Bail (Criminal Litigation) Flashcards
What is the general right to bail?
For most offences, there is a general right to bail (presumption of bail)
Unless there is a substantial right to believe:
- a failure to surrender;
- commit an offence on bail;
- interfere with witnesses; or
- obstruct course of justice
For what offences is there not a general right to bail?
Murder and serious sexual offences
- murder or attempted murder;
- rape or attempted rape;
- manslaughter;
- serious sexual offences
In these cases of ‘serious offences’ - bail is not presumed and bail will likely not be granted
What are some restrictions under conditional bail?
Curfew, residence and particular place, report to police station, exclusion from areas, electronic tag, removal of passport
- must be relevant to the crime, proportionate and enforceable
What is bail?
Bail is an order to appear before the court
The defendant is released subject to their duty to surrender to the court at an appointed time and place
When is bail granted?
Where there is a gap in court proceedings - after MC first hearing, after sending hearing, after PTPH, if there is a break between conviction and trial
What is the starting point for bail applications?
There is always (subject to exceptions) a presumption of bail
Who bears the burden of proof to deny the defendant bail?
It is up to the prosecution to prove and persuade the court that the exceptions apply and that D is not granted bail
The prosecution needs to apply to remove bail
When do the exceptions to bail apply?
There must be a real prospect of custodial sentence
- offence must be seriousness enough to warrant imprisonment
What are the substantial grounds if the defendant is released on bail, which can deny the defendant bail?
- Fail to surrender to custody
- Commit an offence while on bail
- Interfere with witnesses
- Obstruct the course of justice
When can committing an offence whilst on bail rebut the presumption of bail?
If the offence is indictable or triable either way and it appears to the court that D committed the offence whilst on bail for another offence
What is the approach to bail if the defendant has been charged with murder?
Only a Crown Court judge can grant bail
- if the court believes there is no significant risk of the defendant committing while on bail
What is the rule for any bail condition to apply?
Any bail condition must be justified and necessary
All conditions must be relevant, proportionate and enforceable
What is a surety?
A guarantee given by a parent or guardian that the defendant will surrender to custody at the appointed time
What is security for the purposes of a bail condition?
Money paid to the court by the defendant or anyone else
If D does answer bail, the money is returned
What bail conditions can be used to ensure the defendant stays in a certain location or is restricted in their movement?
- Residence
- Exclusion
- Curfews
- Bail hostels
- Surrender of passport
- Reporting to police station
- Restrictions on communication