Ancient Philosophical Influences Flashcards
What does the slave Meno explain?
uneducated slave in ‘Meno’ can learn Pythagoras’ theorem as he has experienced it before
Iris Murdoch ‘Metaphysics as a guide to morals’
What is epistomology?
The study of knowledge
What is rationalism? (epi) + explanation
- Using reason to gain knowledge
- A priori knowledge
- It is self-evident
- Sense experience is not enough, it is not reliable
- We rely on reason/ratio
- Plato is a rationalist
What is empiricism? (epi) + explanation
- using senses to gain knowledge
- a posteriori knowledge
- based off sense experiences
- the use of a working hypothesis can be tested using observation and experiment (eg.science)
- Aristotle is an empiricist
When was Plato born/died
427-347 BCE
Who did Plato study under?
Socrates
what is the realm of forms?
a philosophical theory claiming their is a perfect reality in contrast to the flawed one we see in the material world. it is also where the soul originates.
what are ‘imperfect reflections’/particulars?
the objects that we see in the material world or the concepts when we imitate the Forms
why did plato reason there must be a realm of forms?
because everything is unreliable and changing in the material world. therefore cannot be perfect but also because there is some true essence that everything in the world seems to refer back to
Hereclitus quote
“you cannot step in the same river twice”
what is the form of the good?
The uppermost form that gives meaning to all other forms and is true knowledge itself. It illuminates all other forms as it is an ultimate end in itself - therefore also the ultimate aim of everything is goodness.
hierarchy of forms
- FOTG
- Higher Forms
- Lower Forms
- The Material World
- Shadows of the Material World
what is a higher form?
larger concepts eg. justice
what is a lower form?
perfect objects
what is the material world?
our plane of reality
What is plato’s evidence arguement
we must know of the forms to recognise them in this plane
plato said learning is just remembering (amamnesis)
he concluded, as a dualist, that our soul must have once been in the ROF
the cave allegory
prisoners are chained in a cage and see the shadows cast on the walls as reality
one of the prisoners escapes and leaves the cave
at first he is blinded by the light
but eventually he is able to see the true world is more than the one he thought was real
the prisoner go’s back into the cave to tell the others
but they shun him and will not leave the cave
what does the cave represent?
the material world
what do the prisoners represent?
humans
what do the shadows represent?
imperfect reflections
what do those casting the shadows represent?
the politicians of athens
what does the sun represent?
FOTG
what do the real world objects represent?
the forms
what does the escaped prisoner represent?
the philosopher
What is the reasoning criticism?
Why a priori not a posteriori?
What is the absurdity and extremes criticism for Plato’s cave?
the use of objects can be nonsense (eg. perfect dog poo)
or they can be illogical, eg the perfect form of cancer??
How is evil an issue for Plato’s cave analogy? How is this limited?
a perfect form of the evil would have to exist in contrast the form of the good
but this may be a misunderstanding, the material world is the ‘dark’ reflection, it is not about morality, it is simply a lack of vision
What is the issue of perception for Plato’s cave analogy?
the forms are subjective
Concepts of Beauty.Goodness may come from experience and upbringings
How are the qualities of the soul an issue for Plato’s analogy?
for your soul to remember surely it would have to have senses
what is amamnesis?
education is the process of remembering
what is the myth of Er?
- Told by Socrates
- Er died in battle
- 10 days but his body did not decay
- 12th day on funeral pyre
- came back to life
- spoke of the afterlife
- assessed, if bad received 10x pain caused in life and if good got to choose next life
- All chose wealth and power, only philosophers realised they should choose peace and justice or they would not live a moral life in the next.
What did Freud think of Plato’s theory?
A coping method reaction to the death of Socrates rather than an effective use of a priori reasoning
What did Bertrand Russle think of Plato?
When taken to extremes it becomes a bottomless pit of nonesense.