Anderson Flashcards
What is the principle of maximum parsimony?
- simplest hypothesis
What kind of hypothesis do you always have for transmission genetics?
- genetic hypothesis
How is hypothesis testing carried out for transmission genetics?
- genetic hypothesis leads to prediction
- in some cases can use observed no.s to give idea of genetic hypothesis
- compare prediction with observed
What is a null hypothesis?
- diff between O and E no.s can be explained by chance alone
- no signif diff between O and E
What is P (p values)?
- probability of obtaining observed deviation, or even bigger, assuming null hypothesis correct
What gives a simple approximation of P?
- chi-squared
What does a p value of greater than 0.05 mean?
- no signif deviation from expectation at 5% level
- if did 20x, expect 1x to get deviation bigger, can accept null hypothesis
- no reason to reject it, can’t say its proven, just failed to prove it wrong
What does a p value of less than 0.01 mean?
- signif deviation from expectation at 1% level
- if did 100x and genetic hypothesis correct, only expect deviation 1x, so quite unlikely result just by chance
What does a p value of less than 0.05 mean?
- signif deviation from expectation at 5% level
Why is there a grey area for p values between 0.01 and 0.05?
- can’t just assume one thing if just below threshold and opp if just above threshold
- chi-squared only aid to thinking about signif, have to weigh up data biologically
Where are qualitative differences in phenotype found?
- in “conventional” Mendelian analysis
- prod by allelic variation at single locus
What are quantitative characters influenced by?
- usually several to many genes and env
- look at real pop (not in lab)
- several oligogenes or many polygenes
What is a polygene?
- 1 member of group of genes contributing to quantitative character, NOT group of genes
What is an oligogene?
- 1 member of group of genes, w/ fewer members but each are making bigger contribution
What is a QTL (quantitative trait locus)?
- section of DNA that correlates w/ variation in phenotype
Why is unlinked always the default hypothesis?
- simplest explanation
What are the 2 types of variation?
- continuous
- discontinuous
What is a meristic character?
- countable quality w/ integer values
When are genes said to act additively?
- when sub of 1 allele for another alters phenotype value by certain amount irrespective of other alleles present at same or other loci
What simplifying assumptions are made in additive model for polygenic inheritance?
- 3 genes
- each making same contribution
- no env contribution
What is the additive model for polygenic inheritance (EXAMPLE)?
- height of hypothetical plant controlled by 3 genes
- a1, b1, c1 each add 1cm
- a2, b2, c2 each add 2cm
- a1a1 = +2cm
- a1a2 = +3cm
- a2a2 = +4cm
- then to all of these:
–> b1b1c1c1 = +4cm
–> b2b2c2c2 = +8cm - no dominance, no epistasis
P1 x P2 = a1a1b1b1c1c1 (+6cm) x a2a2b2b2c2c2 (+12cm)
F1 = a1a2b1b2c1c2 (+9cm)
F2 = 8 phenotypes in ratio 1:6:15:20:15:6:1
What are the general features of the additive model for polygenic inheritance?
- F1 mean exactly intermediate between P1 and P2
- F2 mean same as F1
- variation greater in F2 than F1
- extremes in F2 correspond to P1 and P2
How do extremes in F2 correspond to P1 and P2 (additive model for polygenic inheritance)?
- for n genes proportion F2 as short as short parent = (1/4)^n
- which is a v big no.
- so unless no. genes v small or vast no. in F2 gen, then prob not going to see extremes
Why is scale transformation needed?
- common problem to find non-normal distributions = skewed distributions
- not a big problem just need to define quantitative character in way that will fit, eg. log(score)
- makes curve much more symmetrical so maths will now work for it
What are the components of total phenotypic variance (VP)?
- = genetic (VG) added to environmental (VE) component
What is heritability in the broad sense?
- H^2 = VG/VP
What does broad sense heritability show?
- indicates proportion of phenotypic variance attributable to genetic variation
- property of particular pop in particular env
- not good predictor of success in selective breeding
- only part of VG is due to additive effects of gene
Why is only part of VG due to additive effects of gene?
- VG = VA (additive component) + VD (dominance component) + VI (interaction/epistasis component)
What is the range of values broad sense heritability can have, and what does a value of 1 mean?
- 0 to 1
- 1 means all variance due to genetic component
Why dont VD and VI operate in way modelled?
- 2 interacting alleles separated in mitosis
- so interact w/ other alleles when fertilised
- could decrease superiority due to diff allele combo, so inherently unpredictable
What is narrow sense heritability, h^2?
- h^2 = VA/VP
- good predictor of success, as focusses on VA (1 component of VG)
How can estimation of narrow sense heritability be used in selective breeding?
- test effect of selection on pop involved
- choose best by taking from above certain point in distribution = truncation point
- mean of offspring will be higher than original mean
How is realised heritability (h^2) and its components calc, and what does a positive value mean?
- response to selection / selection differential
- response to selection = mean of offspring - original mean
- selection differential = mean of parents - original mean
- +ve value shows trying to increase phenotypic score (-ve means opp)
How can narrow sense heritability be estimated using a graph?
- DIAG*
- plot mean of offspring against mid parent value
- slope gives h^2
- for some characteristics (eg. egg prod) may need to use regression of offspring on 1 parent, so h^2 will be 2x slope
What are the typical values of h^2 and what do they mean?
- high (>0.5) –> more than half contributed by VA
- medium (0.2-0.5) –> still a signif contribution by VA
- low (<0.2)
What is the breeders equation?
- response to selection = h^2 x selection differential
What are the limits of selection?
- not poss to improve phenotypic scores indefinitely by cont selection, as favourable alleles may all approach fixation
- -> mostly makes use of existing genetic variation, VA will decrease, so if VE stays same then h^2 will also decrease
- selection for 1 trait may lead to correlated response in another trait affecting fitness (eg. selection for extreme size often leads to loss of fertility, so problem maintaining pop)
- inbreeding depression
How is selective breeding diff to natural selection?
- over short period of time (few gens)
How does inbreeding depression occur as a result of selective breeding?
- picking ‘best’ encourages inbreeding
- increased freq of deleterious recessive alleles, as having 2 copies becomes more likely
What is a solution to inbreeding depression?
- select 2 lines (may have inbreeding)
- cross them
- hope recessive alleles complement each other and gen F1 hybrid w/ superior phenotype
How can genotype and environment interact?
- superiority of 1 genotype over another may not be maintained in all envs
- DIAG*
Why does a heritability of 0.7 for maize height not indicate that 70% of height of each plant is determined by genes acting additively and 30% by environment?
- means 70% variance in maize height in typical pop, due to genetic variation for genes acting additively
- 30% due to diffs in envs experienced by diff plants and interactions between alleles
If h^2 for maize height = 0.7 and h^2 for ear length = 0.17, is it true that genes are more important in determining height than ear length?
- no
- deletion of relevant genes for either character might be lethal
- both important to us, ear length could have undergone more selection so even be more important
If heritability for maize height is 0.7, is it true that there is little scope for increasing height by changing env?
- no
- high heritability indicates diff in envs experienced by individuals in typical pop contribute less to overall variance in genotype
- may still be scope for great improvement w/ env quality, unpredictable from heritability
Does high heritability for maize height indicate if 1 pop has high higher av score than other that it must carry superior genes?
- no
- could only conclude this if know envs identical and even then change in env could reveal diff norms of reaction
How is heritability in humans diff?
- heritability calcs assume env varies independently of genotype
- but family members share similar genes and envs
- regression of offspring on parents shows familiarity rather than heritability (shown by slope)
How does heritability vary for twins raised together?
- dizygotic and monozygotic twins share similar env to approx same extent
- but dizygotic twins share only 50% of genes
- so diffs in degrees of similarity between monozygotic and dizygotic twins may be attributed to genes
What is concordance?
- way of comparing degree of similarity between twins
What is a threshold trait?
- DIAGS*
- can plot threshold against liability
- there is a threshold liability
- liability influenced by genes and env
OR
- plot freq against no. predisposing alleles
- threshold zone where may or may display phenotype
- then disease where they will defo show phenotype
How can H^2 be calc for twins (assuming MZ and DZ share env to same extent)?
- 2 (tMZ - tDZ)
- where tMZ = phenotypic correlation of monozygotic twins and tDZ = phenotypic correlation of dizygotic twins
How are quantitative genes identified in humans?
- can’t do controlled crosses which allow detection by linkage to marker
- eg. originally RFLPs (restriction fragment length polymorphisms)
- eg. now SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms)
- DIAG*
What does QTL mapping involve?
- taking 2 lines where can follow many marker genes
- prod F1
- then F2 or backcross w/ parent (comparing homozygote w/ heterozygote)
- then need method to recognise 2 distributions are signif diff
What happens if the QTL and marker recombine, and what does this show about out ability to detect QTLs?
- reduce the diff in phenotypic score between homozygotes for marker alleles
- so ability to detect QTL determined by magnitude of effect by QTL on phenotypic score, and extent of recombination between marker and QTL
What does finding QTLs through linker-based analysis req/involve?
- large no. markers distributed across all chromosomes, at least every 5-10cM (can be done easily)
- test each maker for signif diff between av phenotype scores for 2 homozygotes
- or in practise usually homozygote and heterozygote in backcross
- log10 (prob of obs result if QTL assoc w/ marker / prob of obs result if QTL not assoc w/ marker)
What does identifying a QTL actually show?
- doesn’t identify gene
- just region around markers where think gene making contribution
- don’t know if more than 1 gene, but no tendency for QTLs to cluster together, distributed throughout genome
After a QTL identified, how is the gene identified?
- fine mapping
How is fine mapping carried out?
- for each marker showing signif diff, gen and compare lines that are isogenic except in region of suspected QTL and recombinant in this region
- congenic = isogenic (nearly)
- want flanking markers DIAG
- genotype recombinants prod to find COs (tells us CO is in QTL) DIAG
- look specifically at chromosome in region where we know QTL is
- can identify gene if narrow region down to 1 or a few genes
What has been used instead of linkage analysis in humans?
- GWAS
How is GWAS carried out for human diseases?
- range of DNA markers around genome, up to half a mil SNPs
- looked at many SNPs and got statistical analysis essentially equivalent to chi-squared –> log10 (P)
- null hypothesis is no assoc between marker and phenotype
- can’t use 5% level as looking at so many SNPs, so need v low probability threshold
- assoc clear if SNP is in QTL
- otherwise detection of QTLs dep on LD
How can SNPs be used to detect nearby QTLs is assoc studies?
- linkage disequilibrium
What is linkage equilibrium, and when is it expected?
- state where random assoc of alleles at any 2 loci
- expected in infinite pop w/ random mating and no selection
If allele freqs for A, a, B, b are p1, p2, q1, q2 respectively, what haplotype freqs will be gen by random assoc of alleles of 2 genes, and why is this true even if genes are linked?
- fAB = p1q1
- fAb = p1q2
- faB = p2q1
- fab = p2q2
- haplotypes gen by meiosis in wide variety of genotypes, so parental combos in 1 meiosis will be recombinants in another
- DIAG*
What is linkage disequilibrium?
- non random assoc of alleles at 2 loci
- deviation form linkage equilibrium