Animal models of traumatic brain injury Flashcards
Primitive level: steps of TBI?
mechanical input -> primary injury -> secondary injuries ->
secondary injuries and restorative processes influence ong term outcome
Describe impact effects of primary injury?
- tissue deformation
- contusions
- lacerations
- haemorrhages
Describe non-impact effects of primary injury?
- diffuse axonal injury (DAI)
- swelling
Examples of focal injury?
- contusions
- lacerations
- haemorrhages
Examples of diffuse injury?
- DAI
- swelling/herniation
- ischaemia
- vascular injury
Describe the mechanisms behind secondary injury in TBI
Primary injury -> Ca2+ influx -> NT release -> excitotoxicity
-> mitochondrial damage -> ROS -> gene exp -> BBB opening -> inflammation -> oedema -> raised ICP -> herniation
Inflammation -> release of DAMPs, chemokines, cytokines -> neutrophils, monocytes -> microglia/astrocytes
Why are in vivo models of TBI necessary?
Single models can’t truly reproduce the complex pathophysiological spectrym of TBI
(need to ID mechanisms and test therapies)
How to assess the validity of a model?
- face validity: same phenomenology
- construct validity: similar underlying mechanisms
- aetiological validity: similar changes in aetiology
- predictive validity: predictive value, accuracy and reliability
List similarities between mammalian TBI models and real TBI
- gross histopathology (contusion, BBB disruption, cell loss, brain atrophy)
- molecular changes (inflammation/apoptosis/oxidative stress/axonal injury)
- functional deficits (memory and learning deficits)
- long term effects (detectable in rodents up to 1 yr)
Differences between primary mammalian TBI models and real TBI
Anaesthesia (not in human TBI): type of anaesthesia used can affect functional and histological outcome e.g. diff. cell count
Craniotomy (not in human TBI): surgery is a brain injury itself; MRI shows craniotomy results in oedema/inflammation
Primary problems of in vivo TBI models
- Drug selection: drugs rushed to trials (e.g. CRASH study gave steroids for TBI for anti-inflamm but this increased mortality)
- Trial design: low participant number, single vs multi-centre trials
- Patient selection: mild/mod/severe TBI, confounding factors, sex?
- Endpoints: GCS, motor/cognitive impairments, survival
Describe and evaluate in vitro TBI models
Use
- immortalised cell lines
- primary cell cultures
- organtypic slices
- acute explants
- 3D organoids
Induce TBI through:
- stretch
- shearing
- weight drop
- blast injury
- stir, transection, acceleration
PROS
- repeatable
- controlled biomechanics
- environmental and pathophysiological isolation
- high throught + screening approaches
CONS
- snapshot
- clinical improvement?
- functional outcome?
- network effects?
- extra-CNS effects?
List examples of in vivo TBI models
- drosophilia (invertebrates)
- zebrafish (non-mammalian)
MAMMALIAN:
- controlled cortical impact
- fluid percussion
- weight drop
- penetrating ballistic model
- blast injury
- rotational model
- Maryland model
Describe and evaluate drosophilia (invertebrate) model method
- inside container w/ loaded spring to fling them -> TBI
- pipette pressure pulse to hit head
Causes vacuoles and cell loss
PROS
- cheap
- no ethical restrictions
- fast life cycle
- easy genetic modification
CONS
- reproducibility
- no skull
- different biomechanics
- morphological differences
Describe and evaluate zebrafish (non-mammalian) model method
- stab wound injury
- weight drop
- focussed ultrasound
Causes inflammation, cell loss, delta (behaviour)
PROS
- fast life cycle
- less ethical restrictions
- study behaviour
- vertebrate
CONS
- reproducibility
- different biomechanics
- different metabolism