5. Overview of Study Designs and Experimental Study Designs Flashcards
What are the 6 differences in how study designs differ?
- Number of observations made
- Directionality of exposure
- Data collection methods
- Timing of data collection
- Unit of observation
- Availability of subjects
What is an experimental design study approach?
Manipulation of the study factor - if the exposure of interest was controlled by the investigator
What are the 2 types of design study?
Experimental and Observational
What is an observational design study approach?
Randomization of study subjects - if there was use of random processes to determine exposure of study subjects
What does controlled assignment mean related to in study designs?
Experimental studies/manipulated
What does uncontrolled assignment mean related to study design?
Observational studies
Is a cohort study prospective or retrospective?
Prospective
Is a case control study prospective or retrospective?
Retrospective
Associations between exposure and disease status
slide 10
What does the specific interpretation of results from a 2x2 study depend upon?
the design of the study
How cases status and exposure status were ascertained
Whether cases are incident or prevalent
What are true experimental studies?
They are most convincing for conferring evidence of associations between risk factors and outcomes
for manipulation of study factors and randomization of subjects
What is an example of a true experimental study?
randomized clinical trials
What are the two main types of experimental studies?
- Randomized clinical trials
2. Quasi-experimental studies
What do randomized clinical trials mostly focus on?
individuals
What do Quasi-experimental studies mostly focus on?
on the group or community
What gives the strongest evidence for causality?
Study Designs
specifically with internal validity = experimental studies
What is the strength of the evidence usually referred to as?
internal validity
Will clinical trials generally be representative of a population?
not generally
What does randomization create?
It creates comparable groups by equally distributing known and unknown factors (e.g., confounders) that could otherwise bias results
What is performed after informed consent?
randomization
What are the 3 types of randomization?
- Simple
- Restricted
- Stratified
What does randomization increase?
increases internal validity
What is internal validity?
The ability to make causal inferences from the study results
What is external validity?
The ability to generalize the results to a greater population
What does RCT stand for?
Random Clinical Trial
How do large RCT’s relate to internal or external validity?
large RCT’s generally have good internal validity but poor external validity
What gets to the tension between epi as an science and an applied field of research?
internal vs. external validity
In an external validity RCT when would you compare the study population? and why?
in the latter stages because there is not enough information in the early stages to assess differences in participants vs. non-participants