Aquinas natural law Flashcards
What is natural law based on?
Natural law is based on a particular view and nature of the universe.
What does natural law assume about the universe?
Natural law assumes that the universe has a natural order that works to achieve an ‘end’ or ‘purpose’.
What is believed to determine the order, direction, and purpose of the universe in natural law theory?
The order, direction, and purpose of the universe are believed to be determined by a supernatural power.
What does the term “telos” mean in the context of natural law?
Telos means purpose or end goal.
What is the telos for humans according to natural law theory?
The telos for humans is eudaimonia.
Define synderesis.
Synderesis is the innate knowledge of a basic moral principle: to do good and avoid evil.
What is a precept in the context of natural law?
A precept is a rule intended to regulate human behaviour.
How is reason defined in natural law theory?
Reason is the capacity of applying logic consciously by drawing conclusions from new or existing information, with the aim of seeking the truth.
From what idea did natural law originate?
Natural law originated from the idea that everything has a purpose (telos).
How can the purpose (telos) of something be determined?
The purpose (telos) can be deduced from the design of it.
According to natural law, what defines something as “good”?
Good comes from fulfilling that purpose (telos).
On what basis is natural law interpreted?
Natural law is based on nature as interpreted by human reason.
Is natural law primarily deontological or teleological?
Natural law is mostly deontological but has some teleological aspects.
What type of ethical theory is natural law classified as in terms of identifying right actions?
Natural law is absolutist as right actions can be identified.
Who created natural law and where is it particularly influential?
Natural law was created by St. Thomas Aquinas and is influential within the Catholic Church.
Who are the two main philosophers associated with natural law?
Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas.
Who is credited with natural law’s first appearance and what was his profession?
Cicero, a Roman lawyer, is credited with natural law’s first appearance.
What is Cicero’s famous quote about true law?
“True law is right reason in agreement with nature.”
What was Cicero’s profession and philosophical stance?
Cicero was a Roman philosopher who believed in the universality of ethical laws, rejecting the idea that ethics is subjective.
What is Cicero’s view on the universality of laws?
Cicero believed that there is one universal law for humanity, not different laws for different places or times.
What does Cicero’s quote about law emphasise about the nature of ethical laws?
Cicero’s quote emphasises that there will be not one law at Rome and another at Athens, or one now and another later, but one law that is everlasting and unchangeable, encompassing all nations and all times.
According to natural law, what are the characteristics of the universal law?
The universal law is absolute, timeless, and eternal. It is binding upon all people in all places at all times and is discoverable through reason.
What does Aquinas say belongs to natural law according to “Summa Theologica”?
“To the Natural Law belongs everything to which a man is inclined according to his nature.”
What is the essence of natural law according to Aquinas?
We have this natural law that needs to be discovered and followed.
According to Aquinas, what should humans do by nature?
By nature, we should do good and avoid evil.
What does H.L.A. Hart say about the principles of human conduct and their discovery?
H.L.A. Hart says that there are certain principles of human conduct awaiting discovery by human reason.
According to H.L.A. Hart, what must human law conform to in order to be valid?
Human law must conform to the principles of human conduct discovered by reason if it is to be valid.
What does “awaiting discovery by human reason” imply about the nature of rules and morality?
It implies that we should not invent our own rules because they suit us; instead, we are discovering a universal, eternal law that is binding upon all people at all times.
How does Hart’s view relate to the concept of eternal law and its characteristics?
Eternal law is discovered by reason and then followed, showing that morality is objective and absolute.
What does Hart’s perspective indicate about the objectivity and absoluteness of morality?
Hart’s perspective indicates that morality is not a matter of personal opinion or preference but is based on objective, absolute eternal laws that are discovered by reason.
What are the ancient philosophical influences on Aquinas’s natural law theory?
Natural law predates Aquinas and can be traced back to ancient Greek philosophy, particularly Aristotle and the Stoics.
What are the four tiers of law according to Aquinas?
The four tiers of law according to Aquinas are Eternal Law, Divine Law, Natural Law, and Human Law.
What does the concept of synderesis entail in Aquinas’s natural law?
Synderesis is the innate knowledge of basic moral principles, specifically the principle “to do good and avoid evil.”
What are primary precepts and secondary precepts in Aquinas’s natural law?
Primary precepts are the basic principles of natural law that are universally true and binding, such as preserving life, reproducing, and seeking the truth. Secondary precepts are the specific rules derived from these primary principles, which can vary according to circumstances.
How does the doctrine of double effect relate to natural law?
The doctrine of double effect states that an action with both a good and a bad effect can be morally permissible if the bad effect is not intended and the good effect outweighs the bad. This doctrine is often applied in natural law ethics.
What is proportionalism in the context of natural law?
Proportionalism is a development within natural law that suggests that actions are morally right if the good outcomes proportionally outweigh the bad outcomes, taking into consideration the context and circumstances.
How did Aquinas’s approach to natural law differ from ancient Greek philosophy?
While ancient Greek philosophy, particularly Aristotle, influenced natural law, Aquinas integrated these ideas into a Christian framework, emphasising that natural law is part of God’s eternal law and highlighting the role of divine revelation.
Why is it important to understand applications and proportionalism when discussing natural moral law?
Applications and proportionalism are important developments of natural law, providing nuanced approaches to moral decision-making. Understanding them helps in discussing how natural law can be applied in various situations and in evaluating its practical implications.
How did Stoicism view the world?
Stoicism viewed the world as an ordered place arranged by nature, or by the gods, in the best way possible.
What did the Stoics believe about the nature of the universe and how we should conduct ourselves?
The Stoics believed that the world was an ordered place and that nature tells us how we should conduct ourselves and what the right thing to do is.
What is the “divine spark” according to Stoic philosophy?
The “divine spark” is an innate ability within humans that enables them to reason and understand the universe.
How does the Stoic belief in the divine spark relate to human reason?
The Stoics believed that this divine spark allowed humans to use their reason to observe nature and work out the right way to conduct themselves and lead their lives.
According to Stoicism, what is the path to human happiness and a good life?
The path to human happiness and a good life is to accept the natural order of things and live according to nature’s rules.
How does the concept of natural law relate to the Stoic view of the natural order?
Natural law is living in accordance with the natural order of things and living according to nature’s rules, which can be understood by using reason to observe the world.
What is the connection between the design argument and natural law in Stoicism?
The design argument suggests that one can know God’s existence through the observation of nature. In terms of natural law, one can understand what God wants humans to do by using reason to interpret the natural world.
Why did the Stoics favor reason over emotion?
The Stoics favored reason (mind) over emotion (heart) because they believed that reason is essential for understanding the natural order and determining the right way to behave.
How is the Stoic emphasis on reason important to natural law?
The Stoic emphasis on reason is important to natural law because it underlies the belief that humans can use their rational abilities to discern the natural order and moral principles that should guide their conduct.
How did Aquinas draw upon Aristotle’s ideas in his development of natural law theory?
Aquinas developed many of his ideas from his reading of Aristotle, particularly regarding the concept of telos and the purpose of human life.
What did Aristotle believe about the universe and everything within it?
Aristotle believed that the universe and everything within it has a telos, or end or purpose.
What does “telos” mean according to Aristotle?
“Telos” means end or purpose. According to Aristotle, everything has a purpose or aim.
What is the telos of humans according to Aristotle?
The telos of humans, according to Aristotle, is to achieve Eudaimonia - a state of supreme happiness, flourishing, and fulfillment.
Define “Eudaimonia” according to Aristotle.
Eudaimonia is a state of supreme happiness, flourishing, and fulfillment, which is considered the ultimate goal of human life by Aristotle.
How did Aquinas incorporate Aristotle’s ideas in his argument for the existence of God?
Aquinas was influenced by Aristotle in the development of his argument for the existence of God, particularly in his use of teleological arguments, which suggest that the design and order observed in the universe imply the existence of a divine creator.
How did Aquinas agree with Aristotle regarding the nature of human existence?
Aquinas agreed with Aristotle that rationality or the ability to reason was a fundamental aspect of human existence.
What did Aquinas agree with Aristotle about regarding the purpose of everything?
Aquinas agreed with Aristotle that everything had a purpose.
How did Aquinas differ from Aristotle regarding the origin of purpose?
While Aristotle did not attribute the purpose of everything to a divine source, Aquinas argued that the purpose of everything was given to it by God.
Which of Aristotle’s ideas did Aquinas incorporate regarding virtues, and how did Aquinas expand upon them?
Aquinas incorporated Aristotle’s ideas about the four cardinal virtues but expanded upon them by emphasising that the purpose of developing these virtues was to fulfil one’s true nature in relation to God.
What was the purpose of developing the cardinal virtues according to Aquinas?
According to Aquinas, the purpose of developing the cardinal virtues was to develop as a human being and fulfill one’s true nature in relation to God.
How did the concept of “telos” influence Aquinas’s understanding of human purpose?
The concept of “telos” influenced Aquinas’s understanding of human purpose by suggesting that humans have a specific end or purpose that they should strive to fulfill.
What did Aquinas derive from Aristotle regarding the concept of telos?
Aquinas derived from Aristotle the idea of telos, particularly the concept of eudaimonia, which refers to a state of supreme happiness and fulfilment.
How did Aquinas view the role of reason in understanding the world and natural law?
Aquinas believed that reason was essential for understanding the ordered and rational world created by God. He argued that humans have the capacity, given by God, to understand the world and should use right reason to interpret and make sense of it, which would allow them to understand natural law.
What distinguishes humans from other animals according to Aquinas, and how does this relate to reason?
Aquinas believed that humans have a unique ability to reason, unlike other animals. This ability to reason allows humans to think, interpret, and make sense of the world, which is crucial for understanding natural law.
How did the concept of “nature” impact Aquinas’s ethical framework?
The concept of “nature” influenced Aquinas’s ethical framework by emphasizing the importance of human nature and the need to act in accordance with it.
What implications did the concept of “nature” have for Aquinas’s views on certain behaviours, like homosexuality?
The concept of “nature” led Aquinas to believe that certain behaviors, like homosexuality, are unnatural because they go against the inherent order of human nature. He argued that humans should live in accordance with nature, which includes following natural law principles.
Who are the two main philosophers associated with Natural Law?
Aristotle and Aquinas
What did Natural Law originate from?
Everything has a purpose, purpose comes from the design of it.
What did Cicero mean by “one law everlasting and unchangeable will encompass all nature for all time”?
One universal law that is absolute, timeless, and eternal - binding upon all people in all places at all time.
How does good come about?
Through fulfilling the purpose (telos).
What is humans telos?
Eudaimonia - human flourishing.
What is Natural Law based on and how do we find out what is good?
Based on nature, through interpreting nature through human reason.
What is synderesis?
Innate knowledge of moral principle - ‘do good and avoid evil’.
What type of theory is Natural Law?
Absolutists as right actions can be identified
Who created Natural Law and what denomination of Christianity does it influence?
ST Thomas Aquinas - influential within the catholic church.
What is the creator of Natural Law book called?
Summa Theologica.