3.4 Market structures Flashcards
What are the four types of efficiencies?
- Allocative efficiency
- Productive/technical efficiency
- Dynamic efficiency
- X-inefficiency
What is allocative efficiency? Why does it occur where it does?
This is where production occurs at AR = MC.
If AR>MC: there is more welfare to be gained by producing more, as consumer welfare is greater than the cost of the additional good (under allocation)
If MC>AR: there is welfare loss, as the cost of producing another good is greater than any welfare consumers receive (over allocation) therefore there is WELFARE MAXIMISATION at AC=MR
What is productive efficiency?
- This is where AC = MC.
- Essentially the turning point of AC, so where costs are minimised for the firm.
- Most output for the lowest input.
What is dynamic efficiency?
- Long-run concept.
- If a firm has sufficient profits, it can use those to INVEST and therefore INNOVATE.
- This innovation reduces costs for consumers in the long term, and increases market share for the firm.
Why can dynamic efficiency be at odds with allocative efficiency?
If a firm makes little economic profit, it has little ability to invest and therefore reduce costs in the long-run.
What is X-inefficiency?
- This occurs when a lack of competitive pressures result in organisational failure in a firm.
- This is because of the principal-agent problem : managers and employees have different objectives to shareholders, e.g. long lunch breaks, ‘boondoggles’, office parties etc.
- It also may be caused by a lack of shareholder activism.
What is the concentration ratio?
- This is the number and size of firms in the market
- If a market has a high concentration ratio, it is not competitive
What determines market structure? [4]
- The number and size of firms in the industry
- The homogeneity of the good
- The level of information between firms and consumers
- Level of entry or exit barriers
What are the characteristics of a perfectly competitive market? [5]
- Lots of firms with small market share and no price setting powers
- Perfectly homogenous good
- Perfect information
- No entry or exit barriers
- Rational agents
Why are there two forms of equilibrium in perfect competition? (e.g. if there is an increase in demand or if the firms is already making supernormal profit)
- In the short run, the market price will rise following an increase in demand.
- Firms will now make a supernormal profit in the short-run, incentivising more firms to enter the market (as there are no entry barriers).
- This shifts supply outwards, driving price down until supernormal profit is eliminated and the market price returns to its long-run equilibrium.
Describe two connected diagrams that show how a long-run equilibrium eliminates supernormal profit in perfect competition
What does a long-run equilibrium perfect competition diagram look like?
How is allocative efficiency achieved in perfect competition?
- Assuming firms produce where profit is maximised:
- MC=MR and AR=MR, therefore AR=MC.
- Essentially, firms can only charge one price (the market price) for the good, so they will produce where the marginal cost is lowest.
How is productive efficiency achieved in perfect competition?
- Firms operate at AC=MR, as this is where their costs are minimised.
- As there can only be normal profit in perfect competition, MR=AR=AC.
- Therefore, AC=MC. As firms can only charge one price, profit max is where costs are minimised = productive efficiency.
How is X-inefficiency eliminated in perfect competition?
- If costs are higher than their lowest possible, firms will shut down.
- Organisational slack only forms from a lack of competitive pressures (not found in equilibrium)
How is dynamic efficiency affected by perfect competition?
- There is a high incentive to achieve dynamic efficiency, as firms want to gain a competitive edge.
- However, due to lack of supernormal profit, firms do not have the ability to invest in order to innovate.
How realistic is the assumption of a perfectly competitive market?
- Not very realistic, hard to achieve all criteria.
- Closest thing is ForEx markets and commodities.
What are the characteristics of monopolistic competition [5]?
- Many small firms and a low market concentration
- Slightly differentiated goods
- Imperfect knowledge about competitors
- Low entry barriers
- Small price setting powers
What is the diagram for monopolistic competition in the short run?
It is the same as the one for a monopoly
What happens that causes the short-run equilibrium in monopolistic competition to change?
- As with perfect competitoin, the firm cannot maintain supernormal profits as the near perfect knowledge and low barriers to entry allows other firms to enter the market
- This erodes profit away until only normal profit is being made
How are efficiences affected in monopolistic competition?
IN THE LONG-RUN:
- AE: AR > MC because AR is downwards sloping but AR has fallen, meaning it is more allocatively efficient than in the short-run
- PE: Cannot have productive efficiency in the long run, as the AR curve is below the AC
- DE: Harder to fund as profits are eroded but more competition incentives innovation
- XIE: Firms can’t afford any slack as ATC might be loss making
What is the diagram for long-run equilbrium in monopolistic competition?
- AR must be drawn at a tangent to AC directly above MC=MR so there is only normal profits
What are the characteristics of oligopoly?
- A few large firms dominate
- Strong brand loyalty if the good is not able to be differentiated
- High levels of interpendence between firms
- Oligopolies can price set but may decide to collude or price fix
What are the two broad ways in which oligopolies can act?
- They can compete with each other, through pricing strategies or non-price competition
- They can co-operate with each other, colluding on strategies