6: What is knowledge? Flashcards
What is the definition of Epistemology?
The study of nature, origin and extent of human knowledge
What are the two types of knowledge?
- Performative Knowledge
- Propositional Knowledge
What are some characteristics of Performative Knowledge?
- It means that you know how to do things
- We are born with certain innate performative knowledge (to eat, etc.)
- Questions about truth DO NOT arise in performative knowledge
What are some characteristics of propositional knowledge?
- It means that you know that certain things…
- There are different takes on whether or not there is innate propositional knowledge
- Questions about truth DO arise in propositional knowledge
What are the two types of propositional knowledge?
- A priori knowledge
- Not justified by experience, but by reason alone
- A posteriori knowledge
- Justified by experience
What is the traditional analysis of propositional knowledge?
S knows that P if and only if,
- S believes that P
- S is justified in believing that P, and
- P is true
There are three conditions: belief, justification and truth.
What is the belief condition?
- Is it possible to know something that something that you do NOT believe?
- No.
- What is belief?
- S believes that P if and only if S thinks that P true
- Belief IS a necessary condition for knowledge.
What is the justification condition?
- Justification = sufficient (good enough) reasons
- Personal experience
- Expert testimony
- Authority
- Textbooks
- Accepted history, theories, facts
- Justification IS a necessary condition for knowledge.
What are the three conceptions of truth?
- Subjectivist (me)
- The specific individual
1. What true for me is for me, and you you
- The specific individual
- Relativist (we)
- Relativise to a particular society or group
- Objectivist (the)
- There is some fact to the matter that allows us to settle
Who was Bertrand Russell?
- Longest lived philosophy
- British
- Cambridge University
- Prolific writer
- Pacifist
What did Bertrand Russell thought about truth?
- How is knowledge of truth and knowledge of things different?
- We can’t be wrong about how things seems to us
- We can be wrong about how things are
- Truth bearers & Truth-bearing
- Belief + Statements
- No one’s ever seen a belief or a statement
- These are truth-bearers.
- What are the kinds of things that are bearers of truth?
- Declarative sentence; meaning
- In the absence of belief and statements, truth will not exist in the world.
- Truth is a property of beliefs and statements
- Belief + Statements
What are the three requisites for a theory of truth?
- “Our theory of truth must be such as to admit of its opposite, falsehood”
- Truth and falsehood need to be based on belief and statements
- It depends upon something which lies outside the belief
What are some theories of truth?
- Coherence Theory
- Correspondence Theory
In what consists the Coherence Theory of truth?
- “A belief is true when it coheres with the body of our others beliefs”
What is the difficulty of the Coherence Theory of truth?
- There’s no reason to suppose there’s only one body of beliefs
- The coherence theory presupposes the law of non-contradiction
- “A statement cannot be both true and false at the same time”
- Coherence = consistency ≠ truth, therefore coherence ≠ truth
In what consists the Correspondence Theory of truth?
- The thing you need to look at outside, is the world = the fact
What is a fact?
- An associated complex of some state of affairs in the world
- It is NOT the statement expressing the state of affairs, it IS the state of affairs
- Correspondence with fact as constituting the nature of truth.