Bankruptcy Flashcards
What is the lookback period for general creditors?
90 days
What is the lookback period for insiders
One Year
What is the $ threshold for general creditor consumer debt?
More than $600 within 90 days of filing
What is the $ threshold for general creditor business debt?
More than $6,825 within 90 days of filing
What is the general exception to preferential transfer rules?
Transfer isn’t preferential if debtor was solvent at the time
What is the lookback period for fraudulent transfers?
Two Years
Actual Fraud (Elements)
- Transfer was made within 2 years of filing AND
- Transfer was made within intent to defraud creditor AND
- Transfer rendered debtor insolvent OR debtor was already insolvent at the time
Constructive Fraud (Elements)
- Transfer was made within two years of filing AND
- Debtor received less than reasonably equivalent value AND
- Debtor was insolvent at the time of the transfer OR became insolvent because of the transfer
Preferential Transfer (Elements)
- Transfer of an interest of the debtor in property
- To or for the benefit of the creditor
- Made within the applicable look back period
- By an insolvent debtor
- On an antecedent debt
- Creditor received more than they would have in chapter 7
Preferential Transfer (Statutory Defenses)
- Contemporaneous Exchange
- Ordinary Course of Business
- Subsequent New Value
Preferential Transfer (Non-Statutory Defenses)
- Ear Marking
- Constructive Trusts
- “Mere Conduit”
Contemporaneous Exchange 547(c)(1)
- Intended by creditor AND debtor to be a contemporaneous exchange for new value AND
- Exchange was in-fact contemporaneous AND
- New Value was in fact given
Ordinary Course of Business 547(c)(2)
(General Elements)
- Debt was incurred in ordinary course of business +
- Payment made in the ordinary course of business +
- Payment made according to ordinary business terms
Subsequent New Value 547(c)(4)
- After transfer creditor gave new value to/for benefit of debtor
- NOT secured by an otherwise avoidable interest +
- Debtor did not make another payment in response
Ordinary Course of Dealing (Factors)
- Length of time parties have engaged
- Was payment for more than normal?
- Was the manner of payment abnormal?
- Did the creditor due anything to gain advantage?
Antecedent Requirement
Transfer must be for an antecedent debt to be avoidable
Insolvency Requirement
Debtor must have been insolvent at the time of transfer for a transfer to be avoidable
Insolvency Presumption
Section 547 (preferences) presumes that a debtor is insolvent for the 90 day period preceding the filing
Utility Companies (11 U.S.C. §366)
- Automatic stay prevents utilities for stopping service for 20 days
- Debtor MUST provide provide ‘adequate assurance’ within 20 days
- Be sure to list utility debt on schedule
- Payments are arguably made in the ordinary course
Luxury Item (Elements for Presumption of Fraud)
- Purchase from one creditor
- Made by a credit card
- Within 90 days of filing
- For $725 or more
Burden of Proof (Without Presumption of Fraud)
Trustee must prove that the debtor didn’t intend to repay the debt at the time the purchase was made
Recent Cash Advances
No discharge if debtor received a cash advance(s):
- Totaling more than $1,000
- From a single creditor
- For a consumer purchase
- Within 70 days of filing
Debts Not Dischargeable Under Any Circumstance
- DSOs
- Fines, penalties, restitution
- Taxes that weren’t filed or filed fraudulently
Discharging Property Taxes
- Debtor can discharge property taxes that were payable (without penalty) more than one year before the filing
- Lien will remain on property
Property Tax as Administrative Claim
Property taxes assessed during a bankruptcy are treated as administrative claims
Property Taxes (Chapter 13)
Plan must offer to pay 100% of property taxes that were last payable within one-year before case is filed
Debt Incurred to Pay Non-Dischargeable Taxes
- Not dischargeable in chapter 7 (though a credit card company might not screen/identify the charge and thus fail to object)
- Can be discharged under chapter 13
Discharging Income Taxes (Elements)
- Debtor filed return(s) for the year(s) in question
- Return(s) were filed at least 2 years prior to filing bankruptcy
- Return(s) were due at least 3 years prior to filing bankruptcy
- Liability assessed at least 8 months prior to filing bankruptcy
- Debtor did not attempt to willfully evade tax
Prior Non-Dischargeable Debts
Debtor cannot discharge debt that was listed in a previous bankruptcy dismissed for fraud or malfeasance
Discharging Income Taxes (Tolling)
- IRS doesn’t necessarily assess liability when taxes are filed
- 240 day period can be extended/tolled by IRS OR if debtor made an offer of compromise
“Late” Income Tax Return (and discharge)
- “Late” return does not satisfy the requirement of filing taxes for relevant year in regard to discharging income taxes
- Late = all extensions have expired and IRS filed a “substitute return” without debtor’s assistance
Debts Discharged in 13 But Not 7
- Marital debts created in a divorce or settlement agreement
- Debts incurred to pay non-dischargeable debt
- Court fees
- Debt’s that couldn’t be discharged in a prior bankruptcy
Co-signor Debt in Chapter 7
- Joint debtor will owe entire amount
- Can be addressed via reaffirmation agreement
- Better for the debtor to make separate agreement to reimburse co-signor (though co-signor credit will take a hit)
Co-Signor Debt in Chapter 13
Creditor can still go after co-signor for balance after plan is done
When Can Exempt Property Still Be Taken?
When Debtor owes money for:
- DSOs
- Back taxes
Tenancy by the entirety (general)
- Permits spouses to jointly own property as a separate legal entity
- Each spouse has an equal/undivided property interest
- Creditors cannot enforce a lien on any property that falls under a tenancy by the entirety if only one spouse owns the debt
Tax Liens and Chapter 7
- Tax liens are not discharged in chapter 7
- Trustee is unlikely to liquidate property if proceeds would simply go towards paying off liens
Tax Lien and Personal Property
Tax liens can attach to personal property
Avoiding Transfers and Homestead Exemption (Penalty)
Any transfer made for purpose of putting property beyond reach of creditors for TEN YEARS preceding bankruptcy can deprive debtor of homestead exemption altogether.
Ways to Reduce Home Equity and/or keep home
- Refinance mortgage for more than debtor currently owes
- Offer to pay cash for difference between value and exemption
- File for Chapter 13
- Reverse Mortgage
- But see penalty of losing homestead exemption for transfers intended to put property beyond the reach of creditors
Keeping House in Chapter 7 (When Behind on Mortgage Payments)
- Lender will ask court to lift the stay (court will likely do it)
- GOAL: stave off foreclosure for length of bankruptcy case. Debtor may have an easier time repaying mortgage once other debts are wiped out.
Credit Counseling Requirement (Time Prior to Filing)
180 days prior to filing
Credit Counseling Certificate of Completion (timeframe for filing)
No later than 15 days after filing date
Credit Counseling Plan (Requirements and Non-Requirements)
- Doesn’t have to be followed
- DOES have to be filed w/ petition
Means Test (Median Income)
Debtor does not have to take means test if income is below state median income given household size
When Doesn’t Debtor Have to Pass Means Tests?
- Debts are not primarily consumer debts
- Disabled veteran + incurred debt primarily during active duty
- Income is below the state median OR
- Debt is primarily NON-consumer debt
Methods of Protecting Cash
-Spend cash on necessary items (food, needed clothing, utilities, rent, car repairs) + Keep receipts
Use exemptions ($1,325 wildcard and $12,575 spillover = $13,900 total)
(Clients with cash are a red flag)
Protecting Cash (Balance of Account)
Exemption amount will be based on balance of the date of filing (not account for any pending payments)
Setoff in Chapter 7
Banks/Credit Unions can take money out of debtor’s account to “set-off” any $ debtor owes creditor (bank)
-Must request lifting of automatic stay
Frozen Bank Account in Chapter 7
Bank might freeze debtor’s account EVEN IF debtor doesn’t owe bank any $
- Bank argues that account is property of the estate and they are protecting it for the trustee
- Contact trustee to instruct bank to release exempt funds
- OR file a motion in court
- Debtor should open an account at a new bank BEFORE filing
Bank Account in Chapter 7 (Balance)
-Make sure that checks have cleared before filing
-Otherwise balance may be higher than amount stated
(listed $5k on account but only have $4k after checks clear = you owe the trustee $1k to make up for the difference).
Federal Wildcard Exemption
$1,325
Federal Homestead “Spillover” Exemption
$12,575
Getting a Bank Account After Chapter 7
It might be easier to get one than before because the bank will know that your debts have been discharged
Methods of Protecting Cash (What NOT To Do)
- Don’t buy gift cards
- Don’t withdraw cash
- Don’t buy luxury goods
- Don’t buy anything out of line with normal spending patterns
- Don’t make preferential payments
- Don’t use a credit card
Tax Refund (Estimate When Amount is Unknown)
-If debtor has had no major life changes (marriage, having kids, buying house, new job) use prior years as an estimate
Tax Refund (Estimate When Amount is Unknown)
- If debtor has had no major life changes (marriage, having kids, buying house, new job) use prior years as an estimate
- If debtor HAS had major life changes = find a free tax refund calculator
Why Do I Have To List My Refund When I Won’t Get It Until Next Year?
- Assets are everything you own or have an interest in
- Since you’re paying taxes now you have an interest now
Tax Refunds Seized Pro-Rata
- Trustee can only take portion of tax-return that can be traced back to pre-petition efforts
- Trustee can take 100% of refund if debtor files in January (or at any point prior to receiving the refund)
Cross Collateralization
Practice of credit unions to secure loans/credit cards with any collateral purchased with funds obtained from the credit union (like a car)
Credit Union/Bank Account Pre-Filing Work (When Debtor Owes a Balance to the Bank)
- Pull money out
- Stop direct deposit
- Get a year’s worth of statements (especially if closing account)
- Make sure all checks have cleared
Annulment of Stay
Court can annul a previously issued stay in cases where debtor abuses the system
Automatic Stay and Delinquent DSO
§362(b)(2)(B)
Act to collect delinquent DSO from property that is NOT part of the estate is NOT a violation of the stay
Creditor’s Duty to Surrender
Creditor must immediately surrender property that is either property of the estate or could be claimed as exempt by the debtor
Single Serial Filer
one previous case pending within 1 year
Stay expires after 30 days
Multiple Serial Filer
more than one prior case within 1 year
Stay never goes into effect unless court orders it
Single Serial Filer (Motion to Extend Stay)
Motion to extend the stay must be concluded within 30 days (notice must be provided to creditors)
Grounds for Relief from Stay
- Lack of adequate protection
- Debtor has no equity in property and property is not necessary for effective reorganization
- Debtor filed w/ intent to delay/hinder/etc
Lack of Adequate Protection (response)
- Show that equity cushion is sufficient to cover claim without additional risk of loss to creditor OR
- Offer additional protection
- Get collateral insured
- Provide cash deposit
- Get co-signor
- Offer additional assets as collateral
Relief from Stay (30 days)
Relief from stay is granted AUTOMATICALLY 30 days after the first hearing on the motion
- Either get a hearing scheduled less than 30 days out OR
- Get a stipulation on the record that stay will remain in effect until matter is heard
Relief from Stay (30 days)
Relief from stay is granted AUTOMATICALLY 30 days after the first hearing on the motion
- Either get a hearing scheduled less than 30 days out OR
- Get a stipulation on the record that stay will remain in effect until matter is heard
Reinstating the Stay
Relief from stay is granted AUTOMATICALLY 30 days after the first hearing on the motion
- Either get a hearing scheduled less than 30 days out OR
- Get a stipulation on the record that stay will remain in effect until matter is heard
Violations of the Stay (types)
- Continuing attempts to collect on debt
2. Refusing to turn over property of the estate
Violations of Stay and Incorrect Notice Sent to Creditors
Failure to use address provided to the court by creditors results in creditor not owing monetary sanctions for a violation of the stay
Statement of Intentions (deadline to act)
45 days from the date statement is filed
Statement of Intentions (Creditors right when debtor intends to surrender property)
Creditor cannot move forward with repossession until stay has lifted (even if debtor intends to surrender)