3) Peace and Conflict Flashcards
3.1 Causes of conflict
-politics
-culture
-resources
-religion
-history
3.1 Current areas of conflict
-Syrian refugee crisis
-Ukraine war
-Taliban in Afganistan
3.1 United Nations
-UN peacekeepers - protect civilians, strengthen security, sent to conflict areas to observe a ceasefire and keep enemies apart
-protect human rights
-deliver humanitarian aid
-uphold international law
3.1 3 Christian arguments against conflict
Life is sacred, there should be no war
-sanctity of life - imago dei
-ten commandments - ‘thou shall not murder’
Should not participate in war - Jesus’ teachings
-‘if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also’ - Sermon on the Mount
-‘love your enemies’
-when Jesus is about to be arrested, one of His disciples tries to defend Him and cuts off an ear of the servant of the high priest (Jesus heals the man, should forgive people)
3.1 Christian arguments for conflict
To help people in war
-righteous anger - using one’s anger in a way that is thoughtful and controlled to bring justice/ protect the weak - Jesus at the temple
-‘Defend the rights of the poor and orphans, be fair to the needy and helpless’ (Psalm)
-Pope Benedict XVI said defending oneself and others is a duty
3.1 Passive resistance
Opposition to a government or to specific governmental laws by the use of noncooperation and other nonviolent methods, as economic boycotts and protest marches.
3.1 The Just War Theory
First developed by St Thomas Aquinas. Conditions which to judge whether and how a war should be waged
-Jus ad bellum - before war
-Jus in bello - during war
-Jus post bellum - after war
3.1 A Just War
Declared for right and noble reasons and fought in a certain way
3.1 Jus ad bellum
Before war
-war must be started by the proper authority (state, ruler)
-war must have a just cause
-everything must be done to make sure good instead of evil results from the war
Catholic church added:
-war must be the last resort
-force used is no more than necessary to win
3.1 Jus in bello
During war
-civilians should not be harmed
-appropriate force used only
-internationally agreed conventions regulating war must be obeyed
3.1 Jus post bellum
After war
-punishing war criminals
-help retrain military in a defeated country where a bad government has been defeated
3.1 Holy War
War where religion is a driving force
Usually has three elements
-an achievement of a religious goal
-authorized by a religious leader
-spiritual reward for those who take part
Started by a lawful authority
-the church
-often God, gave direct instructions to people to wage war in the Bible
-e.g. the Crusades
3.1 The Crusades
Lasted from 1095 until 1291. Aim was to capture the sacred places in the Holy Land from the Muslims who lived there
-capture Jerusalem - residents brutalised and slaughtered
-breaches just war ethics
3.2 3 Arguments for pacifism
-10 commandments
-Jesus taught to not be violent and for peace
-Should peacefully resist instead of violence
3.2 For pacifism - 10 commandments
‘Thou shall not kill’ - sanctity of life
3.2 For pacifism - Jesus taught to not be violent and for peace
-Jesus said ‘Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God’ (Matthew)
-should not only be violent, but create peace
-emulate God’s nature to be creative (imago dei)
3.2 For pacifism - Should peacefully resist instead of violence
Jesus teaches ‘if anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also’
-should show defiance instead of submission
Christian leader examples - Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks
-peaceful protests
Palm Sunday - Jesus entering Jerusalem riding on a donkey to a huge crowd
-in biblical times, the donkey was a sign of peace
-some theologians speculate this act was to provoke the Romans by highlighting Jesus’ popularity - sent a message without violence
-few days before his cruxificion
3.2 Arguments against pacifism
-Righteous anger
-defending the weak
-conscience - Bishop Butler
3.2 Against pacifism - righteous anger
Jesus had a rage in the temple, ‘You have turned my Father’s house into a den of thieves
-he was violent as he was angry at people’s sinful behaviour- this is justified violence
-situation ethics - loving action used for violence
3.2 Pacifism - defending the weak
Christians are taught to care for the weak, protect the marginalized, take action
-Jesus gave sight to the blind, touched the leper, healed the sick - peaceful actions
-Against - these cannot happen effectively without violence and protection for the weak
3.2 Against pacifism - conscience
Bishop Butler - he said we must listen to our conscience as it is the word of God within
-He might call us to violence
3.2 Restorative justice
Process where a criminal and a victim talk to allow forgiveness, understanding and reconciliation in the relationship
-time for the criminal to reflect on their crime
-allows victim to gain understanding and closure about the incident
-restorativejustic.org - 85% of people involved says it helped
-reduces reoffending by half
3.2 Benefits of restorative justice
God is immutable and distant. He can only persuade us to follow him, not force us to
-when forgiving people, we are following the word of God
3.3 Christian view of bullying
-duty of Christians to protect the weak
-humans are created imago dei
-using violence without a just cause - sinful