Agreement (Offer & Acceptance) Flashcards
Define: Offer
“An expression of willingness to contract on specified terms, made with the intention that it is to become legally binding as soon as it is accepted by the person to whom it is addressed” (Treitel)
What are the components of a valid offer?
An offer must be:
- Clear and Certain
- Communicated to the offeree
- Not rejected, revoked or lapsed
What are the components of a valid acceptance?
Acceptance must be:
- A mirror image of the offer
- Made by the offeree in response to the offer
- Communicated to the offeror
Case authority: Language of “may” is not sufficiently clear and certain.
Gibson v Manchester City Council
Case authority: Language of “will” is sufficiently clear and certain.
Storer v Manchester City Council
Define: Invitation to Treat
An ITT is the preliminary stage in negotiations.
Case authority: An advert is generally an ITT not an offer.
Partridge v Crittenden
Case authority: A display of goods is an ITT
Fisher v Bell
Case authority: Placing goods on supermarket shelves is also an ITT
Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots Cash Chemists
Case authority: Where an advert is sufficiently clear and certain to indicate intention to be bound, and is from the product’s manufacturer (with theoretically unlimited supply), an advert may constitute an offer
Granger v Gough
Case authority: An advert couched in certain language, may be an offer where it amounts to a unilateral offer.
Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.
Case authority: Invitations to Tender are not offers but simply invite others to make offers.
Spencer v Harding
Case authority: Offers are made by bidders, offers are only accepted when the auctioneers hammer falls. Items may be withdrawn any time up until acceptance.
Payne v Cave
Case authority: Items put up for auction “without reserve” constitute unilateral offers. (NB: Unilateral offer is with the auctioneer not the seller - claimant only entitled to damages not specific performance)
Barry v Davies
Case authority: An offer must be communicated in one of 3 ways, (1) Orally, (2) in writing, or (3) by conduct.
Taylor v Laird
An offer can be terminated by:
- Rejection
- Revocation
- Lapse
Case authority: A counter offer is a rejection followed by a new offer. The counter offer terminates the original offer.
Hyde v Wrench
Case authority: Requests for further information are distinct from counter offers - the original offer remains open.
Stevenson, Jacques & Co v McLean
Case authority: Revocation can happen any time before acceptance, but must be communicated.
Dickenson v Dodds
Case authority: Revocation may be communicated by a 3rd party.
Dickenson v Dodds