3.6 Government Intervention Flashcards
Why would gov. intervene when there’s monopoly power?
Monopoly power = higher prices and lower output compared to competitive conditions
Protects consumers
CMA?
UK gov. department responsible for promoting competition and preventing anti-competitive practices (e.g. collusion and predatory pricing)
Competition and Markets Authority
Surrogate competition?
When an industry has a high degree of market concentration, gov. regulates these industries to replicate competition (i.e. a need to maintain high quality)
e.g. OFCOM, FCA, ORR, OFGEM, OFWAT
Price regulation?
Used to regulate natural monopolies in the UK
Aim is to bring price closer to allocatively efficient P = MC
Esp. important for essentials e.g. utilities so they are affordable
What are the two forms of price regulation?
RPI - X
RPI + X
How does RPI - X work?
- X is expected efficiency gains
- Regulator investigates costs of firms in industry to find X
- RPI - X is the maximum price rise in the industry
- Lowers prices –> so incentivises increased efficiency
Disadvantages of RPI - X?
- Accurately setting X is difficult (requires time, information and a number of competent staff)
- If X too low = less incentive for efficiency gains
- If X too high = firms less likely to make profit = some will leave the market
Profit regulation?
Setting limits on the amount of profit a firm can make
e.g. rate of return regulation
Rate of return regulation?
Why?
Allows firms to cover costs and earn a return based on amount of capital they use
More capital = higher amount of profit earned
To incentivise investment = productivity gains = essential for utilities
Advantages of rate of return regulation?
Firms are incentivised to increase capital investment = important for maintenance and improving quality
Disadvantages of rate of return regulation?
Little pressure for firms to be productively efficient as costs guaranteed to be covered
Firms may overload on capital investment
Performance targets?
Used to regulate monopolies + incentivise improvements in public organisations e.g. schools, hospitals, police
Quality standards?
Minimum standards of service a regulator requires a monopolist/public body to meet
e.g. A&E given 4hrs to treat/discharge/admit/transfer a patient
Advantages of performance targets and quality standards?
Acts as a surrogate for competition
Disadvantages of performance targets and quality standards?
- Without sufficient sanctions = firms may be unmotivated to meet targets/standards
- Risk of gaming the system (e.g. surgeon avoiding difficult surgery to have high success rate)
- Unintended consequences - (e.g. police officer spending more time completing paperwork than protecting the public)
When would a CMA investigate a merger?
If EITHER conditions are met:
* Combined firm would have market share >25%
* Combined firm would have a turnover >£70m
What conditions are necessary for effective merger control?
- Competent regulators
- Accurate and up-to-date information
- Sufficient time to thoroughly investigate