3. Pretrial Motions Flashcards
What are the types of pleadings?
- complaints
- answers to complaints
- answers to counterclaims
- answers to cross-claims
- third-party complaints
- answers to third-party complaints
- replies to answers, if ordered by the court
This list outlines the various forms of pleadings recognized in legal proceedings.
What are the three requirements of a pleading?
- short and plain statement of the grounds for the court’s jurisdiction
- short and plain statement of the claim showing entitlement to relief
- demand for the relief sought
What is required for a ‘Short and Plain Statement of the Claim’ in a pleading?
A complaint must contain enough factual detail to suggest a plausible claim for relief, not just the mere possibility of unlawful behavior by the defendant.
True or False: A pleading may make inconsistent claims or defenses.
True
The court allows inconsistent pleadings to be determined by the trier of facts.
What is the rule regarding technical defects in pleadings?
Courts are directed to ignore technical defects in pleadings, if NO substantial right of the parties is prejudiced.
This rule aims to ensure that cases are decided on their merits rather than on procedural technicalities.
List five special matters that must be pleaded with particularity and underlying facts.
- capacity or authority to sue
- fraud, mistake, or condition of the mind
- conditions precedent, when denying that the condition has occurred
- time and place, when testing sufficiency
- special damages
These matters require detailed pleading to avoid ambiguity.
What is an answer in responsive pleading?
An answer is a pleading in which the responding party admits or denies the opposing party’s allegations and lists any defenses.
What are the five kinds of denials in federal practice?
- general denial
- specific denial
- qualified denial
- denial based on lack of knowledge
- denial based on information and belief
What is a general denial?
A general denial is appropriate only when the responding party intends in good faith to deny all the allegations in the pleading.
What is a specific denial?
The defendant may deny the allegations of a specific paragraph or averment of the complaint
what is a qualified denial?
The defendant may deny a particular portion of a particular allegation.
Rule 11 and Answers
Rule 11 ensures that when the defendant’s lawyer signs the answer, any denials are “warranted on the evidence, or if specifically so identified, are reasonably based on belief or a lack of information.”
The “reasonable inquiry” requirement aims to prevent the defendant’s attorney from:
i.) denying allegations that he KNOWS to be truthful; and
ii.) from denying knowledge or information about the allegation if he knows it to be truthful.
Affirmative defense
An affirmative defense is a defense that relies on factual issues not presented in the complaint. It does not necessarily deny the allegations of the complaint, but pleads additional facts.
A defendant waives an affirmative defense if he does NOT raise it in his _______ responsive pleading.
first
Affirmative Defenses that MUST be pleaded in the FIRST responsive pleading
- accord and satisfaction;
- arbitration and award;
- assumption of risk;
- contributory negligence;
- duress;
- estoppel;
- failure of consideration;
- fraud;
- illegality;
- injury by fellow servant;
- laches;
- licenses;
- payment;
- release;
- res judicata;
- Statute of Frauds;
- statute of limitations; and
- waiver.
What are the three types of pre-answer motions?
- motion to dismiss
- motion for a more definite statement
- motion to strike
Seven types of objections that may be raised either by a pre-answer motion to dismiss or responsive pleading
i.) lack of subject-matter jurisdiction; (can be raised at ANY time)
ii.) lack of personal jurisdiction; (MUST raise in FIRST pleading)
iii.) improper venue; (MUST raise in first pleading)
iv.) insufficient process; (MUST raise in first pleading)
v.) insufficient service of process; (MUST raise in first pleading)
vi.) failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted (can raise up until trial); and
vii.) failure to join a party under Rule 19. (can raise up until trial)
Rule for Multiple Pre-Answer Motions
What is not allowed?
A pre-answer motion may be joined with any other motion allowed by the rule.
Not Allowed:
a party that makes a motion under this rule MUST NOT make another motion under this rule raising a defense or objection that was available to the party but omitted from its earlier motion.
What is the timing rule for filing an answer or pre-answer motion?
Must be filed within 21 days of service of process.
The 21-day period does NOT include the date of service but DOES include weekends and holidays.
If the 21st day is on a weekend or a holiday, the answer must be filed on the next business day.
Timing for when Defendant must file an answer after pre-motion to dismiss was DENIED
If the defendant responds to plaintiff’s complaint by filing a pre-answer motion that is denied, the defendant MUST then file an answer within 14 days of the denial.
what is rule for amended pleadings?
A party may amend a pleading ONCE as a matter of course if the amendment is filed:
i.) within 21 days of service of the original pleading; or
ii.) if the pleading requires a response:
within 21 days after service of a responsive pleading; or
21 days after service of a motion to dismiss, a motion for a more definite statement, or a motion to strike, whichever is earlier.
Party Amending AFTER pleading ONCE as a matter of course
a pleading may be amended by:
i.) the written consent of the opposing party; or
ii.) with the leave of the court.
What is the rule for Leave to Amend a Pleading?
Leave to amend a pleading should be DENIED only if…
Leave to amend must be freely given when justice requires. In deciding whether to grant a request to amend, the court will consider:
i.) the reason for the delay in raising the matter to be raised by the amendment; and
ii.) the prejudice to the opposing party caused by the delay.
leave to amend a pleading should be DENIED only if it would cause actual prejudice to the other party.
A party’s objection at trial to evidence as not being within the scope of the issues raised in the pleadings
The court may permit the pleadings to be amended to conform to the evidence.