AUD 1 Flashcards
3 major parts of
professional code of conduct
- Members in public practice (MIPPs)
- Members in business (MIBs)
- Other members (OMs)
6 principles of professional conduct
- Responsibility
- Public Interest
- Integrity
- Objectivity & Independence
- Due Care
- Scope & Nature of Services
RESPONSIBILITY principle
General/3 actions
exercise professional and moral judgments, cooperate to:
- improve the art of accounting
- maintain the public’s confidence, and
- carry out the profession’s special responsibilities for self-governance
PUBLIC INTEREST principle
3 obligations
- act in a way that will serve the public interest,
- honor the public trust, and
- demonstrate a commitment to professionalism.
INTEGRITY principle
2 points
Integrity is measured in terms of what is right and just
members should always ask “Am I doing what a person of integrity would do?”
OBJECTIVITY and INDEPENDENCE principle
3 points
A member should
- maintain objectivity and
- be free of conflicts of interest
Objectivity is a state of mind” that requires: impartiality, intellectual honesty, and freedom from conflicts of interest.
Independence: applies only to MIPPs (auditing, in fact/appearance) *but all members performing all services must act w/ objectivity and integrity
DUE CARE principle
(3 actions)
2 definitions
A member should (to the best of the member’s ability)
- observe the profession’s technical and ethical standards,
- improve competence and the quality of services, and
- discharge professional responsibility.
COMPETENCE requires a commitment to continued learning
DUE CARE entails
- Adequate planning of engagements
- Supervision of professional activities for which members are responsible
SCOPE and NATURE OF SERVICES principle
3 min actions
- Practice in firms w/ good internal quality control procedures
- determine whether the scope/nature of services would create a conflict of interest,
- assess whether a contemplated activity is consistent with their role as professionals.
PARTNER EQUIVALENT
Not a partner, but EITHER has
- ultimate responsibility for the conduct of an attest engagement or
- authority to bind the firm to conduct an attest engagement
**so would have to live up to the same standards that a partner would have to
PUBLIC PRACTICE consists of the performance of…
- professional services (e.g., audit, tax, consulting) for a client by a member or the member’s firm.
- Government audits
3 main steps to applying conceptual framework
- Identify threats. (7)
- Evaluate the significance of the threats –> acceptable level?
- Identify and apply safeguards. (3)
CATEGORIES of THREATS (7)
To integrity/objectivty
- Adverse interest (lawsuit)
- Advocacy (objectivity)
- Familiarity (employ relative/friend)
- Management participation (helps manage)
- Self-interest (financial pressure)
- Self-review (own work)
- Undue Influence (threats of w/hold work)
SAFEGUARDS to threats in applying Conceptual Framework (3)
- Safeguards created by the profession, legislation, or regulation.
- Training, standards, reviews, legislations, licensing, resources
- Safeguards implemented by the client.
- Management have knowledge/experience/ethical
- Policies for compliance, fair reporting, ethics
- Governance, audit committee
- Safeguards implemented by the firm.:
- Leadership emphasizing compliance, public interest
- Policies and procedures
- Quality control system
- Rotation of senior personnel
CONFLICTS of INTEREST
- Evaluation
- 2 types
- How to REDUCE to acceptable level
In evaluating possible conflicts of interest, members should ask:
Would a reasonable and informed third party conclude that a conflict exists?
2 types
- Client A vs Client B: Between interests of two clients
- Firm/members vs Client: Between interests of client on one hand and firm and/or its members on the other.
REDUCE to acceptable levels
- full disclosure to client
- client consents
DIRECTOR POSITION
- What threat
- 2 actions
Objectivity
2 Actions:
- Apply Conceptual Framework to determine whether the threat is unacceptably high.
- Preferable to serve as a consultant to board NOT joining board
GIFTS and ENTERTAINMENT
- What threat (2)
- Violations (2)
- Final determination
Objectivity and Integrity
Violation presumed if
- violate the member’s or client’s policies or applicable laws and regulations and
- The member knows or is reckless in not knowing of the violation.
FINAL
- If no rules are violated, then determine if “REASONABLE in the circumstances.”
- Reasonable based on *nature, occasion, cost/value, if assoc w/ conduct of business
PREPARATION and REPORTING INFO
3 examples of violations
- made or allowed material or misleading entries in FS or records
- not corrected misstatements when had authority
- signed, permitted, or directed another to sign misleading docs
What is SUBORDIATION of JUDGMENT
And proper procedure
If disagree w/ superior but still do what superior wants
Procedure
- Evaluate if threat is at an unacceptable level, if would result in a material misrepresentation or legal violation.
- If no, then no further action
- If yes, discuss the matter with the supervisor, and go over head if nec
- If not addressed up mgt chain, then invoke the following safeguards:
- Look for any additional requirements for reporting differences of opinion w/in firms policies and procedures
- Determine if is a duty to report to external authorities.
- Consult legal counsel.
- Fully document the situation.
- If cannot be reduced to an acceptable level, consider quitting the firm and try to eliminate exposure to subordination of judgment.
- Consider quitting (not required but allowed to)
- Doesn’t discharge all obligations, such as to report to regulatory authorities or an external auditor.
CLIENT ADVOCACY
- When allowed
- threats
- NO if doing attest work clients.
- YES if providing nonattest services (ie: tax work, advisory)
should not threaten OBJECTIVITY or INTEGRITY:
- exceed performance stds
- exceed reasonable practice
- compromise credibility
THIRD-PARTY SERVICE PROVIDER (TSP)
- Threats
- Permitted activities
- Safeguards
Threats:
- objectivity
- integrity.
Permitted:
- Mere administrative support (e.g., record storage, software application hosting, authorized e-file transmittal services)
Safeguards if substantive services outsourced,
- notify client before any confidential info provided to TSP
- if the client objects, the member should:
- Not outsource, or
- Decline the engagement
GENERAL STANDARDS (4)
- Professional competence
- Due professional care (not nec perfect)
- planning and supervision
- sufficient reasonable data
COMPETENCE
2 requirements
- member or his/or her staff has appropriate technical qualifications and
- the member can supervise and evaluate quality of work performed.
Departure from GAAP allowed
- 3 exceptions
- 2 not allowed
- When permitted
Exceptions
- if following GAAP would mislead (b/c new events w/o GAAP)
- new legislation
- evolution of new form of business
Not justified
- unusual degree of materiality
- conflicting business practice
PERMITTED: when other accounting principles apply
- Foreign country
- Prescribed by contract
- Required by law or regulatory agency
DISCREDITABLE ACTS examples
- Discrimination
- Exam questions
- Failure to file/pay tax
- Negligence
- Material departure from audit stds
- Confidential info
- False promoting/mkting
4 categories of RECORDS
Treatment when client requests
- Client provided
- delivered upon request, even if bill not paid
- Member prepared (not engaged to prepare)
- upon request, unless unpaid bill
- Member’s work products (deliverable, tax return)
- upon request, unless:
- 1) unpaid,
- 2) incomplete,
- 3) due to prof stds on audit issues,
- 4) litigation
- upon request, unless:
- Working papers (for purpose of engagement, by both member and client)
- members property, not required
Delivery w/in 45 days
CONTINGENT FEE
- Def
- exclusions
fee established for the performance of any service pursuant to an arrangement in which
- no fee will be charged unless a specified finding or result is attained, or
- the amount of the fee is otherwise dependent upon the finding or result of such service
Exclusions
- fixed by court/authorities
- for tax based on judicial proceedings/govt agency
When is CONTINGET FEE not allowed
for any service performed if also provide these attest services:
- audit/review of FS
- compilation of FS used by 3rd party if lack of independence NOT disclosed
- An examination of prospective financial information.
- Nor prep an original or amended tax return or claim for a tax refund for any client, even nonattest clients. *exceptions: test cases, representing for reviews
COMMISSIONS and REFERRAL FEES
- When permitted
- 3 exceptions
Attest clients – prohibited
Nonattest clients – permitted,
- must disclose in writing
Exceptions
- member spouse if activities separate from member practice (b/c no signif involvement)
- reselling product to a client (b/c obvious making money)
- mark up cost of 3rd party services (b/c obvious making $)
ADVERTISING
- Responsibilities
- When is it discreditable act
For
- own promotions AND
- for 3rd parties asked to provide services
Discreditable if false, misleading or deceptive (to a reasonable person), including
- false expectations
- imply ability to influence court etc
- mislead cost of services
CONFIDENTIAL INFO
- Def
- General rule
- 2 discreditable acts
Proprietary info that is not known to public and obtained due to work provided
Gen Rule
- MIPP not disclose confidential client info
Discreditable acts
- disclose w/o permission
- use for personal benefit
**confidentiality duty survives the employment relationship
DISCLOSURE of Confidential Info
- Allowed (3)
- Responsibilities (4)
Allowed
- The client consents.
- Permitted by law and authorized by the employer.
- Required by law for subpoena and reporting violations
may have responsibility or right to disclose the information (if legally permitted) to:
- Initiate an ethics complaint with AICPA, or other board
- Protect member’s professional interests in legal proceedings
- Comply with professional standards and other ethics requirements
- Report potential concerns regarding questionable accounting, auditing, or other matters to the employer’s confidential complaint hotline or those charged with governance
MIPP Independence
- Threats
- safeguards
Threats – same 7 as for integrity/independence
- Adverse interest (lawsuit)
- Advocacy (objectivity)
- Familiarity (employ relative/friend)
- Management participation (helps manage)
- Self-interest (financial pressure)
- Self-review (own work)
- Undue Influence (threats of w/hold work)
Safeguards – same 3
- Profession, legislation, regulation
- Attest client
- Firm
MIPP Independence
- 4 relationships
- Financial
- Employment
- Family
- Consulting
Time Period for Independence rules
Periods
- covered by FS
- of the professional engagement
10 hr person
Partner, partner equivalent or mg who provides > 10 hr of NONATTEST services to attest client w/in any fiscal year
OPIO
OTHER PARTNER IN OFFICE
Partner/equivalent in the SAME OFFICE as the lead attest engagement partner/equiv of attest engagement
COVERED MEMBERS 6 types
- on attest team
- PTI = Position to influence
- 10 hr person
- OPIO = other partner in office
- the FIRM, incl EE benefit plans
- any other ENTITY whose policies can be controlled by any of other 5, or 2+ individuals if acting together
NETWORK FIRM
Cooperate to enhance capabilities to provide services and share 1+:
- Common brand name
- Common control
- Profits/costs
- Common business strategy
- Professional resources
- Common quality control policies/procedures
POPE
Partners or professional employees
AFFILIATE of client
- Problem
- Examples
Independence if covered member has relationship w/ affiliate of client
Examples
- Subsidiary = entity that client can control
- Parent = entity in which client has direct/material financial interest
- Entity that controls client AND client is material to the entity
- Sister entity of client if both are material to parent
- Trustee that controls a client that is not an investment company
- Sponsor of a single ER EE benefit plan client
REISSUED REPORTS
- Def
- Ok/not ok
If independent when first issued audit report, may reissue or consent to incorporate by reference, even in no longer independent
- NOT OK: new procedures that require updating/dual dating the original report
- OK: assess effect of NEW facts on original report -
- ask successor auditors -
- read subsequent FS
- do other procedures
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR)
- problem
Engagement letters may require
- If initiated, binding arbitration is sufficiently similar to litigation to create material adverse interests and impair independence
- Apply conceptual framework
UNPAID FEES
- Def
- Rule
- exemption
Fees are unpaid even if:
- unbilled
- client issued a note rec
Rule:
- MIPP may NOT sign current yr audit report if unpaid fees from > 1yr prior
Exemption
- If client in bankruptcy, rule NOT apply
financial interests
- when is independence impaired and
- NOT impaired
Impaired
- covered member has/committed to acquire any DIRECT (whether material or not) or any MATERIAL INDIRECT financial interest in an attest
NOT Impaired
- Only if interests are both INDIRECT and IMMATERIAL
FINANCIAL INTEREST
Def
Includes ownership (or obligation to obtain ownership) in
- equity
- debt
- Derivatives issued by entity
FINANCIAL INTEREST
Direct (3) vs Indirect
DIRECT - An interest:
- Owned directly (even if managed by others)
- Under one’s control (even if managed by others)
- Beneficially owned through an investment vehicle, estate, trust, or other intermediary when the beneficiary either:
- Controls the intermediary, or
- Has the authority in investment decisions.
INDIRECT An interest beneficially owned through an investment vehicle, estate, trust, or other intermediary when the beneficiary neither:
- Controls the intermediary, nor
- Has the authority to supervise or participate in its investment decisions.
BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP
- Def
Individual or entity is NOT the record owner but has a RIGHT to some or all of the underlying benefits of ownership, such as to:
- Direct the voting
- Dispose of the interest
- Receive its economic benefits
FINANCIAL INTEREST rules apply to…
Covered members Independence
If POPE is not covered member, that person, immediate family, or group acting together can NOT own MORE THAN 5% of client’s ownership interest
UNSOLICITED FINANCIAL INTERESTS
How to maintain independence
Gift
If CM rec/learn of gift, that is EITHER
- direct interest
- material indirect interest
Independence not impaired if
- dispose of interest ASA practable (no later than 30d after knowledge/right to dispose it) AND
- not participate on attest engagement team after learning of and before disposing of
If not yet has right to dispose, independence not impaired if
- member not participate on team (after learning/before disposing
- interest is NOT material to member
MUTUAL FUNDS
- Types of ownerships
DIRECT- interest in fund itself
INDIRECT – own 5% or less of outstanding shares of diversified mutual fund
MUTUAL FUNDS
- When independence impairments
NOT impaired
- Immaterial AND indirect
IMPAIRED If
- Own > 5% of diversified fund’s shares
- Ownership in undiversified fund
- Must evaluate fund’s underlying investments for any MATERIAL INDIRECT interests
IFMs
Immediate family members
SELF DIRECT
- Examples, Re: investments
- covered member is a TRUSTEE of retirement plan and SUPERVISES its investments
- covered member PARTICIPATES in retirement plan and can DIRECT investments
RETIREMENT, SAVINGS, COMPENSATION
- Direct/indirect
DIRECT (impair indep even if immaterial)
Covered member or IFM can
- SELF DIRECT investments into plan or
- participate in plans investment decisions
INDIRECT Covered member or IFM
- do NOT self direct or participate in investment decision
- underlying investments are NOT MATERIAL
DEFINED BENEFIT PLAN
- Re: independence
Covered members do not HOLD interest in investments
- b/c amt rec’d not dependent on performance of investments
UNLESS covered member or IFM are trustees/investment decision,
- then impairs EVEN if IMMATERIAL
EMPLOYEE STOCK OPTION PLAN
INDIRECT While beneficially owned by covered member
DIRECT When has right to dispose of them