Assessment of the UK Constitution Flashcards
Why is its uncodified nature an advantage?
It’s neither codified or entrenched, so it’s flexible and adaptable and can be easily changed to react to changing circumstances, demonstrated in the 2010 General Election when there were no fixed constitutional rules to deal with the indecisive result. Gus O’Donnell (the Cabinet Secretary) had drawn up draft procedures for the possibility of a hung parliament. His plan worked well and the new coalition government was installed with relatively little disruption or conflict.
Why is its traditional quality an advantage?
It is traditional and stood the test of time. The fact that Britain hasn’t suffered a violent revolution or major political unrest since the 17th century civil war suggest that the constitution has enduring qualities.
Why is its lack of constitutional restraints an advantage?
Ensures that Parliament and therefore government can act decisively, unrestricted by excessive constitutional restraints
Why are traditional elements such as the HoL and the monarchy an advantage?
It contains traditional elements such as the House of Lords and the monarchy. These help to maintain public support for the system.
Why could the lack of constitutional restraints be considered a disadvantage?
The lack of restraints on the powers of government and Parliament may be dangerous, especially to individual and minority rights.
Why are the traditional elements considered a disadvantage?
It contains traditional and outdated institutions such as the FPTP electoral system, the monarchy and the House of Lords. Not only are such institutions often seen as outdated, they are also accused of being undemocratic
Why could the lack of separation of powers be considered a disadvantage?
The lack of separation of powers between government and Parliament means that government tends to dominate Parliament. This is often seen as undemocratic as Parliament represents the interest of the people.
Why can its uncodification be considered a disadvantage?
The fact that the constitution is uncodified means that many people are ignorant of it. This may result in political apathy and lack of support for the political system.
