9. Mortgages Flashcards
why are the courts and parliament prepared to intervene in the mortgagor-mortgagee relationship and declare terms void?
inequality of bargaining power between borrowers and lenders
particularly in the resi context where a borrower needs to borrow money to buy a home
fundamental legal principle re: mortgages
a mortgage should be security for a loan only, and not an opportunity for the lender to gain something more than the security (the equity of redemption)
rights of the borrower = equity of redemption:
- equitable right to redeem
- no postponement or prevention of redemption
- no collateral advantages
- no unconscionable terms
what is the equitable right to redeem?
a borrower now has an equitable right to repay (redeem) their mortgage any time the legal date of redemption has passed
in a resi context, when does the legal right of redemption arise?
usually within the first 6 months of the mortgage term
how are clauses which postpone redemption treated by the courts?
may be declared void (since it prevents the equitable right to redeem from being able to arise)
how are clauses which prevent redemption treated?
will be void
How must a legal mortgage be made?
Deed + registration
Does a mortgage trigger compulsory first registration?
Yes, if the land is unregistered
Can a mortgage be recognised even if it does not comply with deed + registration?
Yes, it will be recognised as an equitable mortgage, but it must at least comply with s2 LP(MP)A 1989:
1. In writing;
2. Contains all terms; and
3. Signed by both parties
What are the two ways a mortgagor can create a legal charge?
- Executing a deed declaring the mortgagor is charging the land for sums to be repaid
- Charging a registered estate (no need for express declaration)
What are the three situations in which an equitable mortgage can be created?
- Parties agree that mortgage should only be equitable
- Contract in writing to create a legal mortgage, and there is no deed or the deed fails
- Mortgagor owns equitable interest only
A contract to create a legal mortgage gives rise to an equitable mortgage from what time?
Date of the contract
What is the effect of an unsuccessful attempt to create a legal mortgage?
It takes effect in equity
Does an equitable mortgage need to be by deed?
No, but it must be in writing and signed by mortgagor or their agent + mortgagee
In the registered system, what are the two factors to be considered in determining how a mortgage should be protected?
Whether mortgage:
1. Is legal or equitable; and
2. Was created before or after the Land Registration Act 2002
How is a legal mortgage over registered land protected?
It must be registered if the mortgagee wants to exercise power of sale.
Once registered, it has priority over competing interests, unless those are previously registered, or overriding.
How is an equitable mortgage over registered land protected?
Placing a notice or restriction on the property’s register of title
In the context of mortgages, who has priority in the unregistered system, and why?
The first mortgagee, because they will have custody of the title deeds
How does one protect a subsequent legal mortgage over unregistered land, when they do not have the title deeds?
Register a class C(i) puisne mortgage land charge