3.1 Principles of Insurance Law: Statute and Duties Flashcards
What part of CL position on fraudulent claims did IA confirm
Prior legit claims stand - not void ab initio
Prior insurers (case)
Joseph Fielding v Aviva
What is a ‘fortuity’
Event which triggers the policy is uncertain
Three kinds of qualifying breach under IA
Deliberate, reckless or neither
Under CL, what happens if fraudulent claim
Forfeit whole claim, but unclear on if policy continued
Remedy for careless MR under CI(DR)A
Compensatory - what insurer would have done if had answered truthfully
If fraudulent device does not improve entitlement to payout, this does not taint the claim (case)
Versloot v HDI
Does DoUGF under 17 MIA still apply under IA?
Yes
Is it necessary, to breach 20 MIA, that D be asked a Q to which they gave material rep, or actually answer?
No - D can volunteer MR or omit answer
What part of IA can no party contract out of
Basis of C clause
Form of CoI usually
Written
How many material terms are there for CoI
4
How is a company deemed to have knowledge of circumstances under IA
Imputed knowledge (4(3))
Before when does MIA apply
12/08/2016
Channell J in Prudential v IRC - what did he give?
Definition of CoI
3 points DoUGF (case)
The Star Sea
Castellain v Preston key
N/A profit
Two ways for insurer to accept insurance offer of insured
Accept premium or stamp slip
When can insurer keep premium for breach of DoUGF under 17 MIA
If fraudulent non-disclosure
From when does IA apply
12/08/2016
Three ways in which CoI may be illegal
No insurable interest, achieves illegal purpose or subject matter is illegal
What is an insurable interest
Ensures that individual suffers loss to claim - if no, void
Collateral lie (Case)
Versloot
17 MIA codifies what
Duty of utmost GF
From when do you judge materiality for MIA, and under what case
At time of placement, per Brotherton v Aseguradora
What case suggested position is the same for fraudulent claims at CL or under IA
Versloot
When is there no O to disclose material circumstances under 18 MIA
If known by insurer, common knowledge, insurer waived, decreases risk, or conviction spent
What is FMR
Statement knowingly or recklessly made
Is there a specific definition of CoI?
No
When is there doubt on right to void ab initio under 17 MIA
Where there has been a post-contractual breach
What is the remedy for NEITHER deliberate NOR reckless breach of DoFP under IA
What insurer would have done + return premium
What is there an O to disclose under MIA, and under what provision
All material circumstances, 18 MIA
What provision shows that insured needs an insurable interest - suffer loss or policy is void
4 MIA
Can you contract out of CI(DR)A?
No
What is the duty of reasonable care adjudged by
Standard of reasonable consumer (s.3)
How is the duty of fair presentation split under s.3 IA
Disclosing every material circumstance, OR putting insurer on notice
What is the ‘Sum Insured’
Max possible to recover
What is the two limb test for ‘material’ under MIA
Objective and subjective
4 MIA
Shows that insured needs an insurable interest - suffer loss or policy is void
Can you contract out of IA?
Yes
Can you ever avoid ab initio for fraudulent claim?
No - only if fraud at inception
Where is definition of ‘materiality’ under IA
7(3)
The Star Sea key
3 points DoUGF + post-C MF
Remedy for honest + reasonable MR by consumer under CI(DR)A
Insurer must pay claim
Four peculiarities to CoI for C to come into existence
An ‘insurable interest’, utmost good faith, ‘fortuity’ and condition v. warranty
What part of IA shows that, for knowledge, insured cannot turn blind eye
6(1)
Three kinds of MR
Fraudulent, negligent or innocent
What duty was abolished under CI(DR)A, in terms of what insured must disclose
No duty to volunteer material facts (S.2)
What is ‘materiality’ under IA
Affecting judgment of prudent UW, but unlikely to have subjective limb
Joseph Fielding v Aviva
Must disclose failure to disclose conviction to prior insurers even if now spent
Does it matter (for there to be binding CoI) if policy has been issued or not
No
How many elements make up DoUGF
Two