7. Insolvency in Companies Flashcards
When is a company deemed insolvent?
- Debt exceeding £750 and a written demand in the proper form has been served, and debt remains unpaid for 3 weeks
- Creditor has obtained judgement against the company and has tried to enforce the judgement
- Cash flow test
- Balance sheet test
ALSO can just prove to court’s satisfaction that company is unable to pay their debts
In proving a company is unable to pay it’s debts, is it required to serve a statutory demand?
No, although it is recommended
What is the balance sheet test?
Where the company has liabilities which exceed its assets then it fails the balance sheet test - i.e. Net Assets
Net Assets = Fixed Assets PLUS Current Assets LESS Long Term Liabilities LESS Current Liabilities
Why is the cash flow test hard to prove from the balance sheet?
A balance sheet is only a snapshot of accounts therefore not possible to fully understand company’s accounts
What are the three types of liquidation?
- Compulsory liquidation
- Creditors’ voluntary liquidation (CVL)
- Members’ voluntary liquidation (MVL)
When is an MVL available and when are they commonly used?
Only if company is solvent
Commonly used if companies are dormant
When is CVL used?
When a company becomes insolvent and is unable to sustain its operations due to financial obligations
What is the role of directors in a CVL?
Director remains in office, but liquidator takes over the running of the company from the director
What key potential claims can a liquidator / administrator bring in order to increase assets available to creditors?
o Avoidance of certain floating charges
o Preferences
o Transactions at an undervalue
o Transactions defrauding creditors
o Extortionate credit transactions
When is a floating charge invalid?
When a charge is granted without the company receiving fresh consideration in exchange for granting security, within the relevant time
What is the relevant time period for an invalid floating charge granted to a non-connected person?
12 months prior to onset of insolvency
What else is required in order to make a floating charge invalid, if granted without fresh security to a person non-connected to the company, within the relevant time?
Company must have been insolvent at the time the floating charge was given or insolvent as a result
What is the relevant time period for an invalid floating charge granted to a person connected to the company?
2 years prior to onset of insolvency
Is it necessary for a company to have been insolvent at the time of / insolvent because of a floating charge granted to a person connected to the company without fresh consideration, within the relevant time period?
No
What constitutes a person “connected” to the company?
Director / shadow director
Someone who is a close relative / business associate of a director / shadow director
Associate of the company
In a CVL, when is the formal onset of insolvency?
Date company formally enters into liquidation
In compulsory liquidation, when is the formal onset of insolvency?
When company files notice of intention to appoint an administrator
What is a preference?
Where the company puts the other person in a better position in the event of liquidation / administration
What is the relevant time, if a preference is given to a person who is connected with the company?
2 years ending with onset of insolvency
What is the relevant time, if a preference is given to a person who is not connected with the company?
6 months ending with onset of insolvency
Must the company have been insolvent as the time of / as a result of the preference?
Yes
What is the rule highlighted in MC Bacon regarding preferences?
Must desire to prefer the other party - i.e. not give the preference in order to survive rather than due to a desire to give that creditor preference
What is the rebuttable presumption if a company prefers a connected person?
Presumption that they did have the desire to prefer that person - i.e. company intended to put the connected person in a better position on insolvency than otherwise would have been the case
What is a transaction at an undervalue?
When a company makes a gift to the other person, or enters into a transaction and receives consideration which is significantly lower in value than the consideration provided by the company for the asset
What is the relevant time regarding transactions at an undervalue?
2 years ending with onset of insolvency
For both connected and non-connected persons
What is the rebuttable presumption if a company makes a transaction at an undervalue with a connected person?
Presumption of the company’s insolvency / inability to pay its debts at the time of the transaction
What defence is available for transactions at an undervalue?
That the transaction was entered into in good faith, for the purpose of carrying on the business
What is the relevant time in which an extortionate credit transaction can be challenged?
Transaction made in the 3 years ending with insolvency
Is there a time limit in which transactions defrauding creditors must have been made in order for a liquidator / administrator to bring a claim against it?
No
What is the order for payment of debts during liquidation?
- Secured debts
- Liquidator’s fees
- Preferential debts
- Money subject to floating charges (in order of priority)
- Unsecured creditors
- Remainder to shareholders