3.6 Government Intervention Flashcards
LS16-18
Why would gov. intervene when there’s monopoly power?
- Monopoly power = higher prices and lower output compared to competitive conditions
- Protects consumers
CMA?
- UK gov. department responsible for promoting competition and preventing anti-competitive practices (e.g. collusion and predatory pricing)
Competition and Markets Authority
Surrogate competition?
- When an industry has a high degree of market concentration, gov. regulates these industries to replicate competition (i.e. a need to maintain high quality)
e.g. OFCOM, FCA, ORR, OFGEM, OFWAT
Price regulation?
- Used to regulate natural monopolies in the UK
- Aim is to bring price closer to allocatively efficient P = MC
Esp. important for essentials e.g. utilities so they are affordable
What are the two forms of price regulation?
- RPI - X
- RPI + X
How does RPI - X work?
- X is expected efficiency gains
- Regulator investigates costs of firms in industry to find X
- RPI - X is the maximum price rise in the industry
- Lowers prices –> so incentivises increased efficiency
Disadvantages of RPI - X?
- Accurately setting X is difficult (requires time, information and a number of competent staff)
- If X too low = less incentive for efficiency gains
- If X too high = firms less likely to make profit = some will leave the market
Profit regulation?
- Setting limits on the amount of profit a firm can make
e.g. rate of return regulation
Rate of return regulation?
Why?
- Allows firms to cover costs and earn a return based on amount of capital they use
- More capital = higher amount of profit earned
To incentivise investment = productivity gains = essential for utilities
Advantages of rate of return regulation?
- Firms are incentivised to increase capital investment = important for maintainance and improving quality
Disadvantages of rate of return regulation?
- Little pressure for firms to be productively efficient as costs guaranteed to be covered
- Firms may overload on capital invesrment
Performance targets?
- Used to regulate monopolies + incentivise improvements in public organisations e.g. schools, hospitals, police
Quality standards?
- Minimum standards of service a regulator requires a monopolist/public body to meet
e.g. A&E given 4hrs to treat/discharge/admit/transfer a patient
Advantages of performance targets and quality standards?
- Acts as a surrogate for competition
Disadvantages of performance targets and quality standards?
- Without sufficient sanctions = firms may be unmotivated to meet targets/standards
- Risk of gaming the system (e.g. surgeon avoiding difficult surgery to have high success rate)
- Unintended consequences - (e.g. police officer spending more time completing paperwork than protecting the public)
When would a CMA investigate a merger?
If EITHER conditions are met:
* Combined firm would have market share >25%
* Combined firm would have a turnover >£70m
What conditions are necessary for effective merger control?
- Competent regulators
- Accurate and up-to-date information
- Sufficienct time to thoroughly investigate