9) Concurrent Flashcards
remedies when concurrent ownership goes bad (or at severence)
partition accounting
abandonment
opposite of ouster–you DN owe rent to someone who isn’t living there bc they abandoned
income from SP
–remains in SP –exception: husband spends all his time manging his SP stock portfolio…profits become CP bc of the effort he spent on it during the marriage
JT: leases, mortgages, and severance…
W: leases and mortgages DO NOT sever JTs (so when person who leased it to you dies you lose your share, survivorship was intact)
Homestead laws
in most states protect interests of survivng spouse/children from claims of credtiors, ko like life estate
concurrent owners; expenses/burdens, how, and which? (4)
share by fractional division: mortgage, property taxes, insurance, maintenance and necessary repairs No duty to share costs of UNNECESSARY IMPROVEMENTS unless you agree
separate property states – on divorce (inc 4 factors)
equitable distribution based on economic need, status, rehabilitation, sometimes fault
Joint tenancy: survivorship etc
Survivorship: YES u. transfer: YES u. termination: YES u. encumbrance: YES *BUT can’t encumber co-Ts interest on survivorship
Carr v. Deking
F: P owner was TIC with dad who executed lease w D lessee w/o P’s knowledge or consent H: TICs can use, benefit from, posess entire property so ok to lease your interest. Remedy is partition
Tenhet v. Boswell
F: P had joint tenant who leased his share to D and then died. H: lease made by joint-T can’t survive joint T’s death bc that would destroy co-joint-T’s right of survivorship (so it was mroe like a life esatte PAV)
concurrent ownership expenses and burdens – EXCEPTION
No duty to share costs of UNNECESSARY IMPROVEMENTS unless you agree
Joint tenancy: requirements to create
TTIP: unity of: Time (all created at same time, like privity) Title (all created at same time) Interest (must have equal fractional unidivided interest in property and they must all last same amt of time) Possession: all have right to possess entire parcel
joint tenancy; severance (3)
you can transfer your property interest and this ends the right to survivorship self-severance allowed note: if A, B, C, D each have 25% and A sells his share to B then it’s not that B now has 50% – he has 25% as JT and 25% as TIC
constructive ouster
sometimes divorce otherwise impossible to both live there (eg small cottage) physical abuse
divorce: business goodwill
can be dividied in may states enterprise good will (divisible–the kind that would still exist if you sold the business) vs personal good will (eg dentist): not devisible
tenancy in common: survivorship/etc
survivorship: no unilateral termination: yes unilateral encumberance: yes
ouster: rent? and why?
the situation where concurrent owners do have to pay each other rent – bc you took the other co-T’s right to possession
O’Brien v. O’Brien
F: P husband and D wife are divorcing after D spends 9 years working while P was in med school H: med license is subject to equitable distribution (NY statute ‘property of any form’)
divorce and professional licenses: minority rule
she invested and should get fair returns O’Brien v. O’Brien
AP and ouster?
hard to prove, each entitled to legally occupy the property would have to put on notice that you are asserting full ownerhsip rights over the other one
concurrent ownership, possession, and rent (3 scenarios)
normally no rent owed bc each has undivided right to possess the whole BUT if only one is living there and no rent, must pay all the expenses if value of occupation exceeds the payments DO PAY RENT IF OUTSTER