Assignments Flashcards
In the space below define and describe what it means for a cell to be specified vs. determined
towards a certain cell fate. Give an example of an experiment using the early frog embryo that
would distinguish between the two types of cellular potential. You can use a diagram to help
illustrate your answer. [4 marks]
-Both terms describe the developmental state of a cell as a measure of the level of commitment a
cell has towards a certain fate [0.5].
-Specified describes the developmental status/state of a group of cells such that when the cells are
isolated from an embryo [0.5], or another developmental context, and placed in a neutral
environment such as a culture dish [0.5], these cells will develop according to their normal
developmental fate.
-The cells said to be capable of differentiating autonomously [0.5], that is, they do not require
further cues from the environment in order to differentiate [0.5].
-Specification is the first stage [0.5] and is a labile phase such that the commitment to a cell fate
is still capable of being reversed [0.5].
-The second stage of commitment is determination [0.5].
-A cell or tissue is said to be determined when it is capable of differentiating autonomously even
when placed into another region of the embryo [0.5].
-A transplant experiment [0.5] is an
example of this.
-If it is able to differentiate according to its original fate even under these circumstances, it is
assumed that the commitment is irreversible [0.5].
-This suggests that a cells fate can no longer
be changed according to environmental cues.
From the experiments performed by Wilhem Roux and Hans Dreisch two forms of development
were modeled termed mosaic and regulative, respectively. Define each term and explain how
each experiment can be used to explain each form of development. As a part of your answer,
describe how each scientist explained their different results. [6 marks]
-Mosaic development: the embryo appears to be constructed of independent self-differentiating
parts. [0.5]
-The embryo develops through the distributions of cytoplasmic (morphogenetic)
determinants [0.5].
-Determinants are often proteins or messenger RNA [0.5] that are placed in
different regions of the egg cytoplasm [0.5] and are apportioned/localized to the different cells as
the embryo divides [0.5].
-These cytoplasmic determinants specify the cell type.
-When one cell of the two-cell embryo is destroyed one half of the embryo develops.
-This implies
that both cells have enough information to form one respective half of the embryo [0.5].
-It also
implies that they develop independently [0.5] and that if one cell is removed, the other will not
change their fate to compensate for its loss [0.5]. [3 marks]
-Regulative development: explains the ability of an embryo to develop normally even when cells
are removed or rearranged [0.5].
-This describes the ability of the embryonic cells to change their
fates [0.5] to compensate for the missing parts [0.5].
-This form of development implies that cells
in the embryo have the competence to differentiate into cell-types other than their normal fate
[0.5].
-In the sea urchin embryo, the remaining cell is able to form the cells that would normally develop
from the missing cell.
-This suggests 1) the cells can change their fate in response to a change in the
early embryo, this is an indicator of commitment, [0.5] -2) cells somehow communicate such that
the missing parts are detected and a compensation in fate of all of the cells can be made [0.5] and
-3) the potential of each of the cells in the embryo is greater than their normal fate, this is an
indicator of potency [0.5]. [3 marks]
As our understanding of embryo development has progressed the terms of mosaic vs. regulative
development have been modified. Autonomous specification vs. conditional specification seems
to be a more accurate means to explain the scientist’s results. Describe autonomous specification
and conditional specification. Define the term autonomous by contrasting it to non-autonomous
development and use cells of the early frog embryo to explain your answer. Explain what
conditional specification might suggest about a cell’s potential to form a specific cell fate in the early
sea urchin embryo. [6 marks]
-Autonomous specification, if a cell or groups of cells is removed and placed in isolation the cells
will produce the same cells that it would have made if it were still part of the embryo. -This implies
that the cell has all the information or factors it requires to differentiate into its normal fate and
that no environmental signals or factors are required [1].
-The embryo from which that cell is
taken will lack those cells (and only those cells) that would have been produced by the missing
cells.
-This indicates that the other cells are unable to compensate for the cell loss. -This is likely a
combination of absent cellular communication and limited competence [1].
-Autonomous means that a cell is self-regulating.
-It does not require cues from other cells or the
environment in order to be specified towards a particular cell fate [1].
-In the frog, the one half of the embryo can develop independently of the other half. [1]
-Conditional specification, involves interactions with the environment or neighbouring cells.
-This is
also a description of potential such that each cell originally has the ability to become many
different cell types.
-The interactions of the cell with other cells restricts the fate of one or both of
the participants.
-The fate of a cell depends upon the conditions in which the cell finds itself. [1]
-If a blastomere is removed from the sea urchin embryo, the remaining embryonic cells alter their
fates so that the roles of the missing cells can be taken over.
-Cells recognize a missing cell type and
the remaining cells change their fates to compensate for the missing parts. [1]
During the first division of the C. elegans embryo, several events occur that allow
asymmetric distribution of cytoplasmic determinates. Using what is known about the
cytoskeleton of the egg cortex and the function of the PAR proteins, describe the steps that
regulate this asymmetry.
Initiation of asymmetry in the egg. [2 marks]
-Following fertilization, the sperm DNA and centrosome move to the pole closest to where
the sperm entered the elliptical egg. [1]
-The sperm centrosome [0.5] abuts the cortex and
specifies this end of the zygote as the posterior [0.5].
During the first division of the C. elegans embryo, several events occur that allow
asymmetric distribution of cytoplasmic determinates. Using what is known about the
cytoskeleton of the egg cortex and the function of the PAR proteins, describe the steps that
regulate this asymmetry.
Establishing Polarity: the function and localization of the PAR proteins. [10 marks]
-The PAR genes and PKC-3 encode a variety of cortically enriched scaffolding [0.5] and
signaling proteins [0.5].
-PAR proteins segregate to distinct anterior and posterior [0.5]
cortical domains [0.5]
-As polarization occurs, contractile cortical ruffles that initially appear throughout the
cortex become limited to the anterior, leaving the posterior cortex smooth. [1]
-The multi-PDZ domain protein PAR-3, the PDZ and CRIB domain protein PAR-6 and the
atypical protein kinase C (aPKC) PKC-3 localize to the contractile anterior cortex. [3.5]
-The serine-threonine kinase PAR-1 and the RING protein PAR-2 occupy a complementary
domain in the smooth posterior cortex . [2.5]
-The kinase PAR-4 and the 14-3-3 protein PAR-5 are cortically enriched but remain
symmetrically distributed. [1]
-PAR-6 clears away from the posterior cortex and moves anteriorly, and at the same time
PAR-2 fills in the posterior cortical domain devoid of PAR-6 [1].
-The boundary between the anterior PAR6 and posterior PAR-2 domains stabilizes once it
reaches the middle of the embryo. [1]
-‘Anterior’ and ‘posterior’ PAR proteins polarize the zygote by signaling to effectors that
alter the distribution of developmental determinants [1] and regulate spindle
positioning [1].
-These effectors include MEX-5 and MEX-6 (muscle excess) [1], which are cytoplasmic zincfinger proteins required for the posterior enrichment of several proteins that are
important for germline [1]
-P-granules composed of mRNA and proteins required for
development of the germline [1]
-Cortically enriched GPR-1 and GPR-2 (G protein regulator) proteins, which control the
asymmetric positioning of the mitotic spindle. [1]
During the first division of the C. elegans embryo, several events occur that allow
asymmetric distribution of cytoplasmic determinates. Using what is known about the
cytoskeleton of the egg cortex and the function of the PAR proteins, describe the steps that
regulate this asymmetry.
The mechanism behind the movement of cell components. [3 marks]
-Networks of actin filaments and motor protein myosin (actomyosin) form the contractile
cortex just under the egg’s cell membrane. [1]
-PAR domains form in the C. elegans zygote through an asymmetric contraction of an
actomyosin network at the cell cortex [1]
-Before polarization, nonmuscle myosin II heavy chain (NMY-2, hereafter ‘myosin’) and F- actin are found throughout the cortex as large foci and interconnecting filaments.
-Following fertilization, actomyosin foci form, contract and turn over with no net
directionality, causing cortical ruffling [1].
-As polarization initiates, actomyosin
contractility is inhibited at the posterior cortex, causing the remaining tensile network to
contract anteriorly. [1]
-Actomyosin contraction creates an anteriorly directed cortical flow
and induces the anterior translocation of PAR-3, PAR-6 and PKC-3 [1]
-anterior flow of the cortex causes posterior-ward flow of the cytoplasmic components (P- granules) [1]
During the first division of the C. elegans embryo, several events occur that allow
asymmetric distribution of cytoplasmic determinates. Using what is known about the
cytoskeleton of the egg cortex and the function of the PAR proteins, describe the steps that
regulate this asymmetry.
The function of the PAR proteins in polarity maintenance. [3 marks]
-PAR domain maintenance is mediated by Rho GTPase signaling [0.5] and through
reciprocal inhibitory interactions between anterior and posterior PAR proteins.
-a negative feedback loop [0.5] involving two kinases, aPKC, at the anterior [1] and PAR-1 at
the posterior [1] maintain two distinct domains
-each kinase inhibits specific proteins from
associating locally [0.5]
-The Rho GTPase CDC-42 regulates polarity maintenance.
-CDC-42 becomes enriched at the
anterior cortex as polarity is established.
-CDC-42 regulates polarity maintenance largely through PAR-6
-PKC-3 keeps PAR-2 off of the cortex by phosphorylating a domain within PAR-2 that has
been shown to mediate its cortical localization
-LGL-1 [a homolog of Lethal giant larvae (Lgl)] functions redundantly with PAR-2 to keep anterior
PAR proteins from returning to the posterior cortex during the maintenance phase
During the first division of the C. elegans embryo, several events occur that allow
asymmetric distribution of cytoplasmic determinates. Using what is known about the
cytoskeleton of the egg cortex and the function of the PAR proteins, describe the steps that
regulate this asymmetry.
Give one example of how similar proteins are regulating Drosophila development. Briefly
explain how these proteins function. Give at least one similarity and one difference
between the two systems. [4 marks]
- In C. elegans, PAR-3 protein regulates the cell’s polarity
- For Drospohila, a similar protein to PAR-3 is Bazooka (Baz)
- Baz received its name due to its disruptions in the epithelial making holes in the cuticle
- one similarity between PAR-3 and Baz is in their sequence, being homologous to each other
- Drosophila and C. elegans have similar systems in the sense that they share homologous proteins involved in polarization of the cells (PAR-1, aPKC=PKC-3, PAR-6, Lkbl (PAR-4), Bazooka (PAR-3))
- a difference between Drosophila and C. elegans’ system is the specification of the axis in the cell
- for Drosophila, the oocyte’s axis specification happens before fertilization
- on the other hand, C. elegan’s axis specification occurs after fertilization
- Bazooka’s function is to establish apical-basal polarity in epithelial cells, as well as helping with making single cells asymmetrical
Why is asymmetric cell division an important process during development?
-cells use components of the cytoskeleton to create polarity within the cell.
-This polarity creates asymmetric distribution of membrane-bound and cytoplasmic molecules,
which at cytokinesis, can be unequally inherited by each of the daughter cells.
-important in early fate specification and
patterning of the early C. elegans and Drosophila embryo
PAR proteins are important in which processes?
- during first cell division in C. elegans
- stem cell divisions
- cell migration
- neural development
What experiment did Wilhem Roux perform and what were his results?
- used a hot needle to kill one of the cells of the two-cell stage of the frog embryo
- The remaining cell was allowed to continue to develop and a half frog embryo resulted
- concluded that the early frog embryo must use a form of development called mosaic development
What experiment did Hans Driesch perform and what were his results?
-separated the sea urchin two-cell embryo which resulted in
death of one of the cells
-The remaining cell continued to develop and resulted in a complete embryo although it approximately half of the size of normal embryo.
Cell fate definition
describes what a cell will normally develop into
Planar cell polarity
used to explain how cells within a sheet, such as an epithelial
layer, can sense direction within the plane of a tissue.
Epithelium
- a continuous sheet of cells that adhere together to form a barrier
- Cells within this sheet form strong cell-cell adhesions to maintain the structure of the layer.
- Within the sheet these cells have two major types of polarity: apico-basal polarity (apical to basal) and planar polarity
Apico-basal polarity (apical to basal)
the basal surface is in contact with an extracellular
matrix called the basal lamina
Planar polarity
This is polarity within the plane of the epithelium.
Imaginal discs
-The Drosophila wing develops from a structure in the larvae called an imaginal disc.
-These are sac-like groups of cells that will grow and change shape during metamorphosis to
create the organs and tissues of the adult
Trichomes
-The bristles, also called trichomes, of the wing are small hair like structures that follow a proximo-distal polarity or orientation