8 - fin crime Flashcards
Insider dealing
Criminal offence
CJA 1993
Intent + all reasonable doubt
7 years +/ unlim fine
Market abuse
Civil
UKMAR and FCA
Can prosecute intent
Only prove effect to balance of prob
unlim fine/restitution/loss of reg status
Misleading statements + impressions
FSA 2012
Criminal
intent + beyond reasonable doubt
7 years/ unlim fine
Insider dealing
What actions
what instruments
Covered where
dealing on, encouraging others to deal on, disclosure of
shares, DRs
warrants
debts
options, futures CFDs related to above
excluded:
assets w/out 2ndary market
commodities and commodity derivatives
spot and forward FX
insurance prods
covered:
traded on regulated market or via professional intermediary
not directly between 2 people
What is inside info (CJA 1993)
Relates to particular securities/issuers
Specific or precise
Has not been made public
Price sensitive
insider dealing defences (7)
General
No advantage expected
belief that the information had been widely disclosed
Would have dealt anyway
Did not expect the recipient to deal
Special
Stabilisation
Market information
Market makers in the ordinary course of business
Enforcement on insider dealing law
LSE market ops division monitors transaction in vicinity of price sensitive info announcement
FCA with powers from FSMA200
Laws on ID come from CJA 1993
max 7 years +/unlim fine
What are misleading statements + impressions
Punishment?
Misleading statements, e.g. lying to persuade someone to deal, concealing
relevant facts in takeover documents, etc.
Misleading impressions, e.g. abusive squeezes, market rigging
- both reckless and deliberate
Misleading statements in relation to benchmarks
Criminal, 7 years +/ unlim fine. FSA2012
Defences for misleading statements/impression
Punishment?
Reasonably believed that statement or act was not false or misleading
Acted in conformity with price stabilising rules or control of information rules
(Chinese walls) or share buy-back rules
criminal, 7 years+/unlim fine
2 layers of penalties for misleading statements/impressions
1 -summary conviction (magistrates court)= a fine not exceeding the
statutory amount or a jail sentence not exceeding 12 months, or both.
2 - conviction on indictment (crown court) = a jail sentence not exceeding 7
years or a fine, or both.
Market abuse offences + penalites
UKMAR
Offences:
Insider dealing (engage, attempt to engage, recommend or induce another to engage, disclose)
- Includes amending and cancelling orders
- A person shall not engage in or attempt to engage in market manipulation
civil - unlim fine, lighter burden of proof, can prosecute intention, + effect based (don’t need motive/intent)
MAR inside info definition
Not public
Relates, directly or indirectly, to one or more issuers or to one or more
financial instruments
would have signif effect of prices of financial instrument or related derivative if it were to be made public
UKMAR market manipulation
Entering into a transaction, placing an order to trade, or any other
behaviour which
- Gives false signals as to the supply, demand or price of a financial
instrument or related spot commodity contract
- Secures the price of a financial instrument or related spot
commodity contract at an abnormal or artificial level
- Employs a fictitious device or any other form of deception or
contrivance
* Disseminates information through the media, or internet, or any other
means which is likely to give false signals as to the supply, demand or
price of a financial instrument or related spot commodity contract
* Transmits false or misleading information in relation to a benchmark, or
any other behaviour manipulates the calculation of a benchmark
Scope of UKMAR vs criminal offences
Wider what : financial instruments (traded on a reg market, OTF and MTF) vs specific instruments
- includes emissions allowances
market manipulation - includes commodity derivatives and commodity spot markets
wider where: applies to instruments wherever abuse occurs vs reg market/professional intermediary
wider who: companies and individuals
lower burden of proof - effect based, balance of prob vs beyond reasonable doubt
FCA guidance on market abuse +sanctions
Insider dealing
Improper disclosure
Manipulating transactions
Manipulating devices
Dissemination
sanctions:
- Withdrawal of regulated status
- Financial penalties
- Public statements
- Applying to courts for injunctions and restitution
statutory exemptions from market abuse (safe harbours) - FCA
- Share buy-back programmes and stabilisation measures
- FCA Rules
- Takeover Code
- Market soundings
- Requires formalised process, including disclosures, notifications of confidentiality and record keeping
- country specific accepted market practices
FCA market abuse reporting
STORs - Suspicious transaction and order reports
- Reporting suspicions from transactions
- must report to the FCA without delay
- STORs should contain
- Identity of reporting person submitting STOR
- Description of the order or transaction
- Reasons for which market abuse is suspected of the order or transaction
- Means of identifying any person involved in the order or transaction
- Any other supporting documents needed by the FCA for investigation