Admistartion Post Grant Flashcards
What duty’s are PRs subject to
Fiduciary duty - A PR is personally liable for loss caused by a breach of duty.
Common law duty to dispose of the deceased’s body
Statutory duty to provide information about the estate to HMRC and pay inheritance
tax (‘IHT’) due
Duty to collect in assets
Duty to administer the estate according to law
Duty to provide an inventory and account of estate assets
Duty of due diligence
Statutory duty of care
What Does the fiduciary nature of the PR rule prevent the PRs from doing
No conflict rule - a PR may not purchase an asset from the estate even if this is for a fair value
No profit rule - can not Profit from their position. Payment for services will not constitute a breach of the ‘no profit’ rule if a PR acts in a professional capacity or the payments are authorised under the will
What rules is the power to appropriate subject to
· A specific beneficiary must not be prejudiced.
· Consent of recipient beneficiary is required.
· The value of the asset must be considered at the date of transfer/appropriation rather than the date of death.
If the value of an asset exceeds the beneficiary’s entitlement the PRs may not appropriate.
If the value of the asset is less than the entitlement the PRs may appropriate and then make a balancing cash transfer.
It is common for a will to include an express clause removing the need to obtain the consents required by the section.
Are PRs authorised to pay the insurance premiums (under power to insure) out of either estate income or capital
Yes
If PRs retain assets for a period of time do they have a duty to preserve the estate and actively invest
Yes
What does a lay PR, or a a professional PR who is acting alone, need to to be able to charge for their service
Needs to be given express power in the will
Can PRs be reimbursed for expenses
Yes - All PRs (whether or not they are acting in a professional capacity) may reimburse themselves for expenses properly incurred when acting on behalf of an estate. For example, travel costs incurred in the course of carrying out estate administration.
If delegation is required what is needed?
If delegation is required, the PRs must:
· do so in writing to the agent and
· provide them with a written policy statement which the agent must agree to comply with (s15).
The use of an agent and the terms of the policy document need to be kept under review (s22).
It is common to delegate investment powers and law firms often have links with financial advisers to whom they refer work.
If there is an express clause in a will which permits PRs to accept receipt from a minor beneficiary aged 16 or older is it effective?
Yes
Can a joint PR act alone
If more than one PR is appointed then, similarly to trustees, they are required to make decisions together and should exercise discretionary powers unanimously
Where statutory PR powers and express provisions in a will conflicts what takes priority
The express provisions in the will
What can a claim against a PR be based on
Maladministration
Misuse of assets
Negligence
Breach of fiduciary duty
What does maladministration include
Incorrectly administering the estate by making distributions to the wrong beneficiaries
Using the residuary estate to meet liabilities which should have been paid from other parts of the estate
Paying legacies before debts without retaining sufficient funds for creditors
What does misuse of assets include
Making personal use of the estate assets
What could negligence include in relation to breach of PR duties
Unreasonable delay in carrying out the administration
Failing to invest or making poor investment decisions in breach of the duty of care
What could a Breach of fiduciary duty include:
Breach of the no conflict rule
Breach of the no profit rule
Self-dealing
Can a PR who fails to carry out their duties properly be removed
Yes - a PR who fails to carry out their duties properly may be effectively removed from the role by:
A court order under s 50 Administration of Justice Act 1950 appointing a replacement
PR
An administration action, where the court would take over the administration itself
What can the PRs seek guidance on the court about in order to avoid personal liability
Administration proceedings could take the form of:
an administration action application to have the estate administered by the court.
specific relief, an application for quidance on a particular matter
What is an application under s 48 Administration of Justice Act 1985
An application to distribute in accordance with a written legal opinion - avoid personal liability
How can PRs prevent liability to unknown/ unidentified beneficiaries and creditors
S27 Trustee Act 1925 - Publish a notice of their intention to distribute to known beneficiaries two months after the date of the advertisement.
The notice must be placed in:
The London Gazette,
A newspaper circulating in the area in which any land held on trust is situated, and
Any other newspaper which iS appropriate e.g. if the deceased owned a business, the relevant trade paper may be appropriate
Section 27 only protects against claims by unknown beneficiaries and creditors.
Does s27 trustee act 1925 protect PRs against liability if they distribute assets ignoring the claim of a known but missing beneficiary or creditor
No
What is a Benjamin order
In the case of known but missing beneficiaries PRs may seek a Benjamin Order permitting them to distribute the estate on the basis that the missing beneficiaries have died.
The common assumption which allows PRs to distribute the estate under the Benjamin order is that the beneficiary has died, can any other assumptions be made
Yes e..g the assumption that the missing beneficiary had no children
What must be done before a Benjamin order is awarded
Before an order is awarded the PRs must make full enquiries to attemptto establish the true position (Re Benjamin 1902) and demonstrate there is no reasonable prospect of knowing the true position without disproportionate expense.
What is a quicker and easier way to confirm the presumption of death than requesting a Benjamin order if all criteria is met
Application under the Presumption of death act 2013
Why may an indemnity from beneficiary’s not be a preferred option from PRs to protect against personal liability
An indemnity from the existing beneficiaries is only as good as the person giving it. Also, it may prove difficult in the future to trace those providing the indemnity. As such this may not be a preferred option for the PRs
When may a payment into court be appropriate to avoid pr personal liability
a payment into court may be suitable where a beneficiary can be located but is refusing to accept their inheritance
An order for exoneration by the court will not be made unless ?
the court considers that the PR:
- acted honestly and reasonably,
- ought fairly to be excused for:
the breach of trust and
omitting to obtain directions of the court in the matter
[S.61 refers to trustees, which includes a PR for these purposes]
Can clauses in a will exclude or restrict liability fro PRs wrongdoing
Yes - These clauses may cover a range of scenarios from innocent mistake to
gross negligence and may offer different levels of protection to lay and professional PRs.
Can PRs liability for fraud be excluded by will
No
Where should money collected in be paid Into
• a PR’s bank account (opened specifically to hold estate money and to prevent this being mixed with their personal funds), or
• law firm client account.
Solicitors’ Accounts rules apply to money held in the firm’s client account and the firm must provide credit interest of a “fair and reasonable” sum.
PRs have a duty to pay debts with due diligence what does this mean
this is not defined but creditors should normally be paid before the end of the ‘executor’s year’.
PRs should also pay general administration expenses as and when they arise during the administration - what are examples of expenses
For example:
• Cost of valuing the estate assets
• Probate fees
• S.27 notice costs
Professional legal fees for services provided to the estate
When is an estate solvent
if the assets are sufficient to pay all the funeral, testamentary and administration expenses, debts and liabilities
It is immaterial whether legacies can be paid in full or not.