AC1 & 4 Flashcards
explain, with examples, what is meant by the term ‘decriminalisation’ (4)
- a process in which we may see society refusing to accept an action is criminal
- a reduction in punishment is often seen
- police may become reluctant to enforce punishment
- the act often becomes legalised
- laws are frequently amended because the values in society are constantly changing
- this means that eventually the government have little choice but to decriminalise and accept the act as it can no longer be controlled as people no longer take notice of the law
examples:
- homosexuality was once a criminal offence but it no longer is
- police do not act on cannabis as much anymore
- underage sex and drinking is not taking seriously
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (smoking cannabis)
- illegal in England and Wales but there have been calls to decriminalise it and allow its use particularly for medical reasons
- it is legal in some states in America
- within the UK the law is enforced differently, for instance, Durham Constabulary does not prioritise people who grow cannabis plant for personal use, unlike Cheshire.
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (homosexuality)
- used to be a criminal offence in England and Wales, this then changed in 1967 due to the Sexual Offences Act
- the age of consent has been lowered from 21 to 16, so same as heterosexuals now
- Marriage Act (2013) include the right to have a same sex marriage/civil partnership
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (vagrancy/homelessness)
- still illegal under the Vagrancy Act (1824)
- this act was originally passed to clear the streets of beggars and vagabonds and to prevent further crime from being committed.
- this act has been disregarded by society as they have accepted that there are legitimate reasons for homelessness.
- however, there has been an increase in prosecutions in the last few years.
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (time, place, culture)
time: views and opinions can change over time or campaigns can promote change and change can occur due to medical knowledge advances.
place: the same criminal offences are not necessarily in place throughout the world or even policies in the same way within England and Wales (find example in textbook)
culture: different cultures view crimes differently even at the same point in time.
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (adultery)
- not illegal in England, Wales or South Korea
- in South Korea the state refuses to become involved in an individual’s private relationships
- however, in certain states in the US, Florida and Arizona, adultery is punishable by imprisonment.
with reference to examples, analyse how laws change due to time, place and culture (honour killings)
- in some cultures this is seen as the appropriate way for a family to deal with family or community dishonour.
- this is predominantly prevalent in Muslim nations such as Turkey, Jordan, Pakistan and Morocco.
- it is viewed as murder in more western countries.
compare criminality and deviance with reference to relevant examples (6)
- crime is a behaviour that breaks the formal laws of society, criminal behaviour can lead to formal sanctions and punishment.
- examples of criminal behaviour are murder and theft
- deviance is any behaviour that goes against society’s norms and expected behaviour, for example having an excessive amount of tattoos or wearing dark make up and clothes.
- most crimes are seen as deviant, but all deviant acts are not criminal, for example owning a large number of cats.
- some deviant acts can become the norm, for example, illegal streaming of certain movies
- certain acts that were once desirable may become deviant over time, for example smoking.
explain, with examples, what is meant by the term criminal behaviour. (6)
- social definition = criminal behaviour is against the rules that a society uses to decide what is and isn’t criminal.
- legal definition = a criminal act requires an actus reus and mens rea, actus reus is the action itself and the mens rea is having a guilty intention
- some criminal behaviour can also be described as deviant, but this is not always the case.
- e.g. murder and theft are both criminal and deviant
- the criminality of some acts is different depending on the context, for example, smoking itself is not criminal however, smoking in cars with under 18s is illegal
- an informal sanction against crime is a caution which is a warning, a person must agree to be cautioned
- a formal sanction against crime is a community sentence which can include unpaid work.
explain how social changes affect policy development (smoking)
- society has changed its views and policies regarding the smoking of cigarettes.
- previously seen as socially acceptable
- from being perceived as a glamourous activity in the mid-20th century, smoking is now illegal in enclosed public places following the Health Act (2006).
assess the use of biological theories in informing policy development (eugenics)
- this involves the claim that inheritance can explain the presence of human behavioural characteristics including criminality.
- examples of the use of eugenics include Nazi Germany, where sterilisation of people with undesirable traits was promoted.
- sterilisation laws would prevent incarcerated criminals from giving birth to “criminal” offspring.
- research suggest that criminal fathers are more likely to have criminal children than non-criminal fathers (Osborn and West)
- criminal traits were believed to be inheritable
assess the use of biological theories in informing policy development (death penalty)
- this involves ending a life by state execution.
- death by hanging was legal in England and Wales for the crime of murder until the temporary abolition in 1965. As the murder rate did not soar it was permanently abolished for murder in 1969.
- the policy is operative in some states of the US, for example Texas.
- however, statistics suggest that it is not a deterrent to the crime of murder.
- midazolam is drug used to execute, it does not result in a quick death, it is slow and tortuous
assess the use of biological theories in informing policy development (neurochemical - influencing brain chemistry with the use of diet)
- the use of diet to positively affect aggressive behaviour, which in turn may result in less crime.
- lower than average serotonin levels were found in violent offenders (Vikkunen et al., 1987). hence a serotonin-enriched diet with food such as tuna and salmon may reduce crime.
- research has shown that a reduced-sugar diet reduced anti-social behaviour (Schoenthaler, 1982).
- research by Gesch et al., 2002, involving the taking of vitamins pills by young, male prisoners, showed a reduction in disciplinary incidents.
assess the use of biological theories in informing policy development (brain surgery - lobotomy)
assess the use of individualistic theories in informing policy development (behaviour modification - token economy)
- in prisons, this policy aims to extinguish undesirable behaviours and promote desirable ones.
- the underpinning principle is that behaviours that are reinforced are strengthened whereas behaviours that are punished are weakened
- a token economy system is an example of this, where a token is given for a desired action that is later exchanged for a “treat”. in the short term, this is often successful while the offender remains in prison
assess the use of individualistic theories in informing policy development (psychoanalysis)
- this treatment allows the patient to verbalise their thoughts through a variety of methods, aiming to access unconscious, repressed thoughts that are believed to have led to criminal activity
- the therapist is essential to the treatment as they aim to help the offender turn to law-abiding thoughts; however, there have been criticisms that the therapist may unduly influence the patient
assess the use of sociological theories in informing policy development (penal populism)
- this is where a government attempts to propose new laws to punish offenders.
- it is hoped that such policies are popular with the public and will elicit public support.
- sometimes, the harsh policies may be out of proportion to the criminal offence.
- comments may include the idea of being “Tough on crime; tough on the causes of crime” (the pledge of former prime minister, Tony Blair, to reduce crime)