7) Remedies Flashcards
remedies for breach of k (CL): kinds
1) damages
2) equitable
remedies for breach of k: damages: kinds
1) expectation damages
2) reliance d
3) restitutionary d
4) liquidated damages
remedies for breach of k (CL + UCC): damages: default rule
expectation damages! (always start here)
remedies for breach of k (CL): expectation damages: how to calculate
Loss of value of breaching party’s performance (k price?)
+ incidental and consequential costs generated by breach
- any payments received from breacher
- any costs saved bc of breach
remedies for breach of k (CL): expectation damages: exceptions
CAN’T get expectation damages if:
1) can’t calculate them w reasonable certainty
2) damages are unforeseeable (Hadley)
3) damages could be mitigated (can’t recover for those that should’ve mitigated)
remedies for breach of k (CL): expectation damages: exception: Hadley rule
damages that are not foreseeable are not recoverable
remedies for breach of k (CL): expectation damages: exception: mitigation: employees
don't need to accept substitute work if: different field significantly lower pay/worse terms more burdensome responsibilities damage career prospects
remedies for breach of k (CL): expectation damages: def
restore aggrieved party to the position he would’ve been in if k had been fully performed (what he expected)
remedies for breach of k (CL): reliance damages: def
restore aggrieved party to position he was in PRIOR TO K’ing
remedies for breach of k (CL): reliance damages: how to calculate
any expenses made to anyone in performing or preparing to perform
- any loss that breaching party can prove aggrieved party would have suffered even if the k HAD been fully performed
remedies for breach of k (CL): reliance damages: when available
if expectation damages not available
remedies for breach of k (CL): which applies?
argue for whichever is more $$ for my client! but generally expectation is default
remedies for breach of k (CL): restitutionary damages: def
the value of benefits conferred ON THE OTHER PARTY in the transaction
remedies for breach of k (CL): restitutionary damages: how to calculate
2 ways:
1) reasonable value or cost of benefits conferred (to the other party only, per def) OR
2) extent to which other party’s property has increased in value bc of performance
court will consider equities to decide which
remedies for breach of k (CL): restitutionary damages: when to use
argue for it if it’s more $ for client. Most common time that will happen: “losing k”
remedies for breach of k (CL): restitutionary damages: exception
restitutionary damages NOT available if other party has fully performed!! (only if partial)
remedies for breach of k (CL): liquidated damages: def
k specifies amount of damages in the event of breach
remedies for breach of k (CL): liquidated damages: test
courts will not enforce if think it’s a penalty designed to punish breach. (compensation only, not punishment) Consider:
1) forecast
2) hindsight
remedies for breach of k (CL): liquidated damages: test: forecast
was clause reasonable at the time of k, in relation to the anticipated harm? (more likely to be enforced if there was an anticipated harm that would be difficult to calculate)
remedies for breach of k (CL): liquidated damages: hindsight
was clause reasonable in relation to harm and losses that actually occurred due to the breach?
remedies for breach of k (CL): liquidated damages: result if court finds unenforceable
strikes from the k, follow default rules instead
remedies for breach of k (UCC): seller remedies: when use
if buyer breaches
remedies for breach of k (UCC): seller remedies: rule
depends on if goods were delivered and accepted by buyer
remedies for breach of k (UCC): seller remedies: buyer accepted goods
remedy = k price
remedies for breach of k (UCC): seller remedies: buyer DID NOT accept: situations
buyer wrongfully rejected or repudiated
remedies for breach of k (UCC): seller remedies: buyer DID NOT accept: rule
1) if seller has re-sold: damages = difference btwn k price and resale price
2) if seller has not re-sold: damages = difference btwn k price and market price
3) lost volume sellers: damages = the profit would have made on lost sale
remedies for breach of k (UCC): lost volume seller: def
supply of goods exceeds the demand (ex. tv store)
remedies for breach of k (UCC): buyer remedies: when use
if seller breached (didn’t send, or sends imperfect and never curse)