ideological approaches in that they use empirical evidence, rather than subjective claims.
How do modern scientific approaches to sociology differ older ones?
Older scientific methodology was inductive, generating a hypothesis after collecting data. Contemporary sociology is deductive, focusing on developing a theory first and then testing for it’s validity.
What does Popper deem “progressive science” and how does it relate to the idea of “permanent social laws”?
Science can only be progressive if it attempts to falsify existing theories, just because something was once deemed true, doesn’t mean new evidence cant falsify it.
How does Polanyi (1958) compare science to other belief systems?
A circularity of beliefs: each idea is explained within relation to other ideas within the theory.
Supporting explanations for difficult situations: evidence of the contrary to beliefs is often ignored; within science contradictory results are seen as anomalous.
Rejection of alternative belief systems.
Why do postmodernists, such as Lyotard (1984), criticise science?
Science claims a “monopoly of truth”, which goes against postmodernist ideas of pluralism.
Why do conflict theorists sometimes criticise science?
They say it’s methodology is biased in that, what is deemed useful knowledge is decided and used by oppressive power structures.
Describe Kuhn’s “paradagim shift” view on science.
Science is not linear but revolutionary, instead scientists work within a paradigm which they assume to be true until enough anomalies are present that they have to rethink methodology and what is seen as true.
What does Gomm (1982) science and the theory of evolution?
Science does’t falsify but rather attempts prove the thoughts of society. E.g how Darwinian evolution parallels Victorian capitalist ideals.
What collective branch of sociology would use a scientific approach to sociology?
Macrosociologists
Why would Kuhn say sociology is not a science?
Currently, there is no grand unified theory within sociology.
How does Durkheim argue that social facts can be observed?
Through societal analysis to determine cause and effect.
Why does Weber think sociology can never be “value free.”
Researchers will always be inherently biased on what they chose and how they chose to research it.
What does Weber argue sociology should be if it can not be value free?
Sociology should be value relevant.
What does it mean to say religion is a conservative force?
Religion can be seen as a method of maintaining status quo within society.
What do functionalists argue the purpose of religion is?
Maintaining social order through value consensus.
What did Malinowski (1954) note about religion’s role?
Religion maintains social order through significant but disruptive times like births and deaths.
Parson’s argues that religion promotes “Core values.” For what purpose?
To create a value consensus and to help people make sense of their lives.
What is a critique of the functionalist view of religion?
It ignores the negative aspects of religion such religious conflicts and oppression.
What do feminists argue about religion?
Feminists argue that religion is a conservative force used to perpetuate archaic patriarchal values.
How do religious texts manipulate female sexuality and what impact does this have?
Women are portrayed as either whores or temptresses, as such this denies women of a sexual identity while enforcing the idea only men can be pious.
How does religion force women into traditional gender roles?
It focuses on their ability to have children, and limits them to it.
What does Simone de Beauvoir (1953) say about the afterlife?
It enforces patriarchal values through delayed gratification, if they are prepared to suffer in life they will be rewarded in the afterlife.
What are the critiques of the feminist view of religion?
1) It ignores the fact that other institutions transmit patriarchal values.
2) It ignores how some women use their religion and actively defy oppression, such as Malala Yousafzai.
3) It portrays women as hapless victims of oppression, without any agency.
Marx’s quote in religion.
“opium of the masses.”