2201 Flashcards
Salmond
Legal persons are artificial creations of the law
Anyone capable of rights/duties
Kocourek
Legal persons are the sum total of legal relationships.
Personhood if able to attract legal relations
Kelsen
Legal person is total fiction/construct
Unity of complex obligations and rights
Tur
Legal person is a grouping of rights/duties whose content depends on demographic
Davies and N
Legal persons = groupings of rights/duties
Exact nature depends on demographic
Gregson v Gilbert (ZONG)
Fight over whether or not killed slaves should be covered by insurance.
Killed = insured; Death by natural causes = uninsured
Won at trial
Mullick v Mullick
One son wanted to take a family Idol as personal property
Courts established the idol belonged to the god and the sons were simply the guardians of the idol on behalf of the god
Ram Janikee Deities v Bihar
Two deities held land under 1 Shebait
Tax issue, 1 or 2 estates? (tax breaks at stake)
Ruled each idol was a separate person
Dhanbad
Ram/Monkey temples have small plot between
Parishoners claim it for each other, priest claims it is his
Waiting for gods to appear
Somersett’s Case
Somersett escaped to England
Recaptured by owners, Englishmen demanded his return
Was returned since no slaves exist in Britain
Blackstone’s Absolute Rights
Personal Security
Liberty
Property
Quong Wing
Chino-Brit wanted to hire white watiresses
Saskatchewan banned Chinese hiring white girls
Against: Hire others, Always Chinese, protects white girls, within provincial legislation
Favour: British citizen, discriminatory (criminal fine), against “Settle the west”
Fitzgerald: Agreed with against
Davies: Against because of jurisdiction
Idlington: Basically slavery
Irene Davis Desmond
Biracial Nova Scotian thrown in jail for 1 cent of tax evasion.
Was resisting racist policy at a movie theater segregating seats.
2010: full, posthumous, pardon
De Soto
Apple
Ownership by consensus
Creates obligation towards community
Blackstone and Property
One man claims exclusive rights over something
Hohfeld
Bundle of legal rights/obligations
Bentham
Property is dependent on law to enforce it’s existence
Shelly v Kraemer
Black Shellys bought a house, Kraemer sued them to move because of a no-black covenant
Lower courts upheld it (private agreement)
Supreme courts said it deprived her of her property
Right to buy land
Noble & Wolf vs Alley Pine …
Covenant to ban non non-jew whites
Thrown out because “blood” clause too vague
Nakhuda vs Story Book Farm
Lost monkey Darwin Farms adopter her, Nakhuda wanted back Animal was wild = possesor is owner Signed over rights Lack of papers Farms kept Darwin
Canada Business Corporations Act S15
Corps = Natural person
Interpretation Act 1985
Man = woman + man + corp (and vice versa)
Grants a bunch of rights to corps
Name, seal, perpetual inheritance, sue, property
Blackstone’s Corporations
Guilds, Churches, Universities
Dartmouth College
Possess only property outlined in Charter of Incoproation
Sue/sued, contract, aquire/despose property
Immortal
Salomon V A Salomon Ltd
Salomon created a corp (with family), bought business from self (overpriced), went into debt, went bankrupt
Trial/Appeal: Corps was BS and just a way to avoid liability. He has to pay back his debtors
House of Lords: Corps are corps, overturn.
Significance: Made corps people, 1 man corps, shares confirmed property,
Hobby Lobby
5:4 to allow religious beliefs of owners deny BC
Pierced corporate veil and allowed owners to be business
Dissent: Corps only care about business