4th Amendment Flashcards
What are the Rights Protected Under 4th Amendment?
(1) Secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects
(2) UNREASONABLE searches and seizures
(3) Warrants with oath, description of person, place, or thing
What standard is required for a search AND seizure/arrest?
Probable Cause
What standard is required for a stop?
Reasonable Suspicion
When is a person seized?
Mendenhall and Hodari - when they are taken by physical force or a show of authority their movement is restrained (i.e. grabbed, pushed, threatened, etc) or they submit to authority
What is a 4th Amendment search?
Physical trespass on one’s home or property or person or paper (Olmstead, Katz, Jones) OR invasion of reasonable expectation of privacy
What is the reasonable expectation of privacy standard?
actual, subjective expectation that society is prepared to recognize as objectively reasonable
What is an example of physical trespass?
Katz - bugging a public phone booth
Jones - putting a GPS tracking device on someone’s car and monitoring for 2 weeks
Carpenter - obtaining cell service location information from phone company for all time (monitors non-suspects too)
Kyllo - using a thermal imager to detect heat in defendant’s house
Almonor - pinging a cellphone
Jardines - dog sniffs on curtilage
What is curtilage?
Hester 4-factor test:
(1) proximity to front door
(2) enclosure
(3) use of the area for intimate activity
(4) other steps taken to protect area of passerby people
What is NOT a search?
Dunn and Oliver - entering open field/non-curtilage
Ciraolo, Dow Chemical, and Florida v. Riley - aerial surveillance on non-curtilage/open field
Greenwood - garbage
Place - dog sniff outside car
What is third party doctrine?
If the thing being searched is owned by a third party who consents to the search, and then gives it up to the police, then the person does not have a REP or standing to sue for 4th A violation and the search is legal.
What is the mosaic theory?
Moore-Bush - individual inquiries, each of which are not a search taken alone, may constitute a search when aggregated (e.g. long term instances of surveillance from a pole)
When should a reasonable person believe they are allowed to leave?
Bostick and Mendenhall - Mere police questioning (e.g. can I see your ID? Can I check your bag? Can you follow me?)
Bostick and Whren - temporary detention on a bus or a car
What are the requirements for a warrant?
(1) Issued by neutral and detached magistrate (Coolidge) capable of determining probable cause (Shadwick)
(2) Affidavit or oath supporting request
(3) Time period for execution (any time from 6 am to 10 pm for federal warrants)
(4) Must detail with specificity what is to be searched or seized (Andresen and Groh)
(5) Probable cause
What is the knock and announce requirement?
Absent exigent circumstances, the police must knock and announce their presence before entering a residence to execute a search warrant (Wilson, Richards)
What are the exceptions to the warrant requirement?
Exigent circumstances: preventing destruction of evidence and protecting people from physical harm
Probable cause: seeing crime in real time or plain view