4. Crimes Against The Property Flashcards
What are Theft Crimes?
Theft crimes involve the taking of property from the victim by the defendant.
What factors distinguish theft crimes?
Factors include:
* Nature of the taking
* Whether the defendant acquired custody, possession, or title to the property.
What are two ways that property can be taken?
Property can be taken:
* By trespass, force, or threat
* By fraud, deception, or misrepresentation.
When does a person have custody of property?
A person has custody of property when it has been left with them, but they have no rights over it.
When does a person have possession of property?
A person has possession if they:
* Have custody
* Have authority to exercise discretion
* Have limited rights to use it
* Have borrowed it.
When does a person have title to property?
A person has title to property when they are the legal owner.
What is Larceny?
i.) unlawful taking and carrying away (the slightest movement is sufficient);
ii.) without consent; and
iii.) with intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property(the specific intent to dispossess must exist during the taking).
What constitutes the Actus Reus of Larceny?
The unlawful taking and carrying away of property possessed by another.
Is ownership necessary for larceny?
No, the victim need only have possession, control, and custody of the property.
Can a lawful owner commit larceny?
Yes, if the victim had a greater right to the property at the time of taking.
How can a bailee commit larceny?
A bailee has lawful possession of bailed property, but only has custody of items inside a closed container, as the bailor retains constructive possession of these items.
Are services and intangible property subject to larceny?
Yes, they are subject to larceny.
Can lost or mislaid property be subject to larceny?
In order to be guilty of larceny for lost or mislaid property, the finder MUST:
i.) intend to permanently deprive the owner of it; and
ii.) either know who the owner is or have reason to believe (from earmarkings on the property or from the circumstances of the finding) that she can find out the owner’s identity.
Can abandoned property be subject to larceny?
No, abandoned property cannot be subject to larceny.
What is the Mens Rea of Larceny?
The intent to permanently deprive the owner must accompany the taking.
Must carrying away and intent to permanently deprive occur simultaneously for Larceny?
Yes, they must generally occur at the same time.
The intent to permanently deprive property is met if the defendant:
- plans to keep, destroy, or ransom it;
- handles it recklessly risking loss; or
- uses it temporarily then abandons it, even if it eventually returns to the owner.
There is no intent to permanently deprive property if the defendant:
- plans to unconditionally return it promptly;
- pawns it intending to redeem and return it;
- takes it intending to pay or replace it if not unique; or
- mistakenly but genuinely believes they have a right to it.
What does the Doctrine of Continuing Trespass state?
when one takes property with the intent to return it, but later keeps it, larceny arises at the moment the defendant decides not to return the property.
Does a taking with permission from owner satisfy the continuing trespass doctrine?
No. A taking with permission from the owner will NOT satisfy the continuing trespass doctrine if the taker then decides not to return the property at a later date.
What is Robbery?
Robbery occurs when a person commits a larceny and:
(1) the property unlawfully taken was on the victim’s person or in the victim’s presence; and
(2) the taking was accomplished by force or intimidation
What does ‘Presence’ mean in the context of Robbery?
‘Presence’ refers to the area within the victim’s protection or control.
Property is in a person’s presence for purposes of robbery if:
i.) it is within the area within which the victim could reasonably be expected to exercise some physical control;
ii.) but for the fact that the victim was overcome by force;
iii.) or prevented by the fear or intimidation.
What is Robbery by Force?
The force or violence can be slight, but MUST be MORE than what is necessary to simply move the property.
For a sudden “snatching” of property to constitute robbery, it must be accompanied by:
i.) more force or violence than is necessary to remove the property from the person;
ii.) accompanied by a simultaneous act of intimidation or violence.
What is Robbery by Intimidation?
The threat of violence MUST:
i.) place the victim in actual fear; and
ii.) this fear must also exist during the taking.
Can an empty threat suffice for Robbery by Intimidation?
Yes. Even an empty threat that produces actual fear during the taking is sufficient.
The Model Penal Code definition of robbery requires that the theft be accompanied by:
- serious bodily injury upon another; or
- by threatening or placing another in fear of immediate serious bodily injury.
What is required for ‘Accomplished by Force or Intimidation’ in robbery?
Violence or the threat of violence must occur contemporaneously with the taking.
What is Extortion?
Extortion occurs when a person threatens to harm another to obtain something of value.
Does Extortion require threats of immediate physical harm or taking property?
No. Extortion does NOT require threats of immediate or imminent physical harm, and property does NOT need to be taken from the victim’s person or presence.
What is Blackmail?
Blackmail involves threatening to expose information to obtain something of value.
What is Larceny by Trick?
Larceny by trick occurs when a defendant:
i.) gains possession (not ownership) of someone’s property;
ii.) with the owner’s consent;
iii.) by fraud or misrepresentation;
iv.) with the intent to permenantly deprive the owner of that property.
What is Embezzlement?
Embezzlement is the fraudulent conversion of property by someone in lawful possession.
What is required for Embezzlement?
The person must be in lawful possession of the property.
Can Employees Commit Embezzlement?
An employee has possession and thus could commit embezzlement if:
i.) a third party gives property directly to an employee for the benefit of the employee’s employer; or
ii.) the employee is in a high-level position (e.g., an office manager, bank president, or corporate official).